3 ms·
I think the latter two cases are different because it ultimately comes down to property rights; (b) may be harder to reverse but if you can do it, you still own
by userbinator 5y ago
I think the latter two cases are different because it ultimately comes down to property rights; (b) may be harder to reverse but if you can do it, you still own it (remember the AMD pencil mod? https://www.overclockersclub.com/guides/tbird/ https://www.overclockersclub.com/guides/tbird/) (c) is, being a software decision and thus tied to licensing and such, feels more like "you can't use the hardware because we said so", and that arguably is what people hate. It's a slippery slope in the same direction as the "you will own nothing" movement.
Of course there's a slippery slope to a hardware-as-a-service pay-us-x-per-unit-time-or-we-turn-off-your-CPU, but with competition from AMD on x86 and in-house ARM chips from Apple and hyper-scalers, one would think Intel wouldn't want to make their product even _less_ attractive.
...and what makes you think AMD and others are not going to try the same thing?
- inter_netuser 5y agoisn't ARM a commodity market? seems to require a lot of coordination from the entire industry.
- gruez 5y ago>is, being a software decision and thus tied to licensing and such, feels more like "you can't use the hardware because we said so", and that arguably is what people hate. It's a slippery slope in the same direction as the "you will own nothing" movement. SaaS offerings doesn't seem to gather the same type of hate though? When was the last time people were outraged that the "basic" tier lacked features in the "premium" tier, even though the code for implementing such feature is literally on the same server and gated behind an if statement?
- userbinator 5y agoWith SaaS, it's pretty clear that you don't own anything.
- kristjansson 5y ago> ...and what makes you think AMD and others are not going to try the same thing? Overwhelming competitive pressure? AMD and Intel may be a duopoly on x86 parts, but Apple Silicon has proved, and AWS Graviton has a strong argument, that consumer and cloud compute workloads can transition to ARM. Any attempt by Intel to leverage its market position just accelerates that transition to substitutes.