3 ms·
Your numbers do not check out. >Child support: The minimum guideline is 33% of income for a single child, non-deductible. Where are you getting the 33% figure
by gruez 5y ago
Your numbers do not check out.
>Child support: The minimum guideline is 33% of income for a single child, non-deductible.
Where are you getting the 33% figure from? Using the figures from https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cost_of_raising_a_child https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cost_of_raising_a_child, see that for the $59,410 to $102,870 before tax income group (Average = $79,940), the average spent per year is 13,050, or 16.3% pre-tax. The percentages for the Less than $59,410 and More than $102,870 groups are 24.7% and 12.0% respectively, which suggests that as your income goes up, the percentage devoted to rasing a child goes down.
> US/CA taxes take ~55%, so that leaves 12%. If you have a great tech salary of $150k,
How are you getting 55%? According to https://smartasset.com/taxes/california-tax-calculator https://smartasset.com/taxes/california-tax-calculator, at $150k salary, your effective rate is 32.3% and your marginal rate is 34.75%. This includes FICA. Playing around with the numbers, even a salary of $500k, your marginal rate is only 48.65%.
>that leaves you with a living budget of $1500/mo.
Using the numbers from the sources I've mentioned, you actually have a budget of $6287, and that's with 2 children.
gross income: $150,000
take home (includes federal, FICA, state): $101,545
cost of 2 children: (234,900 / 18) * 2 = 26100
remaining: $75,445/yr, or $6287/month
- jl2718 5y agoThat’s my point actually. Court-ordered child support payment minimums are massively greater than actual costs. Any by the way, even those USDA costs are ridiculously inflated. It’s based on survey data, not actual expenditures, and the people they ask have every reason to inflate the numbers (child support, welfare, tax credits, deductions, etc.). It’s mostly childcare and housing costs, but even the other categories are ridiculous, like hundreds a month per child on clothing and books. Come on. So far, I’ve gotten almost everything second-hand for almost nothing, and my son does just fine in a garage apartment with me.
- dionidium 5y agoRegarding your first rebuttal: you're agree with the person you're responding to that it costs far less than 33% of a middle- or upper-middle-class salary to raise a child. The argument is that the courts demand child support payments from non-custodial parents far in excess of the actual cost of raising the child.