4 ms·
Why do you call copyleft "tyranny"? If overnight, every single piece of open source software were somehow magically relicensed to AGPLv3 only, would there be an
by josephcsible 5y ago
Why do you call copyleft "tyranny"? If overnight, every single piece of open source software were somehow magically relicensed to AGPLv3 only, would there be any negative consequences at all for anyone besides people who wanted to write non-free software?
- ajkjk 5y ago> besides people who wanted to write non-free software? Would there be any negative consequences besides the negative consequences? No, I guess not. Lots of people want to write non-free software, for instance for their jobs or businesses or hobbies.
- josephcsible 5y agoBut users can do even less with non-free software than they can with copyleft software, so calling the latter "tyranny" while simultaneously being okay with the former makes no sense at all.
- ajkjk 5y agoIt really doesn't. You're pretending like non-free software has no value and that's clearly nonsense. There's no argument with that pretense because it has no bearing in reality.
- josephcsible 5y ago> You're pretending like non-free software has no value I'm not saying it has no value or that it should all go away. I'm saying that its value doesn't come from being non-free, so it would be better if it had to be free instead.
- chrismsimpson 5y agoBlah, blah. Straw man, straw man. Typical HN comment. Copyleft is religious zealotry I can do without.