3 ms·
8086 was inelegant from the beginning. PDP-11 was elegant. It could have had a better chance. OTOH PDP-11 was very heavily invested in operating directly in RA
by nine_k 5y ago
8086 was inelegant from the beginning. PDP-11 was elegant. It could have had a better chance.
OTOH PDP-11 was very heavily invested in operating directly in RAM; a lot of commands could operate on RAM, and MOV could even have two indirect RAM operands (registers have address of addresses of the operands). Considering the memory wall we've started to hit like 20 years ago, such an architecture would have a rather hard time competing with RISC.
- addaon 5y agoWould it, or would we have had a convention in later versions that the low N words of the memory map actually refer to registers? This would not resolve the instruction size issues of a memory-to-memory encoding, but it would give two paths to register file growth (growing the number of architectural registers by increasing N as the architecture evolves; and the usual register renaming games), both of which would be software-compatible with previous versions. Having eight named registers and 256 -- or 4096 -- numbered fast registers, plus renaming on top of that, actually seems like an interesting path.