6 ms·
I think Honda got this exactly right, at least in my 2018 car. There is a touchscreen that controls everything, but also physical knobs and buttons for the imp
by jedberg 5y ago
I think Honda got this exactly right, at least in my 2018 car. There is a touchscreen that controls everything, but also physical knobs and buttons for the important stuff you'd want to control while keep your eyes on the road (radio volume, A/C, radio frequency, seat heaters, transmission gear, etc). If you want more detail and more options, you can go to the touchscreen, but if you just need the basics, you can do it without looking down.
- masklinn 5y agoRecently rented a small-ish Ford (a Puma) which had physical control for almost everything you'd want to adjust while driving, though the touchscreen was pretty crap (and didn't duplicate most of the physical controls, which I didn't mind). Also it had one of those infuriating pseudo-analog control wheels, where you can keep spinning and spinning the wheel with no effect once it reaches either end of its selection course (the ones where the selection wraps around is also bad, incidentally, probably worse really), thankfully it was for something of low importance (controlling the regime of the headlamps between off, DRL, standard, and automatic, which has an indicator on the dash).
- stavros 5y agoMy 2014 Mercedes has a clicky wheel/joystick combo with a menu system that doesn't wrap around, and it's excellent. I can always go to any item without looking because I know that 5up and 5left will go to the start of the menu (even if I don't remember which menu item I left it on, though it's almost always the music tab) and then I can navigate with the clicky wheel. No other controls, but very easy to use without looking.
- masklinn 5y ago> My 2014 Mercedes has a clicky wheel/joystick combo with a menu system that doesn't wrap around, and it's excellent. I can always go to any item without looking because I know that 5up and 5left will go to the start of the menu (even if I don't remember which menu item I left it on, though it's almost always the music tab) and then I can navigate with the clicky wheel. Sure for a menu system control it makes complete sense. But the control I was talking about is completely specialised with a discrete number of steps, in that case having a wheel with proper stops is much more convenient. Also I misremembered, the headlamp mode was a wheel but one with proper stops, it was the selector for the ventilation throughput which didn't have stops and would just spin forever. And the modern peugeot I've driven have that for the drive mode selector (e.g. eco / normal / sport / whatever).
- achenatx 5y agomy 2015 honda odyssey is terrible. They have these huge knobs that dont control anything important on the radio. The giant knob only lets you scroll through presets. XM tuning is buried multiple screen taps in, then if you want to manually tune you have to tap up and down, through 100 channels.
- dole 5y agoThe 2018 Honda Pilot’s infotainment system was all touchscreen, they added a physical volume knob back in the 2019 model by demand.
- sickcodebruh 5y agoMy wife and I got the last year of the Civic without a volume knob. I think it was a 2018? Adding to frustration was the temperature control knob right where you’d expect volume to be! Every passenger on a long trip eventually spun this at least once in an effort to control the sound. It was maddening! We sold it back to the dealer less than a year later and got a new CR-V. I won’t say it was one of the most significant reasons but it certainly wasn’t _insignificant_.