10 ms·
Overloaded: Is there simply too much culture?
- DeathArrow 5y agoFor me culture means Michelangelo, Umberto Eco and Shakespeare, not House of Cards, Girls, Squid Game.
- jonsen 5y agoBut are you overloaded?
- scyzoryk_xyz 5y agoPretty sure Umberto Eco would be amused by being placed in that company.
- TickCount 5y agoI absolutely love the show Girls. I loved it so much, I was positively depressed when it ended and I emailed Lena Dunham multiple times to BEG her to revive it. I literally witnessed myself turning into a "fanboy" like I'm 16 again. Normally, if I love something I have reason to consider a "guilty pleasure", I will feel reluctant to publicly say I love it for fear of being judged. But in the case of Girls (and Titanic), I have so often been moved to tears watching them, I have so often experienced the feeling (for me, the mark of great art, because it's the exact same feeling I feel when falling in love) of "death is no longer something to be afraid of because I've just caught a glimpse of something eternal, something that is bound to go on exist forever" - I have so often experienced such feelings watching them, that it's immediately clear to me that it'd be a silly betrayal of my entire being to try and pretend I don't love them. It would be no different from publicly joking about my mom's appearance just to fit in with the cool kids. Have you watched Girls? Yes, it's comedy. Yes it's often silly. But there is so, so much more to it. I'd go so far as to say that anyone who's watched Girls without becoming mesmerised by Lena Dunham by the end, has not really watched the show.
- Kiro 5y agoWow, haven't watched Girls but I'm sure I will after this comment. That's one of the most convincing reviews I've read.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- reginold 5y agoThis definition seems myopic - yes to old/dead white men but excludes women and asians.
- an9n 5y ago> white men But hold on, I thought race was just a social construct? I can't keep up these days.
- YeBanKo 5y agoHow is Shakespeare different or better than let’s say Girls or Squid Game? I think it is exactly what it was, Girls and Squid Game of its time. Michelangelo is definitely out of this world. My favorite of his works is Pietà. Every time I looked at it for half an hour and just could not believe the realism. However, while Renaissance was great foe find arts, there is a lot of mediocrity. We are looking at the best, the rest is forgotten or only enjoyed by narrow group of connoisseurs.
- true_religion 5y agoWell on the one side there are artists (e.g. Shakespeare) and on the other side is art (e.g. Squid Game). I understand their reasoning in that classical auteur style works can be more culturally powerful, especially if they are old enough to serve as an example for their time periods. However, it’d be better to compare Michelangelo to any of the millions of sculptors who lived in the 500 years after him. Shakespeare can be compared to Broadway playwrights or movie screenwriters.
- tgv 5y agoThe problem with calling entertainment low culture is that it cheapens the original concept while still trying to get the same appreciation and respect for it. Perhaps we should forsake the word "culture" and call it "art" again. And no, "House of Cards" is not art.
- yuppie_scum 5y agoFOMO: the article
- gilgoomesh 5y agoEven in 2012, you could have taken a sliver of mainstream media like "vampire fantasy novels" and failed to read everything in a single year. I think the author simply had a narrower view of what was "important". Yes, media is now more accessible and a few key areas (TV in particular) have increased output 3 or 4 fold. But I think its likely that as the author's social circle has grown the author is aware of a greater variety of media that they weren't consuming. Additionally, most people have less time to consume things as they age. These are old problems.
- ehnto 5y agoIt's just one of the costs of individualism. With so much to consume, instant personal choice, and no consistent conduit, there is little chance we have all seen the same stuff. A way around it is explicitly discussing the issue with mates. I keep some close friends who keep in close parity because we all understand that if we don't all play the same game we will end up playing nothing together. Rando internet friends are great but you don't always get that consistency of long term discussion and a deeper relationship. We still reach outside of the group of course, I play other games too, but if X wants to play Sea of Thieves then we all jump in else they won't do the same for you when you want to play your game with them. I think this kind of small scale community building helps a lot, and helps you get the benefits of the internet without the banality of the "all psuedo-anonymous hive mind"
- ericmay 5y agoWhat do you mean by individualism in this context?
- ehnto 5y agoIndividualism in the sense that gives us the framework to find our own paths and explore what we personally want from life in a context that can transcend the immediate communities we live in. One of the downsides is that we don't have to be a big part of those communities anymore, especially with the internet. This results in more fractured cultural diaspora, even amongst people from the same town. I've rarely watched, listened or enjoyed anything my co-workers have because we can select from the near infinite library of the internet. Previously this wasn't an issue even with individualism, because everyone had to watch the same few TV channels and listen to the same few radio stations. I think it's amazing how diverse the world has become, how niche media can be, and how free we all are to explore what we want from life. But that's just one of the costs.
- trabant00 5y agoHow one can misspell "entertainment" as "culture"? And the answer is clearly yes, the west consumes too much of it. The stress leads to distraction gluttony which leads to detachment from the real life which leads to stress as one can hardly navigate efficiently the social hive when his mental picture of it is taken from movies, shows, social media, etc.
- thewakalix 5y agoThe same thing happened to the word "meme". It went from "unit of mimicry and replication" to "funny image macro on social media".
- jonsen 5y agoAre you referring to "entertainment" or "culture" ?
- RajSinghLA 5y agoYour confusion seems to validate the author’s choice of ‘culture.’
- krisoft 5y agoWords gain new meanings. It doesn’t kill the old meanings. From context people understand which meaning one talks about. And for those who haven’t heard of the Dawkinsian memes? Well I guess it wasn’t that succesfull of a meme after all.
- dredmorbius 5y agoIt's kind of awesome how happy accidents like this come to pollute a myriad of word meanings, though many people have absolutely no clue, and simply cannot fathom how eerily words can divest meanings, such that the meat of their importh is utterly changed. Reading this very paragraph a few centuries ago it would have seemed quite silly, with naughty interpretation.
- bryans 5y ago
- _def 5y agoI don't think there can be too much culture. But there's this constant battle about your attention which I consider toxic (because it exploits common human traits)
- terramauthe 5y agoThis reminds me of a Douglas Adams quote - although he was talking about technology, it seems appropriate here also :) “I've come up with a set of rules that describe our reactions to technologies: 1. Anything that is in the world when you’re born is normal and ordinary and is just a natural part of the way the world works. 2. Anything that's invented between when you’re fifteen and thirty-five is new and exciting and revolutionary and you can probably get a career in it. 3. Anything invented after you're thirty-five is against the natural order of things.” ― Douglas Adams, The Salmon of Doubt
- prox 5y agoDouglas Adams has these gems of humor that comes from observing people. I think it’s not far from what does happen on some level.
- reginold 5y agoRelated to this, I wonder how the average age of HN readership has changed over time. My guess is it has shifted towards an older audience continually since the beginning. To that end what new things are "against the order of things" today.
- DoingIsLearning 5y agoI am not sure the age has shifted that much with new users, but I do think that the breath of experts has changed. It shifted from technical ICs and startup entrepreneurs to basically anyone interested in new ideas and good discussion. There are downsides but personally I think it is pretty cool to read the expert opinion of people completely outside my body of knowledge, Farmers, Neurologists, Chemical Engineers, etc.
- ngold 5y agoAt 42 I'm still pretty hip to the fun of change.
- falcolas 5y agoSaid using lingo older than yourself.
- dan-robertson 5y agoThere’s always been a lot of cultural stuff, but the key difference is the reduction of shared culture. 30-50 years ago if you wanted to read enough to contextualise The Waste Land[1] it would require a massive amount of ‘high culture’ from earlier centuries (and not just in English). Nowadays it would still be a huge amount of work though perhaps would not require trips to obscure German libraries. But 30-50 years ago, at least where I live, there were only 3-4 tv channels and a few more radio stations and shows could regularly pull tens of millions of viewers because there was nothing else to watch. The lack of shared culture[2] today means people have less in common. It seems to me that having less in common with people makes them more distant and that there could be negative effects of that. I’ve certainly heard the argument that this reduced shared culture can be connected with the larger political divisions we (feel we) see today. But then 100 years ago when there was no mass shared culture like tv (or maybe there was?) we seemed to not have the same problems, so maybe there is something else at play. [1] I pick this example because the whole thing is referencing many earlier works in one way or another, and it is a concrete thing rather than a field like ‘literature’. [2] I suppose one might claim that tv is not culture because it is too pedestrian. I don’t really think that’s true, but if you just pick your favourite kind of high culture (eg theatre/ballet/classical music/poetry/literary fiction), there would likely have been some tv shows about it and, as there were only a few channels, lots of people outside the small set of people who deeply care about the thing would see those shows. It seems a little more egalitarian to me than what we have today, though I suppose if you are interested in those things it is now very easy and cheap to seek them out online.
- js8 5y agoYou're making an interesting analysis, but it seems to me this "reduction" you talk about is just an illusion that comes from a vastly increased choice (it's much easier to find niche stuff thanks to Internet). And perhaps because we actually long for shared culture, and now see this fragmentation much more clearly, there is a feeling of being overwhelmed by it.
- high_5 5y agoAgreed. The subcultures started this trend in the sixties and now they are accelerating this trend since any subculture can mimic the sense of a shared culture with the closed circles of internet media/social networks. We're building filter bubbles ourselves, having less and less time for understanding, leading to suspicion and in the end conflict with subcultures perceived as threat to our way of living.
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 5y ago"I delight in music that comes to me the old -fashioned way: by people I know telling me about it"
- skissane 5y agoI'm not overloaded by popular culture, I just ignore most of it. I know what I like, and the rest of it I just pay no attention to. Most popular culture I like is stuff from the last few decades of last century (showing my age I suppose), although occasionally something new comes along that appeals to me, but most new things I just ignore. If someone makes a reference to something I don't get, I'll Google the reference, read enough about it to get the point, then move on. It isn't just popular culture. Humanity has multiple civilisations whose literatures go back thousands of years. There is just so much, whether books just published last week or ancient manuscripts, that nobody could ever possibly read it all, everybody has to pick out the parts that interest them and pass over the rest. I'm sure for many people there must be some hidden gems which they would have really enjoyed, except for the fact that they'll live their whole life and never once stumble upon them. Ever since I read The Triumph of Time in high school, my favourite poet has always been Algernon Charles Swinburne. If I had lived in the second half of the 19th century, that would have been rather mainstream, hip and trendy even; in the 21st century, that makes me somewhat idiosyncratic. I don't care. (I also don't care what T. S. Eliot thought about Swinburne, in case anyone wants to bring that up.)
- subpixel 5y agoI've passively ignored most of what is popular culture since high school. Which is to say I'm not hiding under a rock, but I'm not feeling left out if I don't have my finger on the pulse. I _always_ miss some film, tv and music when it's current, but I easily catch up on it years later. Theater is the only cultural genre where you 'use it or lose it', and I accept that bargain. I have learned that expounding on what you don't know makes you sound like an idiot and/or a snob. Boy, it can be very tempting though when people are talking about reality TV empires.
- helsinkiandrew 5y agoI don't know if there's too much - but what I think is good is that we're being exposed to much more culture from other, different, people. Whether it's an American listening to Grime music, or a Netflix viewer watching the Squid Game. The world today lets us see cultures from across time and space much more than the past. Despite the large media companies and global platforms we aren't (or atleast the curious aren't) being fed what curators, journalists or advertisers feel are important.
- djrockstar1 5y agoI feel like this way but not just about entertainment, about everything in general. From one perspective, it's the success of capitalism, such a wide variety of offerings that there is sure to exist something for everyone, on the other hand, the more options you have, the more wrong options you need to avoid. While having too many options isn't a massive issue for relatively small purchases, if I have a meh lunch or get a car wash that felt lacking, it's no biggie, but for larger purchases it's a bit paralyzing. My headphones broke recently, and it took me a good week and a half to figure out what I wanted to buy. Search filters help, narrowing it a price range, a type (earbuds were what I ended up deciding on), then gaining access to further filters for things like battery life, but even after all of that, I'm still left with 100s of options, and many of the things I care about are qualitative and can't be filtered for, things like sound quality or ear comfort. I've been wanting a new laptop for a while and reaching a decision on that seems like an absolutely daunting task. I agree with the article, there really is too much stuff. We have reviewers and aggregators to help alleviate that, we hope that they can curate the best stuff and we don't have to do the work ourselves. But then, there's too many reviewers and aggregators, so now I feel we need an aggregator for aggregators, a reviewer for reviewers, just to figure out who's being paid off by marketing teams, who's churning out surface level reviews for clicks, and who's actually worth listening to.
- zuminator 5y agoThe author winds up answering "no" to his own question. By thus rendering the entire point of his own article moot, he ironically reveals it to be exactly the type of pointless content that could lead one to question whether we do have too much of it. I think ultimately it says something good about the tremendous wealth of our society that we can afford to support huge industries employing millions to do nothing but create trivial content. Before mass production people would make textiles at home as piecework, but it was grueling, boring work that paid a pittance. In the current age people can make quite a comfortable living creating online content at home, all while themselves consuming podcasts or peeking at TikTok clips.
- high_5 5y agoYes, there is too much meaningless culture which is mere entertainment disguised as culture. But this is just a reality of living: All things are wearisome, more than one can say. The eye never has enough of seeing, nor the ear its fill of hearing. What has been will be again, what has been done will be done again; there is nothing new under the sun. Is there anything of which one can say, “Look! This is something new”? It was here already, long ago; it was here before our time. No one remembers the former generations, and even those yet to come will not be remembered by those who follow them. - Ecclesiastes 1,8-11
- HKH2 5y agoSure, human motivation probably hasn't changed much, if at all.
- thom 5y agoI have some sympathy for a media studies professor who appears to have no option, but I’m baffled why people are watching shows they don’t actually like. You don’t have to keep up with stuff just for the sake of keeping up. I log in to Netflix for weeks on end and see nothing new that appeals to me. Music is more reliable, and I’m incredibly grateful to music recommendation algorithms for finding me at least one new artist a week. I don’t sweat listening to their entire back catalogue and integrating it into some gestalt artistic identity to break out at parties though, I just like knowing it’s all there.
- javajosh 5y agoThere's too much of everything. Over the last 20 years everyone rushed to get everything onto the internet, so it's noisy, messy and can be overwhelming if you aren't careful. Personally, I like to subscribe to Netflix for 30 days a year, catch up on stuff, and then cancel my subscription. Same for Amazon Prime, HBO Max and Disney+. I feel lucky that I never got used to Spotify, because it means I save $11/mo that I can use to buy CDs from artists I know I like (and YouTube/KEXP/KCRW is far better at surfacing excellent music anyway). So I end up with CDs in the car, and listening to Youtube at home. It works. As for TV shows, most of them suck anyway. I blacklist websites that I feel are bad for me using /etc/hosts, but I still consume too much news. I was thinking about this today and how to alleviate it without hiding my head in the sand. Honestly a weekly news magazine like The Economist would probably be enough. Ideally I'd have a tool that lets me react once to a given news item and then track it over time, filtering out repetitive or meta news (especially news about other people's reactions to the news), show me only substantive changes over time, and ideally with a weight that (geometrically) increases with proximity. What is humbling is to realize how easily led we are, how things that seem so important, so vital, end up just...forgotten when the news dies down. It's actually quite scary when you think about it, almost as if your reactions to things aren't quite your own! This tool would help recover that control.
- ngold 5y agoOn the news tip. I do wish there was something like ombudsman for news and tracks it over time.
- balnaphone 5y agoWhat "ombudsman" are yu referring to? Is it a software, or platform? Link? Thanks!
- hdjjhhvvhga 5y agoThe author mistook TV shows for culture.
- nobody9999 5y agoI don't really think there's too much culture. We just live in an era where culture is more widely and easily available than ever before. What's more, since there are many more folks who are able to access more stuff, there's more stuff being produced to capitalize on that as well. And yes, crappy reality TV is culture. As is any creative or interactive endeavor. But, as has been the case pretty much forever, Sturgeon's Law[0] applies to all that culture too. For those of you who don't know (welcome to today's 10,000[1]!) and are too lazy to copy paste the link below, Sturgeon's Law states that: 90% of everything is crap. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sturgeon%27s_law https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sturgeon%27s_law [1] https://xkcd.com/1053/ https://xkcd.com/1053/
- throwaway55421 5y agoThe Guardian aims at a particular kind of person who essentially spends their entire life in artistic theory and not the real world. They derive their worth from being able to quote at each other. For those people I'm sure it does feel like an enormous struggle. If you watch for enjoyment rather than as an attempt at gaining social cachet then it's fine.
- Hokusai 5y agoMaybe you are right, I want to be able to talk and discuss topics with friends and peers. I feel that is hard sometimes to know what others are watching and how it matches my taste. I enjoy as much watching and reading media as I enjoy sharing that experience with others. If you do not enjoy sharing experiences with others, whatever you see is good if you like it. > rather than as an attempt at gaining social cachet then it's fine. At least for me, I do not think that watching iZombie, Dune or Cowboy Bebop makes me look better, but it allows to share good moments with friends. To explain the complete plot of a movie or several episodes from a TV show just for a pun or a quick observations is not what we like. I am ok with you watching just for yourself, but it seems that you do not approve that I or others like to share opinions and talk about media. Why is that?
- throwaway55421 5y agoThere is a difference between what you describe, and "being cultured", which is an attempt to elevate one's self above others. UK class system stuff vs. being in a subculture on a forum. "The" culture, vs some shared interest.
- BLKNSLVR 5y agoAll the stuff from before you were born is curated for you by society. It's pre-filtered, the cruft has been removed and for the first few years of your life you have no control over the filter. Then, as agency is attained, you get increasing exposure to the great unfiltered, and you find hidden treasure and trash and you learn what you actually like and dislike - in preparation for the filter you apply to your own children - which helps to define you, to yourself. Then you get a job, partner, mortgage / rent, kids, and, just the requirements to being able to afford all that goes with that, removes the time required for 'agency' and so you're locked in a fairly tight decade-era of culture for the rest of your life unless you actively choose otherwise; seeking out the alternative, following rabbit holes, opening yourself to the full spectrum of colour that is within surprisingly easy reach, following threads that your natural tendency for the easy path would be to drop. Most of my favourite music that I listen to now is recent. My old favourites are from when I hadn't heard my new favourites. Some of my new favourites are contextual around life stages and activities I hadn't reached or participated in earlier. I missed Mad Men, tried to start it a couple of years ago, realised it's 92 hour-long episodes, and worked out that I didn't have the enthusiasm for it after getting through a few episodes because the combination of my friend-base and entertainment value I was getting from it didn't add up to being worth 92 hours of my time. Recently watched Berserk upon the recommendation of a work colleague. Worth it. Squid game, worth it. For me anyway. Live action Cowboy Bebop, enjoying it a couple of episodes in, will continue. Know when to hold 'em, know when to fold 'em. But first, you gotta know yourself. Listen to music you don't like to better calibrate what you do like. Watch the occasional blockbuster movie to help your appreciation for real film. Can't see, hear, taste, or do it all, find your own channel but make sure to rub up against the edges regularly enough to determine if you need to change channels but didn't realise it yet. Culture is about stories from which life lessons are learnt, and there are a lot more TV shows, movies, and songs than there are life lessons, so as long as you check those edges occasionally, you'll be pretty well covered. The Wire destroyed and rebuilt my view of the world, and work, and government, and leadership and morality. The song King Kong as covered by Tom Waits recalibrated my musical brain (which was already uniquely calibrated by Mr. Bungle in the late 90's), The Mighty Boosh and Rick and Morty have been journeys into imagination like I never dreamed. No. There's not too much culture.
- newsbinator 5y ago> Maintaining my fluency was getting harder and harder: I was a media studies professor who was able to devote hours of my ostensible working day to the task of consuming media. I was still falling far behind, and more so every day. In discussing my struggle to metabolise what felt like a never-ending meal, I’m focusing on television. But television was just part of the larger, overwhelming feast. Around the time television options began to expand, so too did the supply (and our access) to so many other forms of culture, from YouTube to digital mixtapes. In another time and place these would be the insane ramblings of a mad person.
- Mandelmus 5y agoI could well imagine those lines in a dystopian 80s scifi novel right next to Neil Postman’s “Amusing Ourselves to Death” on the shelf.
- kashyapc 5y ago"Too many books" was apparently a problem already 2000 years ago; here's Seneca advising his friend against it, in his letter-2: [quote] Be careful, though, about your reading in many authors and every type of book. It may be that there is something wayward and unstable in it. You must stay with a limited number of writers and be fed by them if you mean to derive anything that will dwell reliably with you. One who is everywhere is nowhere. Those who travel all the time find that they have many places to stay, but no friendships. The same thing necessarily happens to those who do not become intimate with any one author, but let everything rush right through them. [...] 'But I want to read different books at different times,' you say. The person of delicate digestion nibbles at this and that; when the diet is too varied, though, food does not nourish but only upsets the stomach. So read always from authors of proven worth; and if ever you are inclined to turn aside to others, return afterward to the previous ones. Obtain each day some aid against poverty, something against death, and likewise against other calamities. And when you have moved rapidly through many topics, select one to ponder that day and digest. This is what I do as well [...] [/quote]
- BLKNSLVR 5y agoI can't even keep up with Kim Stanley Robinson. He writes 'em faster than I can read 'em.
- bovermyer 5y agoThis is a sentiment that resonates strongly with me. I've tried to keep up with the latest - whether it's books, movies, or programming libraries - and inevitably, I spread my attention too thin and learn too little about too much. Now, I've swung the other direction, and begun really dedicating my attention to a narrow set of things in just about every facet of my life. It's... an interesting difference.
- playpause 5y agoCan you elaborate? I’m interested to know how you’ve done this, and what differences you’ve noticed, good and bad.
- cblconfederate 5y agoNo it s just bad and unremarkable. People are so bored that they re watching reality shows on social media most of the day
- Zababa 5y agoI personally don't feel the need to "keep up" with anything. That may reduce the number of things I can share with strangers I meet, but not that much. When I have a few friends that talk about the same thing for a long time, I tend to take the time to see/read it. Usually I have a good time, and I can talk to them about something that they like a lot. But this is a few movies a year at most. Someone else quoted something from Seneca against reading too many book: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29317420 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29317420. I feel like the deeper I go into something, the more I get from it. Going deeper could be seeing/reading the thing multiple times, talking about it with friends, researching it. It transforms what can be a passive consumption into an active one. I see a lot of videos, explanations or memes that are based on taking way too seriously something. While this is often used as a joke, I feel like there is value in that. I think everything can be used as a lens through which you can perceive the world, if you spend enough time with it.
- wayeq 5y agoWhat a decadent problem to have. Maybe the problem isn't that there is too much shit to stare at, but that we spend too much time staring at shit.
- lcall 5y agoIndeed, we all have to prioritize, based on carefully-chosen values and purpose for life. I linked to some details and previous discussions in a previous cmt: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29266094#29269429 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29266094#29269429
- lcall 5y agoIndeed, we all have to prioritize, based on carefully-chosen values and purpose for life. I linked to some details and previous discussions in a previous cmt: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29266094#29269429 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29266094#29269429 Edit: I think the coach John Wooden said like "The trouble with all the good new books, is they keep us from reading all the good old books." Value and newness are orthogonal. I wrote more about that too, at my web site about maturity models (in profile, then under "life lessons" etc. Nothing for sale.
- cryptodan 5y agoIt's lack of creativity in entertainment. To many reboots of television shows, no new movie topics, dual acting, political correctness, and not wanting to offend people has made entertainment dull. You can never get enough culture.