2 ms·
This kind of reminds me of the cryptocurrency climate change hack. Mining cryptocurrency uses electricity and some electricity currently comes from fossil fuel
by AnthonyMouse 5y ago
This kind of reminds me of the cryptocurrency climate change hack.
Mining cryptocurrency uses electricity and some electricity currently comes from fossil fuels, so that's bad.
In many places the cost of direct heating from fossil fuels (fuel oil or natural gas) is less than using electric heaters, but electric heat is typically lower carbon because grid power is a mix of fossil and non-fossil fuels instead of 100% fossil fuels, and this gets better the more of the grid goes to non-fossil fuels. So switching to electric heat can lower your carbon footprint, but might cost more.
Cryptocurrency mining equipment is effectively an electric space heater that generates revenue. So if you heat your home in the winter using cryptocurrency mining equipment, you turn a profit while lowering your carbon footprint. Or it's carbon neutral free money to anyone already using electric heat.
- chrischen 5y agoI think you have to factor in transmission and conversion loss from converting carbon based fuels to electricity and powerline loss.
- AnthonyMouse 5y agoThen on the other side you also have the lower efficiency of small home furnaces compared to large combined cycle commercial power generation. It's not guaranteed to be less -- if your power grid is 100% coal and you're heating with natural gas, it very well might not be -- but in many/most cases it is. The most obvious winning case being where your power grid is predominantly nuclear, hydro and renewables. If you're in the US they have the breakdown by state here: https://www.nei.org/resources/statistics/state-electricity-generation-fuel-shares https://www.nei.org/resources/statistics/state-electricity-g... Washington, Oregon and Vermont are predominantly hydro. Illinois, New Hampshire and South Carolina are majority nuclear. South Dakota is, surprisingly, >80% hydro and wind. Wyoming is, unsurprisingly, 80% coal.
- pflanze 5y agoElectricity generation efficiency from coal is only 25-50% according to [1]. Heating efficiency of modern home furnaces is typically way above 90% according to [2]. Power transmission efficiency across the power grid is around 94% according to [3]. I'm treating natural gas the same as coal since, while the direct emissions are about half the CO2 per thermal unit produced, its production is much more problematic (esp. emission of methane) [4]. I've taken these numbers and the numbers given at the link you provided and calculated that probably (lacking numbers for the mean efficiency of coal->electricity production) only 10-15 states out of 51 satisfy your claim that heating with electricity (via resistive heating) is making lower use of coal than burning coal locally (as mentioned above I'm treating natural gas as an equivalent). I've put my spreadsheet here [5]. Note that the situation would be much different when using heat pumps instead of resistive heaters. (Aside of the coin generation, cryptocurrency mining rigs are resistive heaters.) [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Coal https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Coal [2] https://www.pickhvac.com/gas-furnace/most-energy-efficient/ https://www.pickhvac.com/gas-furnace/most-energy-efficient/ [3] https://www.ceicdata.com/en/united-states/energy-production-and-consumption/us-electric-power-transmission-and-distribution-losses--of-output https://www.ceicdata.com/en/united-states/energy-production-... [4] https://group.met.com/fyouture/natural-gas-vs-coal/66 https://group.met.com/fyouture/natural-gas-vs-coal/66 [5] http://christianjaeger.ch/electricity_production_in_the_US.ods http://christianjaeger.ch/electricity_production_in_the_US.o...
- AnthonyMouse 5y ago> Electricity generation efficiency from coal is only 25-50% according to [1]. 25% efficient generation is from ancient garbage that has largely already been retired because it's uneconomical. Combined cycle turbines have efficiency up to 64%: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Combined_cycle_power_plant https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Combined_cycle_power_plant Power plants in active service are probably around 50% efficient. > Heating efficiency of modern home furnaces is typically way above 90% according to [2]. That number is for the newest highest efficiency furnaces. By comparison you could say that commercial power generation with cogeneration achieves even higher efficiencies, but neither is widely deployed. Existing furnaces are as low as 56% efficient: https://www.energy.gov/energysaver/furnaces-and-boilers https://www.energy.gov/energysaver/furnaces-and-boilers The average for the existing installed base is probably around 80%. Someone evaluating this for personal use might research the efficiency of their own furnace or compare the cost of installing a more efficient one vs. the net cost (possibly net profit) and environmental benefit of heating with electricity generated by rooftop solar. > I'm treating natural gas the same as coal since, while the direct emissions are about half the CO2 per thermal unit produced, its production is much more problematic (esp. emission of methane) [4]. Then you have to count the same thing the other way when you're heating with natural gas. Fuel oil is even worse because it emits more CO2 per unit heat than natural gas and is extracted using the same methane-leaking process. Worse than that, many oil wells capture only the liquid fuel, have no infrastructure for capturing the natural gas and knowingly release it directly to the atmosphere! Assuming your equivalence between coal and natural gas, that commercial power generation and transmission are 47% efficient (50% x 94%) and home furnaces are 80%, the percent non-fossil fuels needed for breakeven with natural gas heat is 41.25%. Some even lower number for oil heat. That's pretty much exactly the existing US average (and thus already ahead in places like California which are at >51%), and is only going to move in one direction as fossil fuels get phased out of the power grid.
- saalweachter 5y agoElectric space heaters are the least efficient way to use electricity to heat a space.
- bitwize 5y agoA variant of this idea suggests that humans evolved sophisticated intelligence -- and a bipedal stance -- as a way to efficiently let off waste heat in the hot tropical environment. Hard for me to believe, but the idea is out there.