3 ms·
From the book of Proverbs (in the Bible): "The wise man gets a lot of advice" (paraphrased). One chapter later: "The fool listens to most of it" (also paraph
by AnimalMuppet 5y ago
From the book of Proverbs (in the Bible): "The wise man gets a lot of advice" (paraphrased).
One chapter later: "The fool listens to most of it" (also paraphrased).
If you don't have the time to sort it all out, don't listen to all the viewpoints. Society, collectively, is insane - it believes so many contradictory things that could not all possibly be true. You can't listen to society or "they say" as a guide. You'll get nonsense.
But part of this is on the news, especially television and internet news. They need a hot take for this hour to draw eyeballs. It doesn't have to make sense, it just has to be new and different. But if you're trying to follow it to learn what to do to protect yourself in the pandemic, it's a hopelessly self-contradictory jumble. People wind up saying "They lied to us! They're still lying to us!" The problem is that "they" - the "they" that the media present to us - is too big a set.
Now, individual experts still can be mistaken, give bad advice, or even lie. But no expert is as confused as the union of all the experts.
- ericjang 5y agoYou don't believe in the "wisdom of the crowds" ?
- AnimalMuppet 5y agoHere is a set of people. On a given subject, the median position is likely to be at least reasonable. That's the "wisdom of the crowds". Here is a set of experts. Within the area of their expertise, the median position is probably pretty close to right. The intersection of their views are almost certainly right (though it may be the empty set). But what you can't do is take the union of the views of a set of people, and expect anything except a bizarre jumble of self-contradiction. And that's what the media gives us. (In fact, the media gives us the union, with extra emphasis added to the outliers, because those are "more interesting" and therefore attract more eyeballs.) Wisdom of the crowds? Maybe. Wisdom of the media coverage of the crowds? No way.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- musingsole 5y agoUnion vs. intersection vs. outlier weighting is a beautiful way to put this.