14 ms·
The plastic surgery and vision correction industries work pretty well in the US. You see price competition and patients have the ability to shop around and mak
by refurb 5y ago
The plastic surgery and vision correction industries work pretty well in the US. You see price competition and patients have the ability to shop around and make choices that are important to them (references from other patients, doctor personality, etc).
Now contrast that with going to a hospital for a procedure where you have time to shop around. Can you get a price? No. Can you easily get appointments with doctors to get their opinions on your case? Maybe. Can you get other patient references? Unlikely (but maybe).
What’s the difference? One insurance covers (thus the patients is cut out of price conversations) and one insurance doesn’t cover (this patient is the end payer). The big problem is more and more costs are being shifted to patients as deductibles and co-insurance, but hospitals treat it like it was 1990 and the patient pays some token amount so “who cares”?
And sure, an emergency doesn’t leave you much time to shop around, but something like 80% of healthcare procedures aren’t emergent.
- helloguillecl 5y agoThe United States leads the way in treatments and medical tech, but this gives me the impression that the US society is not benefiting as it could from that.
- bottled_poe 5y agoThis seems poignant. The cost/benefit analysis does not seem to be aligned with the market. I suspect it’s driven purely by lack of qualified practitioners.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- jac241 5y agoIt's not. Physician reimbursement has been going down year over year since the late 90s. Each unit of physician work (relative value units, RVUs) is worth 50% of what it was in 1998 for Medicare at least, and most insurers peg their reimbursement at a specific multiple of the Medicare rate. Sorry, the insurance companies, PBMs, and hospital administration is to blame for the high cost of care, not the physicians who don't control how much they are reimbursed for each office visit or procedure.
- refurb 5y agoIf that’s true then why have physicians wages continued to increase for most specialties? Some have stagnated, but I wouldn’t say physicians are underpaid.
- texasbigdata 5y agoMedicare and Medicaid are at best 50% of reimbursable amounts in most sub industries. Also, while $/CPT code can go down, you can see more patients/day or alter your staffing ratios and other operating metrics to more than compensate. Healthcare has some of the most "woo woo" hand wave-ey financial metrics around. Do a private equity quality asseatment on quality of earnings on "gross earnings" in most health care settings. Other than the Enron consolidations there can't be a more bullshit financial metric (heck entire area) under US GAAP than gross earnings. With that level of obfuscation (purposefull or not) it's no wonder you have almost full opacity into the cost chain.
- refurb 5y agoAs someone who used to work for a company trying to get insurance to pay for medical technology, the US was typically the easiest and fastest country to get coverage in for both private and public insurance.
- knubie 5y agoReally any healthcare procedure that is not typically covered by insurance has seen costs go down over time. Things like lasik eye surgery, or orthodontics are great examples in addition to the ones you've already mention. The service and technology gets better while the price continues to go down.
- wombatmobile 5y ago> The service and technology gets better while the price continues to go down. What did you think the farmer who was charged $6,589.77 for 6 stitches might have to say about that proposition?
- willcipriano 5y ago"I wish stitches were done on a fee for service model like shooting lasers into people's eyes is."
- JshWright 5y agoThat was still a FFS model. The difference is whether the procedure is typically covered by insurance.
- willcipriano 5y agoI don't see how it's fee for service if nobody can tell you what it's going to cost upfront.
- JshWright 5y agoThe uncertainty comes from not knowing exactly what services will be performed, who will be performing them, and how much the insurance company will cover (which has a ton of variables, many of which aren't known until everything is settled). In my opinion, getting away from the fee for service model is one of the routes we ought to be taking to address healthcare spending in the US (if you're charging per service, you're incentivized to perform as many services as possible in a given encounter).
- LinAGKar 5y ago>What’s the difference? The difference is that one is completely optional and you can spend as much time as you want comparing options, while the other you're forced to do on a whim at whatever place is closest. You can't shop around when you're bleeding out, as in the article. And such emergency health care constitutes most of these surprise bill situations.
- wombatmobile 5y agoYou’re missing two key element of the process - the willingness to exploit, and the lack of alternatives.
- refurb 5y agoBasically what I said in my last paragraph?!?
- Jansen312 5y agoCentralized hospital and clinics in certain locations. Don't allow building healthcare based on maximized spread. When there are multiple alternatives next to each other, it generates not just competition for customers (patients) but also doctors/nurses employments. Also build fully government subsidized hospitals in each of this location to force the private pricing not escalating. Then every hospital admins will need to undergo 6mths IRS audit. This force the job extremely undesirable and reduce the demand for it.
- saiya-jin 5y agoExactly the same situation is in rest of the world, no patient is shopping around. just goes usually to closest/biggest hospital. Yet we don't have this tragic mess US has. So its not about shopping around, rather some other reason like regulations, wrong dynamics between hospitals and insurances etc. You don't have better equipment nor doctors in US compared to biggest hospitals in Switzerland for example. Yet we have fraction of the costs as patients, and its not due to low doctors/staff salaries. Equipment is also top notch everywhere, new machines in all departments.
- refurb 5y agoSwitzerland is #2 in per capita healthcare costs after the US. US is $11k per capita and Switzerland is $7k per capita. Countries like Finland (4.2k) and New Zealand ($4.1k) show Switzerland could be doing way better. Maybe the pot shouldn’t call the kettle black? https://data.oecd.org/healthres/health-spending.htm https://data.oecd.org/healthres/health-spending.htm
- usrusr 5y agoI believe that in the end, it boils down to culture, with all the regulatory dysfunction and market dynamics acting as intermediary. In the US getting wealthy seems to be almost implicitly well respected, no matter how you got there. At least if it's not obviously illegal. You found a tweak to squeeze more money from health insurances? Good for you, let them suffer for their apparent weakness. There's apparently still a threshold of where even success cannot vindicate the way to get there (that Oxycotin family comes to mind) but that threshold is super high. I believe that this threshold is much lower almost everywhere else on earth and that this has an influence on individual decisions on all levels. It doesn't even remotely make people elsewhere angels or something like that, but it's a little bit of friction in every decision towards "take what you can"
- splix 5y agoI believe that "closest/biggest hospital" is a choice in emergency. Or when it's something unimportant. Otherwise people tend to choose a doctor and clinic based on reviews or recommendations, or maybe years of experience. Even with a free healthcare you still have a paid private medicine and a free public one. And they have to compete which leads the price going down, because one side is always zero or close to it. Not like it's in the US where the direction is opposite as you don't have a zero side but only "unbelievable high price" side.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- Retric 5y agoDentistry is paid for by insurance and is relatively cheap either way. Healthcare in the US is expensive for several reasons. Excessive paperwork and bureaucracy, unpaid bills, required service, 24/7/365 services, complex diagnosis, lawsuits, medical school, regulatory capture, etc etc. Changing any one of them isn’t going to fix pricing. We really need to change several pieces at the same time and the industry really doesn’t want lower prices as that reduces their income.
- SamoyedFurFluff 5y agoI’m pretty sure most of this is also what, say, EU has to deal with. They most certainly have bureaucracy, unpaid bills, 24/7/365 services, complex diasnosises…
- Retric 5y agoSingle payer largely avoids unpaid bills and a great deal of bureaucracy around billing. This is true even in the US, just look at the VA’s costs. The VA is serving a very expensive population and it does so relatively cheaply for the US. At least in terms of services rendered rather than just per person. The 24/7 comment was in comparison to dentistry. It’s tempting to compare getting stitches to getting a filling but inherent overheads are associated with an ER which must be added to the bill.
- Symmetry 5y agoSome big differences: Without the equivalent of AMA lobbying Europe has a lot more primary care doctors per capita than the US. No long history of trying to get everyone healthcare without using taxation resulting in a pile of Rude Goldberg regulations that nobody understands. Regular use of cost-benefit analysis in deciding what procedures or drugs to pay for, now that the FDA has approved aducanumab it's going to be available to people even though it probably doesn't work and is breathtakingly expensive.
- hellbannedguy 5y ago1. Plastic surgery, and surgical vision correction, are problems of the wealthy. 2. I have no idea what your point is, or I hope it's not a superficial as it sounds. 3. Most of us have 0 dollars we the big guy comes a calling. 4. I think it's obvious we need a medical system like Canada. (To those premadonna Medical Professional Professionals who don't want to participate fine; print out a shingle and good luck. You might be a wealthy boy one day. My hope is you take no tax payer loans, or apply to public colleges. It will most likely be in Plastic Surgery though. Oh yea--why do we waste precious residences on Plastic Surgeons. And please spare me with the Cleft Lip.) 5. At this point, I'd very happy with disallowing all health professionals from collecting on medical bills. This would overnight lower chapter 7, and 11, bankruptcies. 6. The USA is not the best country anymore, unless you come from wealth. Make sure daddy doesn't secretly hate you though.