10 ms·
I wish there was a coordinated public service campaign around "Hang up, Look up, Call back". I feel like if we could really ingrain those 6 words that it would
by hn_throwaway_99 5y ago
I wish there was a coordinated public service campaign around "Hang up, Look up, Call back". I feel like if we could really ingrain those 6 words that it would go a long way to blocking these types of phishing scams.
Number one thing I tell folks in my security training is to never respond or click a link on an inbound message. Instead, look up your bank or service provider and make an outbound call (or direct URL navigation) to them.
- coderintherye 5y agoThere is, sort of: https://scamspotter.org/ https://scamspotter.org/ Discussed here earlier today: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29278411 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29278411
- JulianK 5y agoI recently heard about an incident where hanging up turned out to be more difficult than it should have been. Stay calm. Call from another phone perhaps? https://bc.ctvnews.ca/beware-of-the-delayed-disconnect-phone-scam-1.5375708 https://bc.ctvnews.ca/beware-of-the-delayed-disconnect-phone...
- david_allison 5y agoDefinitely call from another phone if using a landline. https://security.stackexchange.com/questions/100268/does-hanging-up-on-a-uk-landline-call-not-terminate-the-connection https://security.stackexchange.com/questions/100268/does-han...
- tzs 5y agoIf you don't have another phone would it be safe to first call some other known number and see if that goes through? If it does, then you should be able to infer that the previous inbound call has (probably [1]) hung up, and it is now safe to call your bank. [1] A sophisticated enough scammer could hold the line, give a fake dial tone, detect that the number you are dialing is not the bank number they expected you to dial, dial that number themselves on a different line, and relay between that line and yours to convince you that you really did have a clear line, and then keep holding the line when you then hang up and try to call the bank.
- jamesknelson 5y agoThe issue I imagine here is that calling the bank can be costly both in hold time and in phone fees. If banks were able to remove this disincentive to call by ensuring that their phone lines have zero wait time, and offering to immediately call back to avoid billed-by-the-minute phone charges (or in the case that they already offer this, by making it clear to customers), then I think there’s be a larger uptake of the idea of “hang up, look up, call back”. As it stands, I’d be afraid of needing to wait 30 minutes in hold, and getting billed 30 minutes of call time by the phone company for the privilege. I’m not from the US, so it’s possible that your banks are doing this part better than the local ones, but that’s always the worry with the phone for me.
- tatersolid 5y ago> and getting billed 30 minutes of call time by the phone company for the privilege What bank doesn’t have toll free dialing numbers, and what voice plan in 2021 doesn’t have unlimited voice calling minutes?
- vlovich123 5y agoBanks have 1-800 numbers which are free and generally most phone plans I’m aware of are unmetered by minute
- MattGaiser 5y agoThe person above is not from the USA. Unlimited everything plans aren't even that common in Canada.
- vlovich123 5y agoI was replying to this: > I’m not from the US, so it’s possible that your banks are doing this part better than the local ones, but that’s always the worry with the phone for me. Since the person is asking about what it’s like here I’m providing that perspective. In Canada banks also provide 1800 numbers so it should generally be free. I thought Canada has mostly unlimited plans but I haven’t had a Canadian phone plan in over a decade.
- cbhl 5y agoThe tricky bit is I know some legitimate departments of my bank follow this policy -- so if they make an outbound call to me, they will trust what I say on the phone, but if I hang up and call them back, they will take down my number and call me back later.
- wcarss 5y agounfortunately, trust is a two way street!
- gonehome 5y agoEven worse Morgan Stanley will ask you for two factor codes over the phone(!). It’s impossible to implement good user behavior when the banks themselves are wildly negligent.
- lowercased 5y agoI tried to buy something, but it was a large amount - over my normal usage. I had to call the bank, and they said "we're sending a code to your phone..." and the text message said "DO NOT share this code. We will NEVER call you or text you for it. Code xxxxxx. Reply HELP if you didn't request it." So... they then say "what is the code?" that specifically says "DO NOT share this code". I know what's going on, mostly, but it was still confusing.
- smaccona 5y agoIt’s worth pointing out that if you are not the one initiating the call, then this is a legitimate attack vector, and not just via SMS text message or email two factor but also any type of OTP. The attack goes like this: (1) given that the whole point of two-factor auth is to prevent access to your account in the event that your primary authentication tokens (usually a username and password) are compromised, let’s assume for this attack that a bad actor already knows your username and password. (2) the attacker calls you up and says “this is <your bank>”, then (3) the attacker logs into your account with the username and password they already know (4) this either triggers an email or text message with the second factor, or if you use a hardware token or an app then the code is available there. Either way, the attacker requests you to read back the code over the phone (5) the attacker uses this secondary code to gain access to your account, and can then take any action including changing your password and 2nd factor setup. I think this is the reason security teams set up these messages to say things like “NEVER share this code!” and the like.
- vmception 5y agoUnfortunately financial companies act outside of the best practices that make it impossible for the consumer to distinguish. After being transferred during after hours, American Express asked me for some unnecessary information and I hung up. I called back and got someone different with a local US accent and I told them what I encountered and they said that's normal (facepalm). I called back during normal business hours and the more expected experience occurred.
- tlogan 5y agoStrange. I have American Express and they clearly say: American Express will never call you to ask for your information. Even if some transactions is suspicious they tell me to call them.
- ectopod 5y agoSay "if it's important send me a letter". Hang up. Don't waste your time running round after these idiots.
- jaredsohn 5y agoCan't that be faked in the same way?
- pfortuny 5y agoBut it is much costlier (time, materials, logos…) and a different technique.
- bitreality 5y agoMost cyber criminals have a script. They don't deviate from the script unless they think they have a potential home run. Even then, going from this to sending out fake mail correspondence... That's a whole different toolbox. 99%+ of the time they will not even consider it. Especially since it's not scalable.
- ChrisMarshallNY 5y agoI remember that scammers got in touch with my wife, trying to get personal info. It was fairly elaborate. She got a call from a man that she said had “a golden voice,” followed by official-looking mail correspondence (very quickly, which was suspicious, in itself -it can take many days for my bank to get me correspondence). They had our home phone number, her name (not mine), and address; either through public records, or via a breach (which is why “they didn’t get customer credit card info” is a worthless reassurance). It was “Synchrony Bank,” telling her she was victim of a fraud. I contacted the real Synchrony Bank, and let them know about the fraud. The contacts stopped.
- vishnugupta 5y agoSure it can be faked. But but it'll filter out most of such scams which are "online-only".
- 5y ago
- andrewljohnson 5y agoI just never answer my phone unless you are in my contacts or I suspect I’m due a call from something local. It’s mostly spam. The lesson in these times is don’t answer your phone… the phone companies are completely overrun.
- weaksauce 5y agohas there been a breach of credentials associated with clicking on a link and having firefox or chrome fill in your password saved from the site? i am pretty paranoid but if firefox says it's able to fill in a saved cred from this site i assume it's probably the right site. now i am paranoid enough that i don't do this for sites with a lot of downside like banking or the like... those are a strict "i'm calling the number on the back of the card or lookup the number from their website" kinda things.
- frosted-flakes 5y agoFirefox/Chrome will link the saved credential to the domain name, so unless your bank lost control of its domain name, that's an unlikely attack vector. To be safe you can confirm that you're on the right site by manually looking up the domain name.
- weaksauce 5y agoYeah that I get but I am curious if there is a more subtle hack or technique that would bypass that somehow. like a MitM attack or something more clever.
- lokedhs 5y agoThat would be nice if it worked. I had a call from my bank, and they before the they could even tell me what it was about, they asked me to answer some security questions. When I pointed out out how ridiculous that was, and I asked them to prove their identity first, they didn't even have process for it. Calling back was also impossible since apparently there was no way to get connecter back to the person with whom I was speaking. I was unable to get back in touch with them, and a week later someone else called from the bank trying to do the same, and the same thing happened again. I refused to answer their security questions and they had no way to prove their identity. The next time they called, they didn't ask for the security questions anymore and just got to the point immediately. They have never asked for it since. I wonder if I'm flagged in their database as someone who shouldn't be asked security questions.
- pdonis 5y ago> That would be nice if it worked. It looks like you didn't even try it. In order to do what the GP described, when your bank calls you, you say nothing and answer nothing. You hang up and call back on a number you know. > Calling back was also impossible since apparently there was no way to get connecter back to the person with whom I was speaking. You don't have to. You just ask the bank when you call them back: did someone just call me a little bit ago? What about? If the bank can't answer that question, it's time to find another bank. Any reputable bank will be able to look at your file and see that a call was made to you and what the issue was. > The next time they called, they didn't ask for the security questions anymore and just got to the point immediately. They have never asked for it since. This does not look like success to me. It looks like failure. What your bank should be doing is sending you a message via some known channel--like the message center on their website, where you can see messages for you when you log in--telling you that there is an issue that you need to call them about. If you're giving information to someone who calls you out of the blue and says they're from your bank, you're setting yourself up to be scammed.
- lokedhs 5y ago> It looks like you didn't even try it. In order to do what the GP described, when your bank calls you, you say nothing and answer nothing. You hang up and call back on a number you know. I did do exactly that. I asked them for a reference that I could give when I call back. They couldn't give me that. I then did try to call them back, and said "someone called me about something just now, what was it?" and they were not able to tell me. > If the bank can't answer that question, it's time to find another bank. Thankfully, that's not my normal bank. This was the bank that has by car loan. That's my only interaction with them. It's unlikely I'll have more business with them. > This does not look like success to me. It looks like failure. Absolutely. This along with the other issues suggests that they value convenience over security. Also, this is not a small bank we're talking about. I have never seen issues this bad with other banks, but the problem is that when there are banks that get away with this, that suggests people in general do not make a fuss about it and simply accepts whatever people tell them on the phone. If nothing else, it proves why phone scams work. If the bank didn't even have an answer when I asked them to authenticate themselves, that suggests very few people even ask.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- silvestrov 5y agoYou can hardly teach a large part of the population how to drive a car and use the indicators when switching lanes. How can you expect to be able to teach them security processes? The only working approach would be to make a law that phone companies must ensure that caller numbers cannot be spoofed in any way and make them responsible for loses due to spoofed numbers. And require that banks publish which phone numbers they call customers from (like spf is for email), and do so in a format that mobiles can use. So the mobile can show the customer "this is really your bank" or "unknown caller".
- makeitdouble 5y agoI think it will work way better when companies will plain stop calling customers at all. As it stands now I receive ‘legitimate’ calls from a credit card company to open new options on my account. Or from my phone company to switch my plan. And the interesting part is that as it is ultimately to improve the caller’s monthly numbers, they won’t offer the same conditions online or through mail, I tried. And calling back the same person is a royal PITA. So in some cases, it costs me to not deal with transactions on the phone, inbound, from a person I need to trust to be what they say they are.