3 ms·
This had a mirror situation in the East. Korolev was a genius engineer. He was also a workaholic who would not relent until he got first class components for h
by inglor_cz 5y ago
This had a mirror situation in the East.
Korolev was a genius engineer. He was also a workaholic who would not relent until he got first class components for his rockets, even if it involved bitter fights with ossified Soviet industry.
When he died, his peers Glushko and Chelomei could not really replace him. After Korolev's death, innovation in Soviet space program slowed down and they lost the edge.
- panick21_ 5y agoThat's not quite fair. In the East there were actually many different streams of development. And the Soviet space program didn't really slow down. They would continue to make great engines and launch great rockets. In no way can it be said that they lost 'the edge'. What failed was the moon program, but its not at all clear that Korolev being alive would have changed that. The Soviet still ended up building the second most powerful rocket ever. They built engines that were way better then anything the US did (RS-25 might be the exception but it was outrageously expensive). The Soviets also built pretty cool nuclear engines as well. In the 90s US engineers went over to Russia and literally didn't believe the engine specs they were being told. Some of the things they did was considered impossible in the West. Keep your eye on the 'Everyday Astronaut' channel on Youtube. He will soon release an insane 1.5h video about Soviet rocket engines. Its insanely detailed and long and well researched. I was able to see it because of Patreon, but it should be public in a week or two.
- inglor_cz 5y agoWhat was unique about Korolev was the fact that his designs worked almost from scratch and usually did not result in much delay. It wasn't just product of his genius, but of the fact that he was willing to spend hours and hours on the phone with various factories, cajoling and threatening them into shipping the necessary parts in good quality and on time. Generally, the USSR had a major weakness in logistics of industrial products and Korolev was able to overcome it. N-1 was an impressive design, but Korolev's successors were unable to get it to fly, which was a major financial black hole and a source of embarassment for the USSR. To be honest, we do not know if Korolev could make it fly either. The design was very revolutionary, a lot of engines firing at once. Soviet engines were absolutely great. But development of the launchers as such slowed down significantly after Korolev's death. As one of the examples of losing the edge: Soviet attempt at building a space shuttle was almost ten years delayed compared to the American one.
- panick21_ 5y agoInteresting, I have not read to much about Korolev day to day. What the best thing to read? They should have never attempted to build the Shuttle. I mean as far as I know they started to copy it pretty late in the game. In my opinion the US could have been far ahead overall, but they decide to drop every aspect of Apollo. The should have continued with the Saturn 1B and the Apollo stack.
- inglor_cz 5y agoI am afraid my sources are Czech, for example, Konstruktéři raketového věku by Karel Pacner and a lot of articles by the same author. Pacner was our top rocket journalist, he had a lot of sources in Russia. Unfortunately he died this February. Quality was a recurring problem in industrial production east of the Iron Curtain. I was born in an industrial city as well (Ostrava) and it was well known which section of which factory is "good" and which is "bad". People could not be fired for mere incompetence or laziness (as long as they were physically present), because jobs, especially in primary production, were seen as a right. Therefore, getting a good and reliable team together and getting rid of the misfits was a real challenge. In production, quantity was rewarded. Quality did not matter as much. As a result, you had leaking faucets, uneven sheets of metal, crooked nails, weak glue, brittle bricks, shoddy workmanship ... and finding high quality stuff was a problem even for important industries.
- panick21_ 5y agoMakes a lot of sense to me. And tracks with my general reading of history. One example is how much Soviet tankers loved the in the West much mainlined Sherman tank. Soviet tanks loved them because they would just work and you could actually drive it any distance. Its still quite amazing what they managed to do in terms of turbo and nuclear machinery despite those problems. At the other hand, they build all these amazing engines but at the end of the day, they are still launching practical rockets with R-7 derived rockets. Those they actually produce stably in large numbers. While the more complex engines have never been produced in anywhere near those numbers.