3 ms·
If an employee at the bank removes a zero, you can sue them and your bank and get your money back. More likely, it wouldn't come to that, you can contact your
by cogman10 5y ago
If an employee at the bank removes a zero, you can sue them and your bank and get your money back. More likely, it wouldn't come to that, you can contact your bank and get that 0 corrected without legal interference (because they don't WANT to be sued).
If someone steals your coin... That's it. Game over. There's no way to force them to give it back. Assuming they are in the same country as you and you can identify them, then you might be able to start legal proceeding to get your money back, but even then, nothing you can do will force them to return whatever coin they have. If they die, game over, the coin is lost forever and the best you can hope for is their estate has enough value in it to recover the loss.
An error on the side of the bank gives you a clear target for legal action to recover funds, and barring you having more wealth stolen than the bank has value (unlikely), you'll get your money back.
The security of the block chain is both a boon and a curse. It allows the blockchain to operate without a central controller, but it also, by design, makes transactions irreversible.
- camjohnson26 5y agoThe justice system is an external control, I’m saying that blockchain protocols can have value because they provide this security without an external control. That permanence could be a feature or a downside depending on how the protocol is used.
- cogman10 5y agoAnd I'm pointing out the downside. External control does not work on the blockchain, which means that when mistakes or theft happen, there's no mechanism to undo. It's a pretty large downside. The only upside I've heard is that you could avoid oppression or government theft. However, I'd contend that a government that would directly rob your bank account isn't exactly going to stop at just that.
- camjohnson26 5y agoWe agree there. The crypto ecosystem seems to be in a massive bubble, and Tether is a blatant fraud that’s contributing to wash trading on the unregulated exchanges, and NFTs are just a scam. But it bothers me when people use those facts to try to say that blockchain technology therefore doesn’t have a valid use case. It does, and proof of work was a monumental invention, but how blockchain ultimately will be used is unclear right now because the industry is so broken.
- Jensson 5y agoI think we should continue to research blockchain and crypto, it is an interesting topic. But when the crypto scam industry is worth many billions then basically every online discussion will be full of people who try to manipulate others to buy into crypto so that their crypto assets would increase in value. So until the scam part dies down it will be impossible to have a fruitful online discussion about it, it will just be a lot of scammers and a lot of defensive people who try to avoid getting scammed.
- fsflover 5y ago> If an employee at the bank removes a zero, you can sue them Only if you live in a democratic country with fair courts.
- cogman10 5y agoFine, if you live in a non-democratic country with no or an unreliable banking system, go nuts with the blockchain. I get the feeling that 99% of blockchain users/proponents aren't in that circumstance.
- fsflover 5y agoYou are probably right. But they help the other 1% by using crypto.
- fsflover 5y agoNot sure why downvotes. If only 1% of people who need it use Bitcoin, it becomes unreliable for them.
- JoachimS 5y agoBut it still doesn't protect the other 1%. An oppresive regime that can steal their money or other physical assets, can also beat, pressure them until they hand over access to their crypto wallet.
- fsflover 5y agoThere are always edge cases, where nothing helps. Fortunately, most countries are not like North Korea and you have some freedom, often enough to use crypto.
- acdha 5y ago… and if you live an abusive or failed state, the blockchain encryption just means that the kidnappers will start running XKCD 538 on you or your family until you give them your password. This is not a problem with a technical solution. Consider also the scale: what percentage of cryptocurrency users live in regimes like that versus the percentage who have functioning courts but are one exploit/phish away from irrecoverably losing all of their cryptocurrency?
- deadw3ight 5y agoBasically the question is: who do you want to rely on/trust more, encryption or the justice system?
- cogman10 5y agoThat's a false equivalence. I have more trust in the correctness of encryption than the reliability of the justice system. HOWEVER, that's not what's at issue with crypto. The issue of crypto is that it's irreversible. It absolutely does exactly what you tell it to do, and no more. But, at the same time, that means that when non-algorithm mistakes or exploits (ransom, cons, etc) happen you have 0 recourse to fix it. There's a reason crypto is the preferred method of wealth transmission for scam artists, hackers, and ransomware.