5 ms·
> Saying that blockchains are less secure than a relational database storage points towards not understanding immutable ledgers with shared state at all. If I
by echelon 5y ago
> Saying that blockchains are less secure than a relational database storage points towards not understanding immutable ledgers with shared state at all.
If I crack your Bitcoin keys, your money is mine. Nobody is going to restore your property.
If I hack into a bank or rob you at an ATM, police will come and get me, and the judicial system will put me in jail.
Crypto is stateless. Lawless. You can't own math. You just have a solution to a problem that you haven't shared with anyone.
And if someone with compute resources cared, they'd take it away from you.
- fsflover 5y agoCrypto simply does not rely on a third party, which is both its advantage and disadvantage.
- echelon 5y agoThis is such a libertarian hyper dream. In this world, unless you live in the wilderness without tools and supplies, everyone depends on others to some degree. Crypto is an attempt to greedily cut others out and play god. The more plebs you convince of your world view, the more powerful you become. Meanwhile you do nothing of value for society. Just waste brilliant minds and power.
- rodiger 5y agoThe point isn't to not depend on anyone else for anything, instead it's to unwind some of the dependency assumptions we've built up over time. Many in the world don't have access to a financial system. If they have internet, now they do (assuming they can find some way to onboard). Beyond that, plenty of financial tools only were accessible to the ultra-rich/institutions. Many of those are now accessible to everyone. May be worth taking a step back to see why brilliant minds are intrigued.
- fivea 5y ago> Many in the world don't have access to a financial system. If they have internet, now they do (assuming they can find some way to onboard). If anyone has access to the internet, they have access to banking services. I mean, there are internet banking services being offered in Burundi and Mozambique, two of the poorest countries in the world.
- bko 5y ago> If I hack into a bank or rob you at an ATM, police will come and get me, and the judicial system will put me in jail. What if the state decides the money in the bank isn't really yours (e.g. civil forfeiture, political dissident, capital controls, etc)
- acdha 5y agoThe same thing as if they decide that you are using your cryptocurrency to evade taxes, child support, launder money, etc.?
- rodiger 5y agoThat doesn't make them "less secure," and there are many ways to improve blockchain wallet security (which is independent of blockchain security) beyond a single point of failure.
- camjohnson26 5y agoBut if an employee at the bank removes a zero from a field in the database and lowers your balance there’s nothing in the protocol to prevent that, external controls have to be added to keep that from happening, like checksums, auditing, and monitoring. Blockchains provide that security in the protocol but of course have other problems. It’s all trade offs and different use cases.
- echelon 5y agoThat bank employee is going to find themselves on a trip to federal prison.
- camjohnson26 5y agoIf they get caught. The point is that blockchains can have value, I don’t know anyone reasonable who doesn’t believe this. Git is technically a blockchain.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- echelon 5y ago> If they get caught. Federal and international regulations require sophisticated bookkeeping and auditing. Banks and fintechs spend billions of dollars on fraud detection and security. Not only is it a matter of protecting their own self interests, but laws and reputation demand it. > The point is that blockchains can have value, I don’t know anyone reasonable who doesn’t believe this. Git is technically a blockchain. Git history doesn't have monetary value. It has practical, functional value.
- camjohnson26 5y agoThe processes you mentioned are external controls, I’m talking about the protocol. For Git, I don’t see how that’s relevant. If things that don’t have monetary value can be secure at the protocol level why shouldn’t money be just as secure.
- fhood 5y agoA relational database can also be stateless and lawless if you try hard enough. But I think that the point that a lack of recourse is inherent to the technologies ideology does ring somewhat true.
- ricardolopes 5y agoBeing lawless is a feature, not a bug. This is why, despite the many apparent flaws, bitcoin usage just keeps on growing with people living under authoritarian regimes, for instance. The money is yours and no government can confiscate it.
- the_af 5y ago> Being lawless is a feature, not a bug Depends on who you ask. Being lawless is not a feature to me, for example. Some of what I think you mean by that I will probably want, but not lawlessness itself.
- 300bps 5y agoThe money is yours and no government can confiscate it. Anyone can confiscate it. Let's say the Government wants your cryptocurrency. You rub your hands together with an evil laugh and say it's protected by a private key that you've memorized! They put you in jail and say you can come out when you hand over the keys to your cryptocurrency. Or it could just be a random person with a plumbing wrench that will happily stop hitting you in the head with it if you give up your private key. Or it could be someone that breaks into your house and steals your wallet's recovery phrase. Or it could be you accidentally sending ETH to a BTC wallet.
- ricardolopes 5y agoThe original argument was that with traditional finance, banks could edit your balance when needed. That can't be done with bitcoin: the protocol won't accept transactions that aren't signed with the owner's private key. The best metaphor is perhaps digital cash. No government can edit the cash in your wallet out of there, but as the owner, you can definitely lose it by force or stupidity.
- hartator 5y ago> The money is yours and no government can confiscate it. Well the FBI owns the largest Bitcoin wallet. And I am pretty sure it's not from mining. Ref: https://steemit.com/bitcoin/@loryon/fbi-is-global-stakeholder-in-cryptocurrency-currently-owns-largest-bitcoin-wallet https://steemit.com/bitcoin/@loryon/fbi-is-global-stakeholde...
- agumonkey 5y agoThe question is, will the cryptoheads accept living by their 'freedom' rules or will they recreate coercitive means of securing assets (with their own memetic flave of course).