3 ms·
> The argument was that getting rid of the informal, localized social norm enforcement mechanisms (your nosy neighbors, a meddlesome priest, etc) that used to p
by naasking 5y ago
> The argument was that getting rid of the informal, localized social norm enforcement mechanisms (your nosy neighbors, a meddlesome priest, etc) that used to prevent people from fully expressing their individuality created a vaccuum that was filled by surveillance.
I'm not clear on why this vacuum must exist and more importantly, why it must be filled.
- jrumbut 5y agoI don't know either.
- Apocryphon 5y agoWe live in a society.
- naasking 5y agoYes, a society ruled by laws. We're not talking about a vacuum of laws.
- Apocryphon 5y agoI think the idea is that the increased size and density of society has led to more complex social structures that prior laws were not able to catch up to. See your sibling comment about the consolidation of populations into cities and the creation of modern policing. Technological advancement also leads to more issues- contrast the multitude of free speech/censorship fights over online content vs. AOL chat rooms having blanket moderator policies two decades ago. As society grows, so does the vacuum created by places the law is hazy on. And so does the number of bad actors, from thieves snatching Amazon packages off doorsteps to jihadist suicide bombers.
- naasking 5y ago> As society grows, so does the vacuum created by places the law is hazy on. And so does the number of bad actors, from thieves snatching Amazon packages off doorsteps to jihadist suicide bombers. I'm pretty sure the law is not hazy one bit on either of those issues. The original claim was that social norms was enforcing some kind of behaviour, and that individualism has eroded those norms thus permitting previously forbidden behaviours, and therefore led to us deploying surveillance to "pick up the slack" to enforce such behaviours. I'm still not clear that those norms were necessarily good, that eroding them was necessarily bad, that all of those behaviours should be forbidden, and that therefore this is why surveillance arose. Presumably, surveillance is used to go after those breaking the law, not those breaking social norms, so this just seems like an elaborate non sequitur.
- Apocryphon 5y agoFrom a less philosophical and more partisan read of the situation, I'm inclined to believe that 9/11 and the subsequent War on Terror gave the premier national government the carte blanche to pursue surveillance, widely supported or tacitly consented by the majority of the populace. And because such surveillance was normalized, large corporations, themselves experiencing several decades of increased free rein thanks to deregulation, also began engaging in profitable surveillance activities. Perhaps this all would not have been so inevitable if we were living under a different sociopolitical climate.