2 ms·
The argument was that getting rid of the informal, localized social norm enforcement mechanisms (your nosy neighbors, a meddlesome priest, etc) that used to pre
by Animats 5y ago
The argument was that getting rid of the informal, localized social norm enforcement mechanisms (your nosy neighbors, a meddlesome priest, etc) that used to prevent people from fully expressing their individuality created a vacuum that was filled by surveillance.
The argument that localized social norm enforcement has disappeared is old, and goes back to the creation of cities. The vacuum was filled long ago by the creation of organized city police departments. Robert Peel, who organized the London police, was explicit about the police as enforcers of social norms. See Robert Peel's principles of policing.
Large scale surveillance is relatively new. Where it fits is an issue, but it's hard to argue it arose out of that old problem.
- jrumbut 5y agoHistorically, the police department in San Francisco enforced very different norms from the police in Amarillo. Now with increased mobility and the distance-collapsing features of the Internet, there is a felt need for norm enforcement at the national or international level. This is where the surveillance comes in. Organizations like the FBI or Interpol chase big norm violators, but they don't touch the stuff that the neighborhood patrolman would tackle (in the Robert Peel view of policing).
- throwaway0a5e 5y ago> but they don't touch the stuff that the neighborhood patrolman would tackle (in the Robert Peel view of policing). Nor should they. But this doesn't stop a bunch of Karens in some gated community in LA from getting their panties in a knot over what some wackos in da yoop are up to and thanks to the internet the former has plenty of stuff streamed right to their iphones in 1080p to get pissed off about. Norms don't generalize to a national level except for very broad norms and very small nations.
- germandiago 5y agoA bunch of Karens hahaha. In Spanish we say "charos". Una panda de charos. Funny hahahaha.