4 ms·
What "large institutions" are good for is preventing norm enforcement. > Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the
by AnthonyMouse 5y ago
What "large institutions" are good for is preventing norm enforcement.
> Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press; or the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the Government for a redress of grievances.
Prohibits the Department of Defense or Department of Education from doing a form of norm enforcement. Prohibits the states of Alabama or California from doing a form of norm enforcement. Good.
Laws prohibiting discrimination on the basis of race/sex/religion/etc.
Prevents the CEOs of Walmart or Apple from doing a form of norm enforcement. Good.
The things done by China or the USSR to people with the wrong ideas. Direct norm enforcement by a large institution. Serious candidate to be the worst thing ever.
- throwawaygh 5y agoOn the other hand, such constraints on large communities can sometimes allow small communities to perform norm enforcement. For example, that same amendment makes it illegal to prevent a church to subjecting gay minors to various forms of norm enforcement. Size seems like a misnomer here.
- AnthonyMouse 5y agoIt makes it unconstitutional for a law to do that. It doesn't stop private citizens from exerting social pressure on churches to not do that, e.g. by shaming them in public.
- throwawaygh 5y ago1. Not always. Small institutions often have totalizing influence, and escaping small communities is often easier said than done. 2. There's nothing stopping private citizens from exerting social pressure on large corporations either. Again, institutional size is a red herring in this conversation. Every argument that small is better than large or vice versa works symmetrically with plenty of real world examples. It's almost like size is a totally orthogonal issue.
- AnthonyMouse 5y agoNo, size matters quite a lot when it's the large institution enforcing norms. If you're openly gay and your church hates gay people, you can stop going to church or go to a different one. The smaller the church is, the easier that is. If you're openly gay and the USSR hates gay people, you're probably gonna get murdered.
- throwawaygh 5y ago> If you're openly gay and your church hates gay people, you can stop going to church or go to a different one. Yes, the difficulty of escaping a norm enforcing institution is an important desiderata. More important than size. The social dynamics of cults are a (politically acceptable) counter-point. Leaving a small and insular community is rarely so trivial. > If you're openly gay and the USSR hates gay people, you're probably gonna get murdered. This conversation started with a discussion of large social media sites and you keep bringing up authoritarian governments to prove "big = bad". Yes, escaping a nation-state is difficult. But if you're on a political extreme and don't like a social media site's speech rules, just don't use that social media site. And deleting a social media account is infinitely easier than abandoning the social group / town where you grew up. So here we are again. This game is becoming a bit silly, so let me unroll an infinitely long thread by providing a template for the next 5,000 replies: you: "X1 is small and X1 is good but X2 is big and X2 is bad." other commenters: "X3 is big and X3 is good but X4 is small and X4 is bad" occasionally: "Nuh-uh X{$n} is not so bad" me: "X5 is small and bad, X6 is big and good, X7 is small and good, X8 is big and bad. It's almost like there are features other than size that better unify toxic norm enforcing communities."