4 ms·
The article never tries to make a direct case for causality. Every time it gets close, it completely ignores any underlying motivation (say authoritarianism).
by mindslight 5y ago
The article never tries to make a direct case for causality. Every time it gets close, it completely ignores any underlying motivation (say authoritarianism). Including such a reference, the article's thesis would be something like since smaller-scale systems of control have been undermined by individualism, authoritarian desires have come to rely on surveillance. Which does not supply that less individualism would cause less surveillance (eg China), despite that being what the article wants to imply.
Modulo that, we're left with a pretty bland idea that as mobility has increased, the desire to know more about newly-met people has increased. Back in the day, a newcomer to town wouldn't be trusted until they had established a reputation. Now you can fly across the country and open a bank account on the same day. I don't particularly enjoy having global identification and surveillance databases like that. But it's hard to ascribe this to individualism per se as opposed to the ease of travel regardless of the strength of communities you're traveling between. We don't attribute the adoption of time zones as a consequence of individual communities failing to keep their "local time", but rather the need for consistency across a wider area caused by train travel.
Flipping the script can be useful to discover blindspots in conventional wisdom, but nothing in this article made me question individualism as being a strong counter to surveillance.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- bsedlm 5y ago> nothing in this article made me question individualism as being a strong counter to surveillance. as I understood it, that has nothing to do with the point of the article. On that level, I'd say the point of the article is how both east and west are converging towards a similar amount of individual surveillance (while most of the article deals with why this may be the case)