6 ms·
I'm a one-man IT show for a few small- and mid-sized companies, and I had to manage an incident a few years ago where one of the companies was taken down for se
by noduerme 5y ago
I'm a one-man IT show for a few small- and mid-sized companies, and I had to manage an incident a few years ago where one of the companies was taken down for several days under a massive dDOS attack. This was accompanied by a ransom email to me. I disclosed the email to the company owner and he asked if we should pay it. I told him I wouldn't pay it if he ordered me to. I was sleeping on the floor for an hour at a time - the host handling the dedicated server basically said we had to go and threatened me that I would have to pay for their downtime, and the attack was large enough to shut down their connection to the transatlantic cable, so I had to fight around it for 48 hours while trying to quietly exfiltrate our data off the server through another one I had in Europe at the moments I could connect. I was contacted by the FBI and ultimately they found the assailants and one of the people behind it went to prison for a couple years; I got a judgment against him for my cost mitigating the attack (although it's symbolic, obviously. I'm sure I won't see a dime of it). He was just some schmuck in Florida.
TL;DR - if everyone refused to pay there would be no profit in it. And if everyone had to have IT staff who were competent, or worry about being fined for malfeasance, there would be no question of paying a third party to deal with something quietly. It's right and proper that authorities get involved. Even if they do find it's some troll farm in Russia, they can sanction and block in a way that small companies cannot. It's one of those situations where you stand together or die separately.
- FDSGSG 5y ago>if everyone refused to pay there would be no profit in it Of course it's very saintly of you to refuse to pay, but often not paying is a very bad business decision. You can be sure that enough people will pay for your refusal to not make any difference.
- noduerme 5y agoIt wasn't for saintly reasons; I saw clearly that it would do no good. If we paid, there was no guarantee the attack wouldn't come back the next day. It would solve nothing - actually, it would be worse because it would put us at their mercy. If we couldn't overcome it, get back online and block the next attack, then I didn't deserve my job and the company would have been better without me. Paying wouldn't make the problem go away, it would have made it infinitely worse for me. So saintly? No way.
- Jach 5y agoStill, the GP's point stands. Especially as attackers create a "brand" and establish trust -- if a few quick searches show other people reporting that they paid and things were restored, then you can bet people will feel much more at ease with the idea of paying and actually being left alone after. When a business depends on it, when data loss is at play instead of just downtime, even more so. People will pay.
- noduerme 5y agoI think paying is a dumb move, regardless of the "brand" of extortionist you're dealing with. It just signals that you're a mark. It might briefly make an executive's life easier, but it'll come back and bite you. I didn't refuse to pay because I thought it would be inspirational or set an example or bla bla bla. It was because I'm not a dumb mark, and I'm not going to let my clients be. And personally, I'd rather burn my house to the ground than let someone rob it.
- FpUser 5y ago>"And personally, I'd rather burn my house to the ground than let someone rob it." That is your personal choice and you're more than welcome to go up in flames if that is what you wish. You should have no rights however to force your personal choice upon the others. They might have a different perspective.
- FDSGSG 5y agoPaying can't be a dumb move when your business continuity depends on an attacker returning your encrypted files. I agree that with DDoS extortion the situation is way more complicated, and the attacker will eventually move on if you don't pay. > And personally, I'd rather burn my house to the ground than let someone rob it. I think we can all agree that this is just plain stupid. Cutting off your nose to spite your face.
- hermes8329 5y agoI think we can all agree that this is just plain stupid. Cutting off your nose to spite your face. No we can't alI agree on that and I think you would be surprised. Personally I'd be seen with a gas can and a box of matches
- Tuna-Fish 5y ago> Of course it's very saintly of you to refuse to pay, but often not paying is a very bad business decision. You can be sure that enough people will pay for your refusal to not make any difference. And this is something where the law can help. Paying a ransom in these kinds of situations needs to be a felony. The punishment needs to be dealt to everyone who acted or knew and didn't report, and it needs to be harsh enough that even in the worst cases people would rather call the cops and report than risk it. (Or, at least some employee in the organization would report it and save their own hide than risk it to protect their boss.) The ramsomware crisis is really bad now, and it keeps getting worse. It will not stop getting worse until the money dries up. Small businesses cannot be expected to have the level of IT knowledge that they absolutely can't be hacked. The reason they weren't victimized before at this level was that the money wasn't there. There are enough places in the world where the authorities will look the other way (or actively cheer on the criminals), meaning this will not end until the flow of money is stopped. If you want to mitigate the losses caused by ransomware gangs, create a subsidized insurance system that helps the victims. Just, that insurance is not allowed to pay off the criminals, just help the business get back on it's feet.
- FDSGSG 5y agoCompanies would still pay even if making ransomware payments was a felony. The ransomware gangs would not go away, companies would just have a bigger incentive to hide ransomware attacks. These groups aren't going to go away even if 95% of companies suddenly stopped paying, deploying ransomware costs next to nothing. There's also a huge incentive for ransomware actors to punish this sort of regulation. > The ramsomware crisis is really bad now, and it keeps getting worse. How come everybody is crying about the "ransomware crisis", but you never hear about a "BEC crisis"? BEC losses are bigger than ransomware losses, and they keep getting worse.