So who deserves what? If you need brain surgery, you want a very good brain surgeon. Does it really matter to you if he was just lucky to become so good? Perso

So who deserves what? If you need brain surgery, you want a very good brain surgeon. Does it really matter to you if he was just lucky to become so good? Personally I would still be willing to pay more money to get the better surgeon, no matter HOW they became so good. Same for all other things. I want the best leader for my country. Does it matter if they are a good leader because they were lucky (born with intelligence, good education and so on)? No, all I care is that they are good, not why they are good. (Assuming all act morally - if the brain surgeon only got so good because he abducted people and experimented on their brains, I would not be OK with it).