3 ms·
>BLM's problem[1] is that it's a national movement about local problems. It's city cops, not the FBI, that kill people with impunity. Which happens because bla
by Levitz 5y ago
>BLM's problem[1] is that it's a national movement about local problems. It's city cops, not the FBI, that kill people with impunity.
Which happens because black people are overrepresented when it comes to crime, which happens because they are overrepresented in being poor as dirt.
There is racism in the police force in the US, no doubt, but constantly dealing with criminals and seeing a disparity in a race is bound to make people racist. If you were to wave a magic wand and make all racism in the US disappear overnight, new racism would appear in the span of a month because poor people are still poor. This is why I think BLM was headed towards failure from the very start.
- javajosh 5y agoI don't know that much about the internal workings of BLM. But I would think the most effective path forward is to become a viable, powerful political bloc, and then use this power to court local establishment politicians. (Heck, in a better time even the GOP would not be immune to the lure of millions of coherent votes!) This approach won't work because blacks don't vote. Which I frankly don't understand. Even with problematic voter laws, I can't think of a scenario, short of someone pointing a gun in my face, that would stop me from voting. And yet, awhile back in the Abrams race in black turnout in Georgia was like 50%. That is...insanely low, and implies a thick, wide self-destructive streak. It bodes poorly for the community, because if you can't be bothered to help yourself, then what hope do you have of changing your situation?
- s1artibartfast 5y agoThe biggest problem with BLM making progress is a lack of solutions they bring to the table. The only consistent proposal is to defund the police, which is very unpopular even within the black community. The majority of the black community sees neighborhood crime as a leading issue and wants to see more cops on the street (just with less discrimination and brutality). Unless BLM can come up with another solution, I don't see them making headway with the black community. That said, other communities may be able to propel BLM agenda into action against the consensus in the black community. Really a bizarre situation overall.
- chuckee 5y ago> Which happens because black people are overrepresented when it comes to crime, which happens because they are overrepresented in being poor as dirt. Have you tried to confirm this hypothesis, by for example looking at studies that examine the crime rate by both socioeconomic status and race?
- sleepysysadmin 5y ago>Have you tried to confirm this hypothesis, by for example looking at studies that examine the crime rate by both socioeconomic status and race? This isn't a hypothesis. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Race_and_crime_in_the_United_States#Explanations_for_racial_discrepancies https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Race_and_crime_in_the_United_S...
- chuckee 5y agoYou seem awfully sure. I was able to find only one study that directly compared crime, race, and income group: https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/wonk/wp/2016/03/23/poor-white-kids-are-less-likely-to-go-to-prison-than-rich-black-kids/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/wonk/wp/2016/03/23/poor-... Unfortunately the metric it uses is whether they were ever incarcerated for any reason. Someone hostile to those results would probably dismiss them as due to police racism. One could try to use homicide and victim surveys as a mostly objective proxy for all violent crime (very difficult and impossible, respectively, for racist police practices to affect), compare that to the violent crime rate of each racial group, and use any disparity to estimate how racist the police and justice system are being. But then one would risk getting a result one doesn't like.