3 ms·
60 years ago housing was an investment in a very different form than it is today. 60 years ago was before Reagan and Trump tax reforms - both of which changed
by bluGill 5y ago
60 years ago housing was an investment in a very different form than it is today. 60 years ago was before Reagan and Trump tax reforms - both of which changed the rules in major ways. (every year the tax rules change in minor ways) 60 years ago also had much higher interest rates than today. Those two are very significant.
Back then deducting your interest from your taxes was very important. The middle class could hardly afford to live in a tiny apartment, but the interest tax deduction meant they could afford to live in a good sized house. Back then you bought a house with the understanding that in 30 years it would be paid for - right about the time you were ready to retire, and then you lived rent free for the rest of your life (nobody considered nursing home expenses).
Today housing as an investment to most people mean do a cash out refinance every few years so they can live beyond their means, then sell to some bigger sucker when they are done.
If you think of housing as the first type of investment it can still be good in some cases. You need less money when you are retired and can live a long life in the place where you made your memories.
Of course when talking about investing in housing it must be repeated "location location location". For some of you your location (and in particular change of location over time!) means buying a a bad investment. For others your location means buying is great. You have to figure this out for yourself.
- xxpor 5y ago>Back then deducting your interest from your taxes was very important. Because of how mortgages are amortized, the deduction's value to the taxpayer doesn't vary directly with the interest rate, but with the total value of the mortgage. Your payments are always going to be mostly interest in the first few years, transitioning over to principal in the later years.
- bluGill 5y agoMost people are getting raises, so as the deduction loses value the raise is making up for the loss. Not important today when basically nobody qualifies for the deduction.
- dragontamer 5y ago> 60 years ago also had much higher interest rates than today. 60 years ago had much higher inflation as well. People are scoffing at 6% inflation during this dramatic COVID19 period... but 1974 had 11% inflation, and 1980 had 13.50% inflation. Under such a market, you had to have higher interest rates. After all, 10% interest rates would _LOSE_ money under real terms in 1974, 1979 and 1980 (all three years famous for having "double-digit" inflation rates). When banks are charging maybe 15% or 20% for mortgages, housing prices necessarily have to plummet to make those houses affordable to the masses.
- mywittyname 5y agoI've been really amused at the news reports stating "highest rate of inflation in the US in 30 years!" Because 1991 is well remembered for...inflation.
- bluGill 5y agoThe 1970s were 40 years ago not 60. Inflation has varried a lot over the years. Though a house as a real good. Is an investment against inflation which is sometimes more important than others.