3 ms·
Gentle reminder that instant runoff voting has been tried & discarded by a number of organizations over the decades (it's literally centuries old!) It's been tr
by godelski 5y ago
Gentle reminder that instant runoff voting has been tried & discarded by a number of organizations over the decades (it's literally centuries old!) It's been tried in America and discarded in the past several times in many different places. It is also how they vote in Australia (which is similarly divided as the US).
I don't disagree that Approval has issues. I think we can improve upon these with score or STAR. But I think it is very naive to start a post with such a criticism and then ignore that it applies even more strongly to the alternative method being presented (either Exhaustive Voting or Two-Round).
- hash872 5y agoI'm not for IRV, you're confusing that with a 'normal' or two round runoff. In a normal runoff there are two rounds, the second round is a few weeks or a month after the first one- the French, most famously, do this for their President. I agree that IRV is pretty terrible https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Two-round_system https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Two-round_system
- godelski 5y agoI'm a little lost at the response. My comment ends mentioning Two-round.