5 ms·
In the US we do have something like a runoff. We have primary elections and then general elections. It's not quite the same thing, but neither is it the same as
by jfengel 5y ago
In the US we do have something like a runoff. We have primary elections and then general elections. It's not quite the same thing, but neither is it the same as plain FPTP.
The American system acknowledges the fact that there are long-term stable coalitions. Even if you went to a single election with a runoff, you're going to end up with similar dynamics. Most of the candidates will say, "If I'm your first choice, your second choice should be that other guy who is in my coalition and believes most of the same things that I do."
There may well be other candidates on the ballot, but they'll usually find themselves unable to win without a coalition to present a slate of candidates. They're in exactly the same position as "third party" candidates already are.
The systems aren't identical and don't produce identical outcomes, but they're a lot closer than I think people make it out to be. A simple procedural change isn't going to fix what's wrong with the American body politic.
There is no perfect tiny party out there with all the right answers that everybody would agree with if only the two main parties would just get out of the way. That is what each of hundreds of tiny parties tell themselves. And that's why there's really no such thing as a "third party". Really, there are hundreds of "hundredth parties" who disagree with each other as much as they disagree with the two main parties, because they haven't put forth the effort of hammering out and nurturing the uneasy coalitions that go into making a dominant party.
- snarf21 5y agoI'd agree with you IF all our primaries were on the same day and there wasn't this caucus >> primaries in a new state each day
- jfengel 5y agoThat's a weirdness for the Presidential election, the only elected national office holder. That one is weird a lot of different ways. But for the various state and district offices, that doesn't matter. There, you really are voting at the same time as all of the other people with an interest in it. I'd say the bigger issue is that for a number of places, only one party really has a chance, and the general election is a foregone conclusion. Voters really only get one bite at the apple, during the primaries. (The voters for the other party never really get a bite at the apple, but they are so far outnumbered that no tweak to the voting system will fix that. They have to hope that the elected representative will keep their interests in mind.)