6 ms·
Voting systems is one of the few political things I'm very passionate about (those of you that know me will know I won't shut up about this). I really do think
by godelski 5y ago
Voting systems is one of the few political things I'm very passionate about (those of you that know me will know I won't shut up about this). I really do think this is one of the most important things we can do to fix our democracy. I've always been saddened that Ordinal systems have captured the public eye but Cardinal systems haven't. Everything I have read suggests that Cardinal is leagues better: scalability, ease, verifiability, resistance to strategies, and vse. I'm really happy to see more and more Approval initiatives (I'm a bigger fan of STAR, but Approval is good enough that I'd shut up about voting).
I also suggest other users look for Clay[0] in these threads. He's the co-inventor of STAR and writes a lot about voting. Also a HN user.
[0] https://twitter.com/ClayShentrup https://twitter.com/ClayShentrup
- Apofis 5y agoJust getting rid of first-past-the-post would do wonders for our country and by the looks of it approval voting is inferior to run-off voting by a mile.
- godelski 5y ago> by the looks of it approval voting is inferior to run-off voting by a mile. I'm curious why you think this? I think exactly the opposite. RCV/IRV has major problems, especially for strong spoilers. They are also more difficult to tabulate and with the recent events of the last election the importance of ease to tabulate went up in my priority list (making me even question my preference of score over approval). In fact, IRV also favors extremists, which is something I really don't want.
- noahtallen 5y agoFor more context, this post has some cool interactive features to explain the voting types: https://ncase.me/ballot/ https://ncase.me/ballot/ Another problem with RCV is that it’s difficult to understand, at least when you get into the runoffs. That makes it harder for people to understand and trust the election system, which is also very important.
- godelski 5y agoI'm not too big of a fan of this site but it is nice. One thing I wanted to point out is the spoiler effect. Often we talk about it but similarly we generally only talk about a weak spoiler. So I wanted to show an example of a strong spoiler[0]. In this example Hexagon splits Triangles votes just by a little, but the sum of Triangle and Hex are larger than Square. But here IRV has Square winning but Approval has Hex winning. This is one big issue for me with IRV vs Cardinal systems. Both handle _weak_ spoilers but IRV doesn't handle ''strong,, spoilers. Understanding that these are two different types of spoilers is really important. It is "Bernie vs Hillary" and "Cruz vs Trump." Even with IRV we'd still see the parties trying to prevent strong primary candidates from running independently because they could spoil the election. With cardinal methods (approval, score, star) this is far less of a concern and thus I think more democratic of an election. I honestly think we should be much more concerned with strong spoilers than weak spoilers (weak spoilers don't affect elections much anyways). [0] https://imgur.com/a/vV15A7Z https://imgur.com/a/vV15A7Z
- noahtallen 5y agoI completely agree; I tend to like approval voting just because it is nearly as good as the other scoring methods while being very simple.
- godelski 5y agoExactly. I say STAR: 5, Score 4, approval 4, IRV 1, FPTP 1 It would be ranked in this order too, but there's more expressivity here than an ordinal system can provide.
- Apofis 5y agoConsidering our present division, I have a big "spider-sense" tingle that approval voting will simply result in everyone just voting all blue or all red, that sounds like a bad deal to me. Run off voting would give moderates a good chance of putting the country right side up again.
- 5y ago
- r00fus 5y agoAll your assertions are actually complaints about our existing plurality voting system. IRV/Approval/Borda/Condorcet voting systems all improve those factors. That they have some edge conditions that could be theoretically exploited belies that fact that plurality voting (ie, FPTP / one person one vote) is a complete train wreck for spoilers and favoring extreme voting. No voting system is perfect (Arrow's impossibility theorem) but some are harder to exploit than others. Staying with a broken system because the proposed replacement isn't perfect is a poor justification.
- godelski 5y agoDown below I actually give an example of IRV/RCV not solving a strong spoiler case. Clay has also written extensively on the subject matter so I'll defer to him. I'll especially defer to him on explaining how IRV actually encourages extremists. I think the problem here is that people get caught up in VSE. I get it, that's what I was caught up in when I first started learning about this stuff. Then I had to really dig through strategic voting and spoilage. The nuance of the systems actually do make a very big difference in the outcomes.
- r00fus 5y agoI'd love to hear how our current electoral system is in any way preferable to RCV (or Star Voting for example). Because for many municipalities, it's not whether they move to Approval vs. RCV or IRV or Star, etc - it's moving away from the dumpster fire of plurality voting.
- pxx 5y agoI'd argue that instant-runoff is _worse than plurality_. It complicates the voting system, makes the wrong tradeoffs (lack of monotonicity is a very serious one), and I'd really like to hear more about why you think approval voting is worse than runoff (instant or otherwise).
- cpeterso 5y agoIRV is also very hard to explain to average voters. Approval voting is easy to explain: you get to give a thumbs up or down to every candidate. In a local mayoral election that used IRV, I've seen some candidates tell their supporters to vote for them in every slot. Either those candidates didn't understand IRV themselves, or they didn't want to try to explain IRV to their supporters.
- mjevans 5y agoI prefer https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Schulze_method https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Schulze_method Though with a candidate modification: add 'none of them / no confidence' as a virtual candidate that can never be removed by the runoff processes. If 'NoT' is the winner then the entire election is thrown out and all of the candidates are banned from the re-run.
- godelski 5y agoCondorcet methods are also hard to explain to voters. The tabulation is rather complicated. At least in comparison to something like cardinal methods. In light of recent recounts I think this is a really important factor to consider. While Condorcet methods have the best VSE, they aren't winning by a huge margin. Besides, VSE isn't everything.
- ClayShentrup 5y agoCondorcet methods perform, at best, only a little better than approval voting in computer simulations. And they have only ever been used in one US city (Marquette, MI) which shortly thereafter repealed it. And they are radically more complicated and unlikely to ever see the light of day. https://electionscience.github.io/vse-sim/vse.html https://electionscience.github.io/vse-sim/vse.html
- troydavis 5y agoYou might be interested in my answer in another thread: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29266519#29277580 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29266519#29277580 I give an example from this year's Seattle primaries where RCV/IRV would have eliminated the candidate that most accurately reflects the electorate but Approval Voting would not have. That's not a trivial or rare situation, either, it's just such a simple race that it's easy to spot.
- ClayShentrup 5y agoHi
- godelski 5y agoIt's the guy from the comment! Always good to see you Clay. Hope you are doing well.
- jpfed 5y agoI have long liked and advocated for approval voting (or cardinal methods more generally), or barring that, basically anything but FPTP. But I'm disillusioned. Many non-plurality methods (including approval) can effectively solve the spoiler problem (i.e. satisfy IIA)... but I no longer think that spoilers are the absolute most important problem to solve. The most important problem is single-seat districts creating anti-majoritarian, disproportional legislatures. Because of how people geographically sort themselves among the likeminded, even independent districting commissions will not be able to effectively prevent anti-majoritarian legislatures. For this reason, I believe that we would greatly benefit from explicitly proportional representation. This can be accomplished through cardinal or ordinal means - I no longer care about that dimension. That doesn't mean that we wouldn't enjoy some incremental benefit from approval or really any non-FPTP system. We would. Seattle should go ahead and do its thing. But the fight for better forms of democracy can't stop with any system that retains single-seat districts.
- kibwen 5y ago> Everything I have read suggests that Cardinal is leagues better Speaking as a fellow kin who also won't shut up about this, right now we need to just acknowledge that ANYTHING is better than first-past-the-post. At this point I honestly don't care which alternative it is, none of them are worse than the current system. In every jurisdiction where any form of alternative voting system is on the ballot, I will throw my support behind whatever effort has the most momentum, regardless of whether it's approval, star, RCV, whatever. First-past-the-post is killing us with its inevitable descent into bipolarization, and we can figure out a perfect solution once we've stopped the bleeding (keeping in mind that voting system reform is merely a necessary first step, and not sufficient on its own).
- godelski 5y ago> ANYTHING is better than first-past-the-post. I disagree with this stance. Mostly because how these methods are presented. RCV has gained such popularity because its claims of preventing spoiled elections. But people think that's Bernie spoiling Hillary and not Stein spoiling no one. RCV only prevents weak spoilers where cardinal systems prevent strong spoilers. The reason I'm so concerned with this is because this is also why RCV got repealed in the past. IN AMERICA. This is my big fear. We all get excited about it, implement a system that doesn't solve the problems we are seeking to solve, and then go back and look for other solutions. We have a solution now, and a wide breadth of them. They just aren't the popular ones.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- cwkoss 5y agoBernie didn't spoil Hillary. More Bernie voters voted for Hillary than 2012 Hillary voters voted for Obama.
- godelski 5y agoI think you misunderstood. Bernie made an agreement with the DNC to not run as an independent candidate. The reason being that he would have spoiled the election.