4 ms·
Yet another thing on the cancerogenic pile sigh At some point you have to ask yourself if everything but water gives us cancer.
by moffkalast 5y ago
Yet another thing on the cancerogenic pile sigh
At some point you have to ask yourself if everything but water gives us cancer.
- laluser 5y agoGotta watch out for lead in the water too!
- moffkalast 5y agoBut if my veins aren't lead lined, what will protect me from banana radiation?
- mbg721 5y agoA plantain vest. The rows of plantains attach to all of the body's normal banana receptors before the lethally radioactive bananas can, leaving you unscathed.
- artificialLimbs 5y agoIf I couldn't grow it or raise it 100 years ago, I don't want to eat it. Open to being convinced otherwise.
- skymt 5y agoNot the worst place to start, but considering palm oil has been used in cooking for thousands of years it's not clear what that principle has to do with this story.
- tshaddox 5y agoDo you mean if you personally wouldn't have been to grow it or raise it 100 years ago? Or do you mean something more like "if it wasn't widely accessible 100 years ago"?
- voz_ 5y agoWhat happened in 1921? Or is this one of those baseless "before we had cancer" comments?
- malfist 5y agoCancer wasn't invented then. In all seriousness, things like pasteurization and refrigeration make our food supply a lot safer than it used to be.
- mbg721 5y agoI realized at some point that "It's food iff your grandparents would call it food" either has to be amended to add a generation, or we have to accept Oreos pretty soon.
- bluGill 5y agoMargarine was invented in 1869. You need to go back a lot farther. You are also skipping out a lot of newer stuff that wasn't possible back then, but after serious study seems safe. Most of what was done 200 years ago is accepted as safe, but there is no actual evidence for it, and in many cases we know it wasn't. (the obvious example of using lead in finishes for food contact items)
- tyingq 5y agoI suppose there's some merit in the "before we had cancer" thing. Certainly many people were dying of other stuff long before they would have gotten cancer.
- gambiting 5y agoYou do realise palm oil is older than 100 years, right? Used literally for thousands of years. "Humans used oil palms as far back as 5,000 years. In the late 1800s, archaeologists discovered a substance that they concluded was originally palm oil in a tomb at Abydos dating back to 3,000 BCE.[4] It is believed that traders brought oil palm to Egypt" https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Palm_oil https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Palm_oil
- yupper32 5y agoIs your medicine cabinet empty?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- artificialLimbs 5y agoNo, I have ibuprofen for when I have a headache lasting more than a day. (It's caffeine... every ... time.)
- yupper32 5y agoSo you eat ibuprofen, but you couldn't grow or raise it 100 years ago. It was invented in the 60s and wasn't available over the counter until the 80s.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- WarChortle 5y agoDo you not take Advil? Tums? Antibiotics? or a myriad of other useful medicine?
- heavyset_go 5y agoAspirin is more than 100 years old and people have been eating calcium carbonate for quite some time. I get your point, though.
- f6v 5y agoUltra-processed foods are probably a consequence of trying to feed billions of people. Do you think there’s enough farm land, water, etc. for the earth population to only grow bio/eco produce?
- rileyphone 5y agoOf note is the monstrosities we call chickens today are a product of breeding contests in the 1940s [0] (but does that mean there is anything wrong with eating them? who's to say). It seems a lot more people today are taking a critical look at what they eat, though often excluding broad categories based on feeling rather than hard science. At first this looks reactionary, but on closer inspection one realizes that the science involved is typically biased or just lacking. We've invested comparatively little into understanding the downsides of modern food products like vegetable oil, but the little windows we have indicate they may be causing whole hosts of human maladies from dementia to type 2 diabetes [1]. Nutrition constitutes the inputs to the complex biological system, and large changes (eg disease) can end up being the result of nonlinear processes started by changing these inputs. Another example is a lack of magnesium in the western diet, through both soil depletion and food processing, leading to large scale deficiencies [2]. What's really dizzying, though, is that this information isn't widely known, and is typically found through either self-directed study or through listening to podcasts. When the average person makes decisions regarding their nutrition, they're relying on outdated and probably harmful advice, despite intending to make "healthy" choices. Maybe we need an app to scan a barcode or read a list of ingredients and respond with the known potential for harm and confidence. All I know is I'll never look at fried chicken the same way again (unless it's fried in lard, of course). [0] https://livestock.extension.wisc.edu/articles/the-chicken-of-tomorrow/ https://livestock.extension.wisc.edu/articles/the-chicken-of... [1] https://web.archive.org/web/20190303234503id_/http://pdfs.semanticscholar.org/b4ce/fae0475f0be1053c6abf0c47f485a22beddb.pdf https://web.archive.org/web/20190303234503id_/http://pdfs.se... [2] https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s11104-013-1781-2 https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s11104-013-1781-2
- outworlder 5y ago> If I couldn't grow it or raise it 100 years ago, I don't want to eat it Humans have been barbecuing meat for millennia. Possibly even before Homo Sapiens Sapiens was around. And yet, it has carcinogenic properties, specially if charred. What's so special about 100 years ago anyway? 1000 might make a difference - but then again, life expectancy wasn't that great back then. It's only because we are living so much that cancer is such a large problem. Also because, due to modern medicine, we can often diagnose the person before they just get sick and die from 'unknown' reasons. Your best bet is to eat food from as many different sources as you can and not eat too much of any single specific thing (which is a modern thing btw, 100 years ago, it wouldn't be as easy to do) and let averages do the rest.
- rackjack 5y agobeing alive gives you cancer
- hypertele-Xii 5y agoCancer is alive. That's so weird. Some part of you decided to go in a different direction. You're not advanced enough to support both. The strain on resources starves you both. Kind of like a cannibal parasite. That sure sounds like a death metal band.
- jszymborski 5y agoWith every cell division, we are not only closer to death, but roll for a "cell transformation"[0]. A transformed cell is most likely to occur in a "cancerised field" of cells. Those fields might be induced to be transformed in-turn by the original transformed cell(s). It's in this way that the snowball turns from a pea to a boulder, but all along the way there are trees ready to stop its momentum. Be it DNA repair systems, the immune system, the extra-cellular matrix, etc... An oncologist once told me (and its not hard for me to conceive), that we're all likely die with a number of tumours in us... just not likely from them. All this to say, yes everything causes cancer. When you consider the molecular biology behind it all, it's a wonder we're anything but giant, spherical, innervated tumours. Just like everything else, you make your own risk assessments in life, but the advice boils down to: avoid undue risks of cancer if you can. What "undue" and "if you can" here mean is deeply personal. [0] A fun euphemism for a cell that is cancer-like.
- justinator 5y agoTo be honest, we're in a constant state of almost having cancer, it's just that our immune system handles the little stuff before it gets out of control. Nothing causes cancer, but certain things tip the scales towards the cancer getting out of control. (about is all simplified of course)
- vmception 5y agoAnd also things can directly cause cancer by directly damaging DNA in the right places at the right time. No need to take the optimistic route. If it makes you feel better: some cancers.
- justinator 5y agoOh, well: I didn't think conceptualize, "we are always in a state of having cancer" was an optimistic view, just realistic :). But DNA gets damaged all by itself, but you're right: something like smoking for decades doesn't help matters.
- DoingIsLearning 5y agoNot trying to be pedantic but carcinogenic is something that _causes_ cancer, that is not the mechanism this study is describing with palmitic acid. The study claims that palm oil promotes the growth of metastasis of an original cancer tumour. So it is not that palm oil _causes_ cancer but that it will _potentially_ promote more agressive copying of tumurous cells into other regions of the body.