4 ms·
the worst examples receive little publicity and involve what i think most people reading here would consider trivial amounts of money and property. The publici
by h2odragon 5y ago
the worst examples receive little publicity and involve what i think most people reading here would consider trivial amounts of money and property.
The publicized examples involve money.
- mindslight 5y agoDo you care to reference specific examples? By your general comment, I had assumed you were referencing Spears and the occasional elder abuse article that pops up on HN. And I'm just saying that in the case of of an elephant with no money, they're a lot less attractive target for that type of hostile fiduciary. Furthermore, it doesn't seem like the article mentions guardianship at all. In fact as it stands it would seem that elephants in general already have guardians - whomever can assert a property right over them. The question is whether an elephant itself should be recognized as having its own perspective. In this way, this case would seem to be more about reforming the current guardianship of elephants to increase their agency, rather than reducing it as you're making out. And yeah to your general point, the courts are imperfect and seemingly terrible when we look at their worst abuses. But that seems somewhat orthogonal to the current question. If we get to the point where say some billionaires are abusing the ability to legally represent an elephant (to further their own interests while harming that elephant), then we can focus on that specific injustice.
- h2odragon 5y agoSpears, yes; and Stan Lee, and... the list goes on. I dont want to comment on the evidence of abuse among the small time everyday "power of attorney" guardianship ive seen, I wish i had not seen it. If we give elephants sub-human agency; do other animals get it too? Are they still "property"? do some humans become less than human? There's non-small questions here that can be re-examined and debated; but I fear there's going to be just a slide into a new ethics without ever evaluating the merits of either the old or new.