3 ms·
> We’ve also taken other measures to frustrate attackers, for example we have physically removed the hard drive so there is no way to persist data on the laptop
by sneak 5y ago
> We’ve also taken other measures to frustrate attackers, for example we have physically removed the hard drive so there is no way to persist data on the laptop itself
This sentence made me believe in the incompetence of the authors.
- intunderflow 5y agoThis is covered more here https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29266521 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29266521 Sorry for not being up to your standards I guess :(
- sneak 5y agocompetence/incompetence is not a compliment or slur. I am an incompetent welder, for example. My point is that if you are removing the hard disk to prevent state storage, that is ineffective, and if you think that it is effective (which you stated), you are objectively factually incorrect.
- Nextgrid 5y agoWell you have to start somewhere. You will never get perfect security, however persisting malicious code on disk (and getting the machine to boot from it) is easy and standardized. Doing the same in firmware (or non-volatile storage in other parts of the machine) is going to be very manufacturer-specific and will require knowledge of the exact hardware, versions, etc and because of the air gap you can't even tell whether your attempt worked (and of course if your malware needs to exfiltrate data it still needs to break out of the air gap). TLDR: it's not bulletproof but increases the effort required from an attacker significantly.
- tornato7 5y agoWhy do you think this shows incompetence?
- sneak 5y agoThere are about 10 other ways of persisting secret information on a system other than the hard disk. The claim they make is amateur hour. There are better ways of doing this. There are embedded systems that can run general purpose OSes that cannot store permanent state, such as rpi <=3 that are much better suited to such things.