3 ms·
I was more commenting on the general concept than a specific implementation. To be honest, while I tried to be optimistic about Google+ I never used it much and
by ghaff 5y ago
I was more commenting on the general concept than a specific implementation. To be honest, while I tried to be optimistic about Google+ I never used it much and didn't dive into things like Circles hardly at all.
Certainly there can be a need to partition things. Today, I pretty much do it by using different social media for different purposes and, to the degree I blend some things, I keep it mostly uncontroversial and not overwhelming for those who may be only interested in some aspect.
- dredmorbius 5y agoCircles turned out to be immensely painful to manage, for numerous reasons. The easiest approach was often to simply nuke them all and start over. Surprisingly, this was remarkably non-lossy. One of the more interesting episodes I had on G+ was when my primary profile was blocked (authentication issues) and I created a new one. In a fit of pique I named that "The Real Slim Shady", and started connecting up with a few key contacts. Within a few days I'd certainly managed to restore my core list of about 100 or so connections. Several people commented on how clear it was to them that this was in fact the same individual. (I did confirm the association through several other sites, which helps.) It also revealed the value of quashing even only a small number of sources of major noise. (See my recent HN submission of Yonatan Zunger's "Privacy, Triage, and Risk" talk: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29249630 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29249630 https://yewtu.be/watch?v=9HQBCEW9odU https://yewtu.be/watch?v=9HQBCEW9odU https://www.usenix.org/conference/pepr19/presentation/zunger https://www.usenix.org/conference/pepr19/presentation/zunger for the relationship between harm-reduction / risk mitigation vs. value-creation. The former is vastly more effective.) This episode gave me a few insights on the nature of identity and trust. It also reminds me of how rapidly even massively-damaged cities and countries (war, natural disaster, etc.) tend to recover, especially if essential culture remains intact. Perhaps not entirely per their previous trajectory, but often with remarkably little long-term impact. This contrasts with trying to raise a specific region up out of poverty, a lack of institutions and infrastructure, and often a low-trust / high-corruption culture.