3 ms·
I am appalled how this person asked a question, out of ignorance, yes, but politely and it got censored, flagged and their comment hidden. I have vouched it bac
by sph 5y ago
I am appalled how this person asked a question, out of ignorance, yes, but politely and it got censored, flagged and their comment hidden. I have vouched it back from the dead.
How are people supposed to understand if the approach taken by the educated ones is of censorship and taboo?
I extremely appreciate @throwawaygh below answering the question clearly and teaching OP a valuable point of view of the matter, without prejudice or indignation of someone else's ignorance.
Shame on those who just preferred to censor the question. This is not how we build an inclusive society. I expect better of this site.
- Kaze404 5y agoUnfortunately this is a more complicated subject than it seems for transgender people. So often we have to deal with people saying the most horrific things under the guise of "I'm just asking questions" that we have to, out of self defense, try and identify when someone is legitimately confused or just concern trolling. That said, thank you for reviving their comment as I personally don't think there was anything wrong with it specifically. Just trying to shed some light on why some people might have interpreted it differently.
- throwawaygh 5y ago> So often we have to deal with people saying the most horrific things under the guise of "I'm just asking questions" It's true. "I'm just asking questions" is definitely a routine used to harass trans people. It's probably the most common routine now that overt transphobia is less socially acceptable. I doubt there's a single trans person in the US -- outside of very cloistered bubbles -- who hasn't been harassed by a troll who was pretending to "jut ask questions". My MIL is one of those people -- she's even gone through the same line of questions on the same exact person (1+ year apart, forgot she already met the person). Which is why she's no longer welcome in polite company. The point: I'm not saying that removing people from some social contexts is never the answer. Sometimes that's the best course of action. But here's the thing. "Just Asking Questions" trolling is a particularly insidious and ingenious routine. Sure, it's mean and petty with plausible deniability. But that's not why it's so genius. Using this routine en masse is a genius move by anti-trans hate groups because it actively shuts down education, which is ultimately the best way we know to increase public acceptance of transgender people. We can't do anything about recalcitrant assholes except cut them out of some parts of our lives. But we can disallow them the pleasure of shutting down education and thereby reinforcing their own ignorance in the broader population. Anyways, that's a long-winded way of saying "kill them with kindness". If they were genuinely curious then your kindness just won trans people an ally. If they were trolling then the only way to cut past the plausible deniability bullshit is to avoid direct anger and beat them at their own "pastor's wife bless-your-heart" game. And anyways, there's something viscerally pleasing about a midwesterner who didn't know you're a midwest transplant slowing realize they're being out-midwested... much more pleasing than having to deal with an asshole accusing you of being mean to them when they were "just asking questions" ;-) But the main point is, it doesn't matter if they're trolling or genuine! In both cases, responding with direct anger to questions in the moment is a losing strategy. The troll gets to play victim and the genuinely uneducated are put on the defensive. (And, yes, it's unreasonable that trans people are so often de facto representatives of all trans people in every daily interaction. I'm just describing the micro-political strategy and not trying to imply there's anything wrong with being a normal human instead of a political operative.)
- 1_player 5y agoI understand and empathise with having to deal with trolls online. It gets tiring very quickly. But when in doubt, on this site my suggestion is to follow its guidelines: "Please respond to the strongest plausible interpretation of what someone says, not a weaker one that's easier to criticize. Assume good faith." https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- Sohcahtoa82 5y agoThe problem is that a transphobe that refuses to acknowledge gender identity can look exactly the same as someone who legitimately does not understand gender identity and wants to know more. The former knows this and will JAQ off.
- throwawaygh 5y agoYes, that's exactly the problem. And in at least some cases it is strategic and intentional. Anti-trans hate groups know that most people will respond with understanding rather than hate when hearing answers to certain types of questions. They know that, like the racists and homophobes before them, they are on the losing side of a rational and polite discourse. The only hope for trans hate groups is to shut down that rational and polite discourse. One strategy for doing so is to identify questions that people have and then prime trans people/trans allies to respond emotionally to those questions. The goal of the "just asking questions" routine is (1) make trans people uncomfortable but also (2) make sure that people who actually do have questions always feel attacked by the trans community instead of empathetic with the trans community. It's a strategy. By shutting down possibilities for education we play directly into their hand. I wrote more in a sibling comment: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29267480 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29267480