3 ms·
I'm not an industry expert, but I wonder if this product is aimed at customers that have been hit hard by the electronic parts supply chain problems. If you ha
by jiggawatts 5y ago
I'm not an industry expert, but I wonder if this product is aimed at customers that have been hit hard by the electronic parts supply chain problems.
If you have some small IC doing some simple digital logic, and the SKU is sold out, that 50c part could prevent you shipping a $200K luxury car or whatever. Throw in this FPGA, program it to emulate the part, and you can keep shipping your products. Little daughter-boards can overcome any pinout, voltage differences, or whatever.
From what I've heard, if some specific IC is out-of-stock, all of the compatible ones are also likely to be out-of-stock. Even if you scrounge up some compatible parts, next month you might run out of some other IC. It's like whack-a-mole in some industries. With something like this, at least in principle you could order one generic "gap filler" part and cover your bases, at least to a degree.
- rcxdude 5y agoIt's fairly rare to see a 'simple digitial logic' chip on a PCB nowadays. In no small part because even entire microprocessors are mostly cost-limited by packaging and placing on the board, not the cost of silicon. So anything that even a small number of customers want to do in digital logic gets adsorbed into either the microprocessor or the peripheral.
- bradfa 5y agoI think it very much depends on what market you're looking at. Often times on designs I've worked on there's a whole pile of logic gates and other simple discrete circuits which help to do housekeeping type tasks, like synchronizing power-up/down or reset circuits. Often the specialized sequencer chips are VERY expensive so a handful of discrete logic gets thrown at the problem. If you could replace a square inch of discrete logic which handles power-up/down and resets with a $0.50 FPGA you can program such that you can even better control your design and even maybe match better what the power-up/down or reset sequence should be, that's going to be an interesting thing to watch in the market.
- monocasa 5y agoCan confirm, have used MachXO chips in that space before. Despite the marketing literature, they're full FPGAs, not CPLDs.
- nickff 5y agoThis line is more of an extension of Dialog's existing options, which were extremely limited, reconfigurable logic devices. Dialog sells the Greenpak devices as flexible interfaces, and for a variety of niche applications; I looked at them a number of times, but they're not as flexible as the marketing materials make them seem.
- ksec 5y agoThis. >2021' - In February 2021, Renesas announced that it has agreed to buy Dialog Semiconductor for $5.9 billion. So a little sad Dialog ends up like IMG / PowerVR.
- floatboth 5y agoNo sadness for Dialog, I'll never forgive them for the utter abominations that are their cheap Bluetooth LE micros… Cortex-M0 with an SWD debug interface, this should be just like an nRF51, right? Hahaha, no, it's completely proprietary undocumented garbage with a Dialog SDK burned in ROM and — get this — tiny one time programmable memory for the "application" (cost-cutting to the extreme?).
- vasco 5y agoThis is hard to do because all the other characteristics of all the circuits would have to be changed, you need different engineers, etc. Over the long run maybe this switch will happen, but the supply chain issues will be gone before anyone with an existing complex product like a car has a chance to start replacing individual ICs with FPGAs
- bradfa 5y agoYou'd be amazed at how fast carrier boards with FPGAs on them can be made to solder down to existing sized pads to replace a no-longer-available part when a manufacturing line is shutdown due to parts availability. I wouldn't discount that Renesas has already been selling these FPGAs for exactly this purpose and mass production using them has already been happening for months. Often big customers get access to parts long before they're public knowledge. Renesas has a whole bunch of automotive customers already for other product lines.
- snvzz 5y agoMass availability will take too long for this to be the aim. Regardless, there's a lot of uses for a FPGA in this power and complexity bin. This will be competing with e.g. iCE40 and GW1N-1.
- InitialLastName 5y agoConsidering that Renesas has had plenty of their own issues with part shortages, it would be a little... concerning if they had decided to build new product rather than the parts their customers are screaming at them for. Luckily (or not), these parts don't appear to be available yet either.