4 ms·
This is an interesting paper. There's a more "popular science" write up here: https://theworld.org/stories/2019-01-31/european-colonization-americas-killed-10-
by PaulDavisThe1st 5y ago
This is an interesting paper. There's a more "popular science" write up here:
https://theworld.org/stories/2019-01-31/european-colonization-americas-killed-10-percent-world-population-and-caused https://theworld.org/stories/2019-01-31/european-colonizatio...
I wasn't a fan of the final line of the highlights:
> Humans contributed to Earth System changes before the Industrial Revolution
This feels like an attempt to wave a vaguely anthropogenic climate change denialist flag, not through actual denial, but "we've done stuff like this before".
What the paper calls "The Great Dying of Indigenous Peoples in the Americas" represents the death of about 10% of the total human population on the planet at the time. I'm not sure this is what you want to be comparing things to if you have the goal of in any way downplaying what fossil fuel use has done over the last 100+ years.
Of course, that may not be their intent. Even so, "two notable earth system impacts come from the death of 10% of humans worldwide and the use of fossil fuels" doesn't strike me as in any way encouraging.
- coenhyde 5y ago>> Humans contributed to Earth System changes before the Industrial Revolution > This feels like an attempt to wave a vaguely anthropogenic climate change denialist flag, not through actual denial, but "we've done stuff like this before". I think you're reading too much into this. My interpretation is just that they are pointing out a deviation from the general consensus.
- jhgb 5y ago> but "we've done stuff like this before". But we have. Holocene extinction started thousands of years ago. That's not a controversial thing at all.
- labster 5y agoIt’s still debatable how much of the early Holocene extinction was anthropogenic and how much was climate change or even predation. At least in terms of the megafauna like wooly mammoths and New World horses. Once state-organized civilization kicks off, consensus is that it was largely anthropogenic, even if it’s just us transporting diseases and pests around.
- jhgb 5y ago> or even predation That falls under "anthropogenic", too. Humans tend to eat stuff a lot.
- PaulDavisThe1st 5y agoI think the paper wants to make a distinction between affecting "earth systems" and human instigated ecosystem transformations such as the Holocene extinction.
- jhgb 5y agoWhatever "earth systems" means to you will be definitely affected by massive ecosystem changes as well.
- galaxyLogic 5y ago> "we've done stuff like this before". Yes, if the science says so. Yes, but the question is: Do we want to do stuff like that again? Human impact of American colonialization: 56 million deaths.
- sokoloff 5y agoThis seems like a large-scale trolley problem. Colonization of the Americas represents throwing the lever from one track/timeline to another. Both timelines involve massive numbers of deaths that would occur earlier than on the other one. Both involve massive numbers of specific lives that existed which wouldn’t otherwise have.
- PaulDavisThe1st 5y agoWho would have died if Europeans had not colonized the Americas?
- sokoloff 5y agoIt’s impossible to say, but it seems likely that the colonial efforts of the Britain, Dutch, Spanish, and Italians would have been directed elsewhere rather than vanishing, resulting in deaths over there instead of over here. I have to think that everything that was first invented/discovered in the Americas would have eventually been invented/discovered elsewhere, but for whatever the delay in time was, people would have suffered/died in some cases. Later, possibly a lot more European Jews in the 40s. It’s an alternative timeline with a corresponding alternative set of deaths.
- kortilla 5y agoNot colonization, exploration. The damage was already done by the time the colonizers arrived.
- inglor_cz 5y agoThe word "want" might be imprecise here. The Spanish conquistadors were fairly brutal, but they probably did not want to exterminate the population of the entire New World outright through introduction of dangerous diseases. If only because they needed some slaves and servants for their luxurious lifestyle, plus women for their physical needs. But in the 1500s, our understanding of contagious diseases was basically nonexistent and the first rational means of combating them (such as quarantine) were considered on par with prayers, holy processions and a judicial search for witches that might have caused the latest epidemic through deals with the Devil. We might be doing something similar again, and again out of ignorance.