9 ms·
Microsoft gaming chief calls for industry-wide game preservation
- giancarlostoro 5y agoThe Godfather 2 came out for PC sometime back and I swear it was on Steam, now I can't figure out how to get it, EA doesn't have it, nor Steam. It would be nice if game app stores did something like 'Movies Anywhere' but basically 'Games Everywhere' without requiring every app store to play a game.
- shmde 5y agoYou can always sail the high seas. Its morally correct.
- giancarlostoro 5y agoI havent done that in so long, as a Software Engineer I appreciate the work the developers put into the game so I usually buy games these days.
- ziml77 5y agoIf it's not available, then there's nothing to feel bad about. They aren't getting your money either way.
- shmde 5y agoYou missed the context. I am not telling you to go sail the high seas on the most modern video games released. If you wanna play a video game which is no longer available and there is no way for you to legally play it. If you cannot buy it the Devs aren't getting paid for the product and if you pirate it still the devs aren't getting paid. Either way its lose lose. PS, I know this is a weak argument but do you really think you buying a video game legally, directly fills the devs pocket or just the top management getting salary bonuses every year with the profit ?
- npteljes 5y agoOn Amazon it's $10 right now, and ebay also has discs for sale.
- hadlock 5y agoGames aren't always for sale on Steam. Ghostbusters famously was only on sale on Steam for ~1 year due to licensing reasons (I think). I bought it and it's in my library and I can download and play it, but (currently) if you want to buy that particular Ghostbusters game, it's not available. TL;DR it's entirely possible GF2 was for sale on Steam at some point in the past.
- rbanffy 5y agoNot only gaming hardware and software, but all sorts of computing artifacts. I moved to Ireland five years ago and I find it's impossibly hard to find and preserve a lot of interesting European computers because people took recycling so very seriously. It's sad, really. And DEC had a large manufacturing plant in Galway. I expected to be able to find more interesting objects.
- mistrial9 5y agoand, small business could not make any money reselling them, so they became a liability, in addition to recycling drives. source: experience in the E*Waste recycling business, and lost my shirt in it like many others
- rbanffy 5y agoWell… if the vintage computing thing continues for a couple decades, it may be worth to invest in warehouses to store the computers after they become obsolete and before they become classic.
- someperson 5y agoDon't just preserve games and hardware, but server side software is also very important. Reverse-engineered implementations of server software (eg, https://wiibrew.org/wiki/Wiimmfi https://wiibrew.org/wiki/Wiimmfi) can only go so far.
- tech234a 5y agoThe main site for Wiimmfi (with live statistics, etc.) is at https://wiimmfi.de/ https://wiimmfi.de/.
- stephbu 5y agoWhile preserving binary “playability” is important, the rapidly increasing longevity of titles and fighting bit-rot is an equally large challenge for both the game and software industry. A game is rarely just the binary execution itself, but often depends on an interconnected mesh of services and downstream partners - most of which are rarely set-up/committed to multi-decade durability, especially as the surface area of problem domain, and actors/threats have grown. For example, who’d willingly port a service that only worked on Centos 5, with SHA1 hashed TLS, or the CDN service that your game update assets were delivered from in 2007. The techniques to isolate a game from its gradually crumbling ecosystem are an after-thought when priorities are survive to shipping. I’m not inferring this is right or wrong, just indicating that it is not even in the calculus on the path to shipping.
- selfhoster11 5y ago> For example, who’d willingly port a service that only worked on Centos 5, with SHA1 hashed TLS, or the CDN service that your game update assets were delivered from in 2007. Hardcore fans of the game. Instead of making the game abandonware, one solution is to open source the whole server-side shebang and let the community sort it out themselves. If it's too difficult, at least there will be some sample source code that is known to interface with the game, so alternative server-side implementations can be built.
- KronisLV 5y ago
- someperson 5y agoPublic patch history is also very important. Most competitive online games (including Fortnite) have changed so much over the past 4 years, and if no concerted effort is made, earlier maps, weapons and other unique historical and cultural artefacts may be lost forever.
- myth17 5y agoMost of the game discs that ship today don’t have the full game bundled and require Day 1 updates. Impossible to preserve these games just with emulation if the game servers are shut down.
- mikepurvis 5y agoSure it's possible— but you do need a mechanism for capturing the update content as well. It's no longer enough to just have an ISO of the disc. My only real frame of reference on this is the Wii U (https://wiiu.hacks.guide https://wiiu.hacks.guide), but for that platform, it's absolutely trivial to either dump them from a console or even pull them directly from the original Nintendo servers (which won't be there forever of course, but you only have to pull them once for the purposes of archival).
- lapetitejort 5y agoNintendo still reigns supreme on this front. Metroid Dread launched with 1.0.0 in the box, no day one patch, nothing to download. A few bug patches have come out to fix things the average gamer would never encounter. Of course there's exceptions. Animal Crossing New Horizons dripped its content out over the course of 20 months. I'm not sure if recently minted copies come with updates on the cartridge.
- salamandersauce 5y agoI think now that AC has had its final patch they will probably update the carts if they haven't already. They did something similar for New Leaf on the 3DS.
- MonaroVXR 5y agoI got a tool that downloads those games, patches and updates for it for the Wii U.
- mikepurvis 5y agoYup, Wii U USB Helper. It's pretty magical.
- dr_dshiv 5y agoGood bye abandonware scene!
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- azalemeth 5y agoThe cynic in me thinks that this is because they've realised that the options are either a loss of history, an industry-sponsored scheme, or a legally-mandated exception to breaking DRM for preservation grounds. Microsoft's DRM on their latest xbox is insane – they actively consider the customer hostile at every available opportunity, have essentially always-online DRM, including for physical discs [1] and have had senior architects giving talks explaining how the "only" way to make a games console is to have a physically secure enclave in a chip with a truly unique root of trust, a very strict hardware watchdog, engineered resistance to under/overvoltage or clocking techniques and literally everything, including all buses and IO, encrypted to the nines. This is clearly incompatible with recording history (and also produces lots of errors like "this game isn't ready yet" – utter tosh. New Xbox consoles require an internet connection at least once to "activate" and play games – meaning any unsold will become e-waste once the servers shut down [2]). I'm glad they're making the argument -- the preservation of our culture is hugely important, and emulation is a good way to do it, particularly if industry sponsored (I think it's a shame that, e.g. there isn't a good PS4 emulator yet) -- but there's a definite false narrative behind this. [1] https://nichegamer.com/xbox-series-x-reportedly-has-always-online-drm-for-physical-xbox-one-games-disc-drive-issues/ https://nichegamer.com/xbox-series-x-reportedly-has-always-o... [2] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9E983349p7Q https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9E983349p7Q
- chrisseaton 5y ago> a legally-mandated exception to breaking DRM for preservation grounds Hmm... not sure I can imagine preservation of video games being high on legislature's priorities.
- azalemeth 5y agoIn the US at least, it's not the legislators – it's the library of congress, who in 2018 allowed (under some very limited circumstances) breaking DRM to fix hardware [1]. In the UK (and I think most of the EU) there are similar national bodies to which one can apply for permission to break DRM -- e.g. in the UK there's a long and complex review process by the civil servants at the department for culture, media and sport [2]. Of course, none of these things actually break DRM. They just say that you can break DRM without getting in trouble. Who knows, in 2055 maybe my handy device at `/dev/quantum/simultaneous_annealer` will magically break five rounds of 256-bit AES or whatever Microsoft use... [1] https://www.polygon.com/2018/10/26/18027200/video-game-drm-consoles-repair-dmca-library-of-congress https://www.polygon.com/2018/10/26/18027200/video-game-drm-c... [2] https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/technological-protection-measures-tpms-complaints-process/guidance-on-the-technological-protection-measures-tpms-complaints-process https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/technological-pro...
- rektide 5y agoFocusing on the game itself is foolish, in todays cloud-ified world. Microsoft Games for Windows Live is gone (2007 - ~2015), for example, taking down the hosting infrastructure for hundreds of games. Games I loved like Section 8 can be started & have some skirmish modes available. But the serving infrastructure is all missing, the core multiplayer expperience is not possible. My all-time favorite game ever, PC or mobile, is Titanfall Assault, a cute fast mobile game: another game that, without the vast wide cloud hosting infrastructure, is dead. All I have are some random cell-phone videos I decided to take. There's some wild wild works every now and then. Return of Reckoning, for example, is a reverse engineered server for Warhammer: Age of Reckoning, a shuttered MMO. I haven't logged in to find out, but I'm quite curious if any or all of the quest lines &c still work. If the various PvP modes work. https://www.returnofreckoning.com/ https://www.returnofreckoning.com/ As for keeping games running, emulation? He's probably almost certaining meaning consoles. And yes, the people traditionally seen as pirates have long been doing the good thing, have been doing the careful work. But I also think of works like Proton & WINE, who similarly are better at running many old games than Windows often is. Where we're headed sucks. Endless remakes of games. Oh yet another Skyrim you can purchase. Yet another Grand Theft Auto 3 you can purchase. I feel like trash for eventually having given in to Steam & having collected a huge library of games I don't really own but paid for, games that are non-transferable. The future is only getting worse, is only making us less empowered.
- tech234a 5y agoIt's worth noting that online services for games built into Windows XP, ME, and 7 (Internet Checkers, etc.) also haven't been preserved [0]. While the games were rather simple IIRC, I'm surprised that there haven't been any server reimplementations for these games given that they were included in several versions of Windows. [0]: https://answers.microsoft.com/en-us/windows/forum/all/farewell-to-microsoft-internet-games-on-windows-xp/035d5144-6c1b-49bb-b3d5-37f6355fec39 https://answers.microsoft.com/en-us/windows/forum/all/farewe...
- usui 5y agoWith death of GFWL, GTA 4 multiplayer was shut down because it depended on GFLW, supposedly. Fallout 3, whose GFLW was removed in a patch a few weeks ago, had to be recompiled with Visual Studio 2019, breaking a lot of compatibility with what modding experts believe to be the entire foundation of mods (script extender). There is a lot of things wrong with depending on a server for local software that could work perfectly on their own. Hopefully people in the future look back at the current era and realize how backwards we thought, but as you describe, it will probably only get worse. I also worry for Steam one day, even though they committed to making a plan for releasing titles if they were to ever shut down. How could they possibly honor that commitment when millions of players log in to download their terabytes of content the day they decide to shut down? Maybe they would do it in waves, but it won't be pretty.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 5y agoI've been downloading and archiving let's plays of beloved games that are becoming too difficult to run. I think this will eventually be all that we have of many titles.
- madrox 5y agoI'm really confused by this whole article given how DRM is the real barrier to emulation, and Spencer is clearly not advocating less DRM. This comes down to whether there's a profit motive by rights owners in ongoing support of a game. The outcome will be...what we already have. Games that have enough nostalgia power get adapted, like old Nintendo or Square Enix titles. And sometimes profit motive is not enough. I worked adjacent to the games division at Disney, and in spite of customer appetite for adapting their 16bit classics for new consoles, there was not a lot of internal support for years...simply because no one saw it as a project to build a career on. Until you solve THAT problem, no company will throw more support behind emulation than they already do.
- stubish 5y agoYou don't need DRM when your customers don't actually get a copy of the game. Like Microsoft's new Game Pass Ultimate feature where you can subscribe and play XBox console games from Windows, streamed from the Cloud. This is what they are up to. You no longer need to own a console or purchase the games. I imagine they will be pushing a future where games are written primarily for these virtual consoles, and using the correct APIs your games will automatically look better as the virtual consoles become more powerful. As for preserving games, this is purely a call for publishers to permanently license their games for this service (ie. if you license music, make sure the licenses don't expire and are compatible with streaming game distribution).
- thunkshift1 5y agoOlder games active == money keeps coming in for cloud gaming while they struggle to enable new ones.
- gentleman11 5y agoIt seems like free software concepts are the only possible option here. Who is going to host the multiplayer servers? Who will distribute old patches? Who will remove their drm when their licensing agreements require it? Who will distribute the old drivers and the microcode blobs? The users need source code access and the ability to modify those systems so they can do this themselves. They need the right to distribute it. Copyright protection needs to be shortened dramatically to make this possible. Imagine books with drm that nobody can open with updates that change the entire meaning that nobody will share, and no ability to reproduce the book if the papers start to fall apart. Books that nobody is able to read without connecting to some drm server, and where if you try to, you are committing a crime - it would be a loss on the scale of the famous ancient book burning events Ie, we need to be allowed to own things in some sense again, not just license them under unintelligible and constantly changing and one sided, non negotiable terms
- mrkramer 5y agoGOG.com[1][2][3] revives and preserves old video games. [1] gog.com [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/GOG.com https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/GOG.com [3] GOG: Preserving Gaming's Past & Future Documentary: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ffngZOB1U2A https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ffngZOB1U2A
- salamandersauce 5y agoI'd really like a GOG for console games. Give me a website where I can buy ROMs DRM free for old consoles legitimately. Maybe bundle in an emulator and a scan of the manual but let me do what I want with the ROM, whether that's create my own repro, run it on a flashcart, play it on my phone etc.
- ndiddy 5y agoIf you buy a Sega Genesis game on Steam, you get the ROM of the game in an “uncompressed ROMs” folder in your Steam library.
- krige 5y agoGOG shifted focus from that a long, long time ago. Now they're a normal storefront that mostly deals in indies and occassionally releases older games - and the quality of those older releases is rarely anything above slapping dosbox and/or dgvoodoo on it. Speaking from personal experience many older games are better preserved by a certain fitness named piracy site, let alone freaking steam. Gog distant third.
- kubb 5y agoWhat's the fitness site out of curiosity?
- lukyanovic 5y agoI would imagine that FitGirl repacks is the site in question.
- mysterydip 5y agoSo many are doing "remasters" or "anniversary collections" of their old games, re-releasing on modern systems sometimes even without any modification. I can't see them voluntarily killing that revenue stream.
- mountainb 5y agoThat's what they want more of, from third party publishers and developers. To the extent that hobbyists and modding stands in the way of that business model, they'll litigate to crush.
- mcnnowak 5y ago"We want to keep old games available so we can keep making money off them."
- shapefrog 5y ago"We want to keep old games unavailable so we can make money off the new ones"
- schnevets 5y agoFunny that this emerges the same week that some games of true historical significance are pulled from online retailers [1]. [1] https://kotaku.com/metal-gear-solid-games-being-removed-over-historical-fo-1848013833 https://kotaku.com/metal-gear-solid-games-being-removed-over...
- bananamerica 5y agoWhat's up with the bullet point format?
- EamonnMR 5y agoWithout concrete steps, this type of messaging from an industry leader feels disingenuous.
- stubish 5y agoI think this article is actually pushing Microsoft's cloud gaming. Right now, you can subscribe to Game Pass Ultimate and play XBox console games under Windows, streamed from virtual consoles in the Cloud. This is how they preserve games. Microsoft just want everyone to license their titles in perpetuity for this subscription service. Lots of people here wondering about DRM, which becomes completely irrelevant when you own neither game nor hardware.
- astlouis44 5y agoSurprised I had to scroll this far to see this comment. If Microsoft had it their way, they’d have Nintendo and others legacy titles “preserved” by being on Game Pass.
- stubish 5y agoIf it takes off, I think you will see the same service from Sony and Nintendo. And Microsoft will welcome them, to their Azure services.
- shmerl 5y agoGood, let MS release their games DRM-free. When will we see Freelancer on GOG? https://www.gog.com/wishlist/games/freelancer https://www.gog.com/wishlist/games/freelancer
- Yaina 5y agoI mean sure emulation works for really old games, but I most games from the last 15 years will break due to DRM issues and shut down servers... I mean how many games are broken now just because Windows Live Games got discontinued? Mirror's Edge gives me DRM-Server error messages when I start it sometimes...
- loosetypes 5y agoRelated but not totally on topic: How much would it cost to buy the rights to an essentially now semi-zombie game, that may have been been popular a decade+ ago? Say a wealthy benefactor wanted to do so strictly to open source and preserve a series, not create new titles. Maybe for a series that stills sells copies here and there, but is well past it’s prime? Say, the Empire Earth franchise? Or something with relatively more recent releases, like Heroes of Might and Magic? Would it be the millions? Would one be able to do so for individual titles within a series?
- nmfisher 5y agoI follow a bunch of people on Twitter who have tried to do this at one point or another. Money never seems to be the sticking point, the problem is (a) figuring out who actually owns the rights, and then (b) actually tracking that person (or company) down. If we're talking about games from the 80s and 90s, many of those rights changed hands a number of times and the people/companies involved have since died/dissolved/retired/disappeared off the radar. Another very good reason for a shorter copyright expiration period.
- ThunderSizzle 5y agoDoesn't copyright require enforcement? If no one claims it or enforces copyright, then nothing is stopping anyone from attempting to work on it, but without the source, it'd be all reverse engineering or something to that affect.
- ezoe 5y agoWhy don't they just stop making specialized gaming consoles? That's the start.
- lobocinza 5y agoJust don't DRM. At least not on single player games, music, books, etc.