3 ms·
Lots of reasons, but for one, it was horribly managed. I use to consult with Microsoft on product and UX. There was one meeting with the product unit manager (P
by cududa 5y ago
Lots of reasons, but for one, it was horribly managed. I use to consult with Microsoft on product and UX. There was one meeting with the product unit manager (PUM) I was in with some others.
My review was … harsh. I was a lot younger, and am still embarrassed about how I delivered my feedback, but it was accurate.
The PUM was giving a presentation on it, started talking about embedded font support plans. Had already interviewed the dev team (which he wasn’t aware of) asking about that. They said it wasn’t on a roadmap/ something anyone was working on. I asked him who specifically was working on it in the engineering team. Vague answer, took a note.
The VP of Windows PM had slipped in the back unbeknown to him.
He kept going with his presentation. I stopped him and asked if it had compatibility with Vista SP1 (it didn’t and I knew this because I tried it), and he goes into this whole spiel about all the work his team did to get it ready for SP1.
I turned my laptop around and tried to install it on the most current org-wide SP1 release and it failed. He said they’d look into it.
He kept going about how great public feedback had been. Stopped him again to ask when the public could try it. He said it was live on the landing page. Asked him if he was sure about that. He was emphatically certain. Asked him if he’d say that in front of his VP. Said yes. Asked him if he wanted to change his answer. Said no.
So I turned my laptop around again and low and behold it was not on the landing page or publicly available. Said something like “so you just lied in front of <VP Name>”.
He was very confused and said he’d never lie to her. Told him to turn around and pointed out he literally just lied “in front” of her (did air quotes).
Not sure if he was just a showboat pitchman saying things he knew were lies, or was just inept and never double checked very basic things (like SP1 compatibility or public availability) his team told him had happened.
So comments here on technical deficiencies and timing are accurate, but the product unit had a terrible leader. Left hand had no idea what the right hand was doing.
- jdsully 5y agoWere windows org meetings typically this hostile? Seems like a different world from my experience in the office org (Note: I did nothing related to XPS, I'm curious about the general team dynamics).
- cududa 5y agoNot in my experience, that one was just a particular kind of bad because he really didn’t know anything about his product. Like I said, still feel bad about how aggressive I was, but truly, the dude kept saying stuff completely disconnected from reality. I was just an “external stakeholder”.