5 ms·
The cost of the equipment to do component levels repairs on an iPhone is well over 100% of the cost of a new iPhone. And the skills required are not reasonable
by kube-system 5y ago
The cost of the equipment to do component levels repairs on an iPhone is well over 100% of the cost of a new iPhone. And the skills required are not reasonable to expect of any but a handful of consumers. The repairs are difficult enough that literally Apple doesn't do them.
- ComputerGuru 5y agoEquipment costs are capex and amortized over all repairs. Apple doesn’t do them because of economies of scale and the cost of hiring talented repairers.
- kube-system 5y agoThis announcement is about consumer self-service repair. Not repair facilities justifying a capital expense. But as you mention, the associated labor cost is prohibitive even for Apple. So who exactly is component-level repair of iPhones a good option for? It seems that it's more of an ideological position than a practical repair technique.
- q3k 5y ago> The cost of the equipment to do component levels repairs on an iPhone is well over 100% of the cost of a new iPhone. Nah. If you know what's broken (which is often a cheap multimeter test away given you have the right schematics/boardview files) you can totally get by with a cheap hotair (858D-style clone for $60), a decent soldering iron (even a dinky TS100, $70), and some decent miscellaneous tools and supplies (tweezers, flux, solder). This is equipment anyone that does any sort of electronics should already have. And likely equipment you'll find at a local hackerspace. For 01005-sized SMD passives you'll most likely also need a cheap binocular microscope (an amscope on a gooseneck for $150 will do), but you can totally do 0201-level stuff without one if you have good eyesight. It gets a bit more expensive if you're doing BGA swaps from donor boards because you need to reball them, but it's still easily all within a $1k budget for all the tools required. But hey, if Apple just allowed you to buy their BGA components new instead of people having to use donor boards, this wouldn't be needed. Component level repair is not voodoo magic, you just need practice and a steady hand. Equipment is cheaper than ever. Pretending it's out of the hands of an average curious hacker is playing into Apple's bullshit about how magical and integrated their devices are and that therefore they're the only ones that can possibly work on them.
- kube-system 5y agoI'll concede that it's possible with cheaper equipment. But the people who actually do this work tend to have $1000+ in equipment at their disposal. And there are very few of them. And none of them would be accurately described as "consumers", or even "DIY-inclined consumers". These people have skillsets so unique that their skills are beyond the capabilities of most professionals in the electronics repair field.
- q3k 5y ago> And none of them would be accurately described as "consumers", or even "DIY-inclined consumers". I think there's much more people that are somewhat inclined to learn these skills and that have access to such equipment than you think. And plenty who don't work in any industry related to electronics that just happen to tinker with electronics as a hobby and effectively have gotten very proficient with a soldering iron. Don't underestimate curious hackers from places where fixing your own equipment makes economic sense. For me, disassembling my iPhone and replacing its battery was much more difficult than any sort of component-level repair. So if we're letting 'consumers' do that, why not let them also try component level repair?
- kube-system 5y agoThis isn't an Apple-sponsored educational exercise. It's a consumer-facing program where they are sharing some of the parts, instructions, and components they use for repairs. While I think Apple should share repair information, I don't think it is a reasonable expectation for them to provide information on repairs that they don't even do. We don't expect this level of detail from any other industry, even when they are required by law to provide repair information. Toyota doesn't give information on how to weld damaged engine parts, even if it's a technically feasible repair. They don't do this repair themselves, they replace it, so how would they be expected to provide this level of detail?
- 29083011397778 5y ago> people who actually do this work tend to have $1000+ in equipment > none of them would be accurately described as "consumers", or even "DIY-inclined consumers". I'm assuming that nearly every single one of the people in your first quote, got there by starting off as someone described in your second quote.
- passivate 5y agoHate to say it, but that is factually incorrect. (1) Component level repair is done daily by multiple repair shops. Apple not doing something doesn't make it impossible or uneconomical. (2) Competition and availability of parts/tools/manuals will bring down costs. Apple forces suppliers to not sell parts to repair shops driving up acquisition costs for parts. (3) If someone still doesn't want to use a third party repair shop, they can take it to Apple. (4) Labor prices vary throughout the world. Smart people exist everywhere. Lets focus on the real issue - reducing e-waste and promoting longer device lifetimes via repair.
- kube-system 5y agoThis program is not for repair shops. Apple not producing repair procedures for component-level repairs does make it impossible for them to share those procedures... because they don't have them to share.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- passivate 5y agoWe don't need any "repair procedures" from Apple. What needs to stop is Apple choking the repair market by blocking sales of components by third-parties. I'm sure Apple has designed the electronics really well, so there is no complaint there. But they're still using normal components in a normal circuit doing normal things. At the electronics level, a competent tech can diagnose and fix/replace faulty components with some working knowledge of electronics and a curious mind. Like with anything else people get better with experience so there may very well be a difference in the amount of repair each individual repair shop can do. As a society, our final goal should be to reduce e-waste and promote longer device lifetimes through reuse and repair in all industries.
- kube-system 5y ago>We don't need any "repair procedures" from Apple. Who is we? Experts? Or consumers repairing their own devices? For the latter, people absolutely do need repair procedures. The first stop for most people is a site like iFixit -- a site founded on the need for documentation to repair an Apple laptop. While we certainly need to be mindful of e-waste, I'm not convinced that component-level repairs are unquestionably a net benefit to society vs module-level repairs. Process efficiency, shipping, warehousing, packaging, materials-used, and the environmental controls in place have huge environmental impacts as well. The total environmental impact is much more complicated than the board itself. I understand and share the desire to tinker with and repair anything regardless of complexity. However, as someone who also produces products, I also think that the law should be reasonable in what it forces me to do when I create something.