5 ms·
> Fun fact: every single example in the Wikipedia "embrace, extend, and extinguish" article https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Embrace,_extend,_and_extinguish#Exampl
by AnthonyMouse 5y ago
> Fun fact: every single example in the Wikipedia "embrace, extend, and extinguish" article https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Embrace,_extend,_and_extinguish#Examples_by_Microsoft https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Embrace,_extend,_and_extinguis... is something that failed (IE is dead, Office 365 works great on non-MS browsers, MS has no influence on Java, MSN Messenger is dead, MAPI is dead, etc.).
You're assuming the goal of these things was to replace the product, when the goal was to destroy the competitor.
Netscape is dead (and Firefox is dying), all the historical competitors to MS Office are dead or have negligible market share, Java never got enough market share to make it easy for people to switch away from Windows, AIM/ICQ/whatever are all dead (and worse, nobody really uses XMPP or other open protocols), hardly anybody runs their own email server anymore, etc.
They successfully destroyed all of the independent versions of these things, so that now their competitors are only the likes of Google and Facebook who get where they are by leveraging their own dominant market positions in other markets.
It's also kind of disingenuous to say "IE is dead" and "MSN Messenger is dead" and ignore Edge and Skype and Teams etc.
- 0x0nyandesu 5y agoWindows market share is the lowest it's ever been. Haven't used windows myself since March 2020 and nothing is making me want to change that.
- lotsofpulp 5y agoAs far as I am concerned, the whole future of Microsoft is Azure and extracting rent from Office.
- Tozen 5y agoWell, until the LibreOffice Foundation gets a bit smarter or greater business support from some heavy hitters. Microsoft relying on Office is on shaky ground. People arguably use MS Office out of habit and since it's a forced de facto standard at work. But, there is no reason they can't switch to LibreOffice for 95% plus of what people are doing.
- lotsofpulp 5y agoLeaders of large organizations need someone outside the organization to blame when things go wrong. You cannot do that with Libre Office.
- 0x0nyandesu 5y agoMy org is basically at this point exclusively Google docs. Chromebooks for support staff and Linux laptops for devs. I think only sales is still on windows.
- ta3567367 5y agoUnderestimating the JVM there a bit. Sucks that Oracle tried to monster it, but it's a solid workhorse. Also, down with MS, leopards don't change their stripes so easily, a change of helm won't turn a company with greed so deeply entrenched in their DNA. *Spots not stripes. Or tigers.
- AnthonyMouse 5y agoSo this requires some context. Java was released by Sun Microsystems, a Unix vendor with their own hardware architecture. The big feature was "write once, run anywhere." Write the program once and it would run on Windows/Intel as well as Solaris/SPARC. The Java language wasn't horrible and WORA was a big advantage in the days when there were half a dozen Unix vendors plus Mac and Windows and Novell Netware etc. So it was becoming popular, and every app the developer decided to write in Java was one that wasn't tied to the Win32 API and therefore Windows. It's also possible to compile other languages to Java bytecode as along as they didn't use OS-specific APIs -- and Java provided platform-independent ones. So there was a real risk that everything would end up running on a platform-independent JVM. Which Microsoft successfully prevented from happening for long enough for Sun to run out of money and get consumed by Oracle.
- com2kid 5y agoIt is hard to remember, or for younger developers to believe, but there was a time in the mid 90s when: 1. Most programing languages sucked 2. Java was fresh and new Java had a lot going for it. It was free, with a functioning IDE that had a working graphical debugger! MS had just about finished killing Delphi (which also cost $$) and over in *nix land the GUI libraries were fighting amongst themselves and Linux wasn't something even an average developer was going to install. So you had Perl, raw C, the horrors that were DSLs and frameworks written in the c++ of the time, then Java came along. Applets failed, sure. And back then everyone wanted their GUIs to look like the platform native UI (how times have changed!) but Swing was super easy to write UIs in. I'd wager the majority of programmers, outside of ex-LISP folks, didn't know what closures were, and functions as first class objects wasn't on anyone's mind. So all of Java's shortcomings didn't seem like a big deal. It "compiled" fast, had actual packages you could distribute and import easily, and the compiler errors made sense. So yeah Java was a fresh breath when it came out. Then c# came out a bit later and was basically better in a million small ways from day 1, except it wasn't open source so a community never built up around it in the same way. Now days we are spoiled for languages to choose from.
- stickfigure 5y agoNone of those examples have anything to do with "embrace, extend, extinguish"? And they're misleading at best. Netscape died because browsers became a part of the baseline operating system. That wasn't Microsoft's choice, that's just de-facto reality (see: every other OS). Just imagine shipping a computing device today without a browser! Steve Jobs put it best (to a different company): You're a feature, not a product. Excel was a vastly superior product to the competition. I used it back when Lotus was still running DOS character mode. The only really competitive product today is Google Sheets, because collaboration is a killer feature. And Google Sheets is doing very well. Java was never a Windows replacement. And as a platform it is doing just fine. Instant messaging died out due to Facebook/Snapchat/Twitter/Slack/etc. It's not like everyone is using Skype (which MS bought, not built, and long after the IM dust had settled). Google dominates email, not MS/hotmail. And spammers killed the "run your own email server" approach. It requires professional knowledge to get email delivered these days.
- selectodude 5y ago>Steve Jobs put it best (to a different company): You're a feature, not a product. Dropbox, which has also been falling apart trying to become a product.
- nitrogen 5y agoNone of those examples have anything to do with "embrace, extend, extinguish"? They all do. IE is eee of HTML and the web. MS Java and VisualJ or whatever it was called was eee of Sun Java. ActiveX was eee of the web browser. That wasn't Microsoft's choice, that's just de-facto reality That's what BG said in his deposition, but MS was the only company who embedded IE into the OS to make ActiveDesktop and put VBScript and ActiveX into IE. Java was never a Windows replacement. AWT and Swing and browser applets were Windows replacements. Instant messaging died out due to Facebook/Snapchat/Twitter/Slack/etc. You're talking about things that happened ten years later. There was a time when one app would connect to every network. Google dominates email, not MS/hotmail. MS Exchange dominates email.
- dralley 5y ago
- jacquesm 5y agoAnd they can't even get those right, between Skype and Teams it would be hard to pick the bigger failure.