3 ms·
Reading 30 studies certainly seems to be a bad way to learn anything unless you're conducting a meta-analysis of them. For one thing, you'd get tired. But just
by astrange 5y ago
Reading 30 studies certainly seems to be a bad way to learn anything unless you're conducting a meta-analysis of them. For one thing, you'd get tired. But just shoving 30 pieces of information into your head and forgetting some of them doesn't help you find out which of them were correct.
- nomel 5y ago> For one thing, you'd get tired. Suggesting that there's no way someone could have the mental stamina to read 30 papers, over the course of two years, is completely ridiculous, insulting, and invalidates your viewpoint, in my opinion.
- astrange 5y agoI was talking about all at once. If it’s over years I would rather wait for a meta analysis, but it depends on the reliability of the early papers.
- nomel 5y agoWhy are you assuming they tried to read it in one sitting? Nothing remotely suggests that in the comment thread. All we know is that they read 30 papers sometime within the last two years or so. You chose a perspective, and just reinforced it, that they were incapable of extracting anything useful from reading those papers, which is insulting. It could be that they read a paper every couple of days, or perhaps when they became available. For some reason, it seems you've already decided that they're incompetent.
- jacquesm 5y agoEspecially in a field in which you are not trained, do not have the background knowledge required to understand the various qualifications and established best practices in. That gap can be absolutely enormous, even for fields that are peripherally related. Specialization is there for a reason, the body of knowledge that we now command is way too large for any single individual to absorb to a substantial depth.