6 ms·

> Never owned a credit card, don't have the slightest wish to do so. Bizarrely, never owning a credit card will negatively impact your credit rating.

gifnamething 5y ago
Expecting someone to lend you 6 figures when you've never displayed any ability to repay 2 is far more bizarre.
- maccard 5y ago
  A credit rating basically isn't considered for a mortgage in the UK. They will check a report, and maybe request you pay outstanding debts (I was asked to clear my CC balance before completion both times), but unless you have a fraud marker or are bankrupt it won't affect you. Mortgages are secured on the asset, so it's far less risky than a personal loan of 5x less - the bank can seize the asset and force the sale of the home (and that difference in risk is reflected in the difference in borrowing rates).
  - chanc3e 5y ago
    My experience is they do indeed dig into your credit report and will approve/deny based on it. Not sure where your information to the contrary comes from? https://www.which.co.uk/money/mortgages-and-property/mortgages/getting-a-mortgage-with-poor-credit/bad-credit-mortgages-ay2m91n0u9mu https://www.which.co.uk/money/mortgages-and-property/mortgag...
    - carnitine 5y ago
      They explicitly mention a report. It’s just the number rating which is irrelevant.
  - TheOtherHobbes 5y ago
    Most UK CC T&Cs state explicitly "If you have a home, we will go after it if you default." Personal loans have similar recourse. Neither are truly unsecured. It just takes longer than an outright repossession because it takes two or three court claims instead of just one. The debt collection industry relies on this, and regularly forces sales of property to pay back CC and other debts. So CCs are disastrous for people who can't pay their debts. Not only are the interest rates extortionate, but for lenders they're almost as safe as a secured loan. And because of the high rates they can be considerably more profitable.
- egman_ekki 5y ago
  Maybe you displayed the ability to not go into debt unnecessarily, which could be also a signal of financial ability. Getting into debt just to demonstrate you can pay it off is a bit like having to catch a virus so that the doctor can tell you you're healthy once you're done with it. But it's true that in the era of negative interest rates, only silly people don't owe money.
  - another-dave 5y ago
    I guess using the analogy — your doctor won't tell you "you've a great immune system" if you've never caught a bug at all. Maybe you've a really weak immune system, they just don't know. Not going into debt unnecessarily is a great thing, but it's not a data point in your favour, it's the absence of a data point.
tazjin 5y ago
I don't think that's really true outside of the US.
- stuaxo 5y ago
  No, it's true in the UK. I had this issue, and had to get a credit card and buy stuff on it for a year... basically without using credit you may not have a credit rating. I always lose my cards and have to get them replaced, so have been back on just a debit card for a few years now.
  - chanc3e 5y ago
    Can second this. I had to get a credit card as mortgage got denied because my credit record didn't exist. Three months after the card, I got approved. This is despite me earning an extravagant wage relative to my age for over a decade and never missing rent/utilities/council tax. Bad system.
    - b112 5y ago
      I think this is being misstated by GP. It isn't that a lack of credit card hurts your credit rating, but that a lack of any credit hurts your credit rating in Canada or the US. There are other ways to get an initial credit rating than a credit card, although I agree that this is the path most easy, and chosen by many to get that first rating. The method I employed, was to buy a car and had a parent cosign. I made all the payments, and this was enough to kick start, and give me at good credit rating.
      - mattowen_uk 5y ago
        Ah but, for most people it's easier to get a low-limit credit card in the UK, than it is to get any other unsecured loan. I also didn't say 'you need a credit card to get a good credit score', I said not having one will negatively impact your score. This is 100% correct; Your credit score is made up of various metrics on how you manage debt, one of which is credit cards. You will get a % boost if you have a card that you manage well, whereas without a credit card, you will get no boost at all in that category. Granted, you may make up for it overall in other categories, but in the main, for most people, my statement still stands. Credit scores start at 0, and only improve if you show you can manage debt across multiple products.
swarnie 5y ago
Such a broken system..... I have to spend everything on a credit card, then when i get home from shopping 45 minutes later go and pay it off using a debt card. Its so unfriendly for the consumer.
- cjrp 5y ago
  I've not seen a credit card where you can't automatically pay the full balance by direct debit each month. You do still have to do some maths (actual balance = current account balance - card balance) but I don't worry about it not being paid off.
- adav 5y ago
  Why not rely on direct debit to pay the full balance?
  - swarnie 5y ago
    Poor management on my part, i'd rather know its done and keep a watch on my spending day to day.
    - scatters 5y ago
      Which demonstrates that you in fact are bad with money, so the system is working as intended. If you don't trust yourself with day-to-day spending, why should a lender trust you with a loan representing months or years of income?
      - swarnie 5y ago
        Oof.... OK mate. Keeping an eye on my spending and borrowing on a daily basis is now a negative? I assume you sit in the same camp that thinks i can afford £1400 monthly rent for 5 years but not an £800 mortgage yeah?
        scatters 5y ago
        Keeping an eye on your spending is great, but you can equally do that with credit; it's easy to look at or download transactions in your credit card app or website. Unless of course you don't trust yourself not to overspend, in which case my point stands. You are aware that interest rates have been incredibly low for years? They have to go up to keep a lid on inflation, and the BoE needs to be able to do that without worrying about mortgage borrowers being overstretched.
deleted 5y ago
[deleted]
deleted 5y ago
[deleted]
socialdemocrat 5y ago
I know this is a thing in the US, but in Norway where I am from it doesn’t matter. Nobody gets a credit card here improve credit rating. I doubt people do they in most of Europe. When somebody does a credit check on you they don’t get a score, only a remark on whether that person has done any negative with respect to their credit worthiness. Thus there is really only the negatives which count.
- fomine3 5y ago
  Credit "score" isn't exist here in Japan, but higher age and zero credit history is bad because they can't be distinguished to bankruptcy person.
- tigershark 5y ago
  In U.K. it definitely helps your credit score.
  - GoodbyeMrChips 5y ago
    Except we don't have a "credit score" in the UK. Credit reference agencies instead report credit history. The difference is a subtle but very important one, as it allows companies to assess your individual circumstances, rather than base decisions on an arbitrary score. The above misunderstanding is so commonplace that the Redit UKPersoanlFinace sub had (has?) a bot explaining this on every UK post mentioning 'credit score'. Here "credit scores" are instead a marketing gimmick launched by credit reference agencies to get consumers to subscribe to monitoring services. The 'score' they give is meaningless. https://blog.moneysavingexpert.com/2021/06/martin-lewis-credit-score-myths/ https://blog.moneysavingexpert.com/2021/06/martin-lewis-cred...
    - ryanlol 5y ago
      It works exactly like this in the US too. The numbers shown to consumers are not what big financial institutions base their decisions on. By the same logic credit scores don’t exist in the US either. It’s just an approximation, your bank still makes their own decisions.
mnw21cam 5y ago
It's more correct to say that never having any credit facility negatively impacts your credit rating. I have a credit card now, but several years ago I didn't, and I had a perfect credit rating, by dint of the multitude of other credit agreements that I had for the general running of my life, like mortgage, telephone, internet, etc.
mbg721 5y ago
The way this works in the US is nuts. I had to get a parent to co-sign the loan for my first car (or else they wouldn't lend me money at any rate), but then I spent a year paying a monthly fee to borrow my own money with a "secured credit card" and instantly I'm good for 40 grand, apparently.
- effie 5y ago
  Isn't it completely rational from the lender standpoint? First they make sure you will be profitable for them (involve other people who can be milked), then they offer you money and hope you can't pay back on time.
  - mbg721 5y ago
    I mean, maybe, but it didn't work; I'm one of those deadbeats who makes all the payments before they're due.
- BenjiWiebe 5y ago
  That's not how it works in the US currently. You go through that process to get your first credit card, yes, but you do not get approved for $40k. My first card was $500. My best one now (with excellent credit score) is $5k IIRC. If you got approved for $40k, there's something else funny going on.
retube 5y ago
Not in the UK

gifnamething 5y ago

Expecting someone to lend you 6 figures when you've never displayed any ability to repay 2 is far more bizarre.

maccard 5y ago
A credit rating basically isn't considered for a mortgage in the UK. They will check a report, and maybe request you pay outstanding debts (I was asked to clear my CC balance before completion both times), but unless you have a fraud marker or are bankrupt it won't affect you. Mortgages are secured on the asset, so it's far less risky than a personal loan of 5x less - the bank can seize the asset and force the sale of the home (and that difference in risk is reflected in the difference in borrowing rates).
- chanc3e 5y ago
  My experience is they do indeed dig into your credit report and will approve/deny based on it. Not sure where your information to the contrary comes from? https://www.which.co.uk/money/mortgages-and-property/mortgages/getting-a-mortgage-with-poor-credit/bad-credit-mortgages-ay2m91n0u9mu https://www.which.co.uk/money/mortgages-and-property/mortgag...
  - carnitine 5y ago
    They explicitly mention a report. It’s just the number rating which is irrelevant.
- TheOtherHobbes 5y ago
  Most UK CC T&Cs state explicitly "If you have a home, we will go after it if you default." Personal loans have similar recourse. Neither are truly unsecured. It just takes longer than an outright repossession because it takes two or three court claims instead of just one. The debt collection industry relies on this, and regularly forces sales of property to pay back CC and other debts. So CCs are disastrous for people who can't pay their debts. Not only are the interest rates extortionate, but for lenders they're almost as safe as a secured loan. And because of the high rates they can be considerably more profitable.
egman_ekki 5y ago
Maybe you displayed the ability to not go into debt unnecessarily, which could be also a signal of financial ability. Getting into debt just to demonstrate you can pay it off is a bit like having to catch a virus so that the doctor can tell you you're healthy once you're done with it. But it's true that in the era of negative interest rates, only silly people don't owe money.
- another-dave 5y ago
  I guess using the analogy — your doctor won't tell you "you've a great immune system" if you've never caught a bug at all. Maybe you've a really weak immune system, they just don't know. Not going into debt unnecessarily is a great thing, but it's not a data point in your favour, it's the absence of a data point.

tazjin 5y ago

I don't think that's really true outside of the US.

stuaxo 5y ago
No, it's true in the UK. I had this issue, and had to get a credit card and buy stuff on it for a year... basically without using credit you may not have a credit rating. I always lose my cards and have to get them replaced, so have been back on just a debit card for a few years now.
- chanc3e 5y ago
  Can second this. I had to get a credit card as mortgage got denied because my credit record didn't exist. Three months after the card, I got approved. This is despite me earning an extravagant wage relative to my age for over a decade and never missing rent/utilities/council tax. Bad system.
  - b112 5y ago
    I think this is being misstated by GP. It isn't that a lack of credit card hurts your credit rating, but that a lack of any credit hurts your credit rating in Canada or the US. There are other ways to get an initial credit rating than a credit card, although I agree that this is the path most easy, and chosen by many to get that first rating. The method I employed, was to buy a car and had a parent cosign. I made all the payments, and this was enough to kick start, and give me at good credit rating.
    - mattowen_uk 5y ago
      Ah but, for most people it's easier to get a low-limit credit card in the UK, than it is to get any other unsecured loan. I also didn't say 'you need a credit card to get a good credit score', I said not having one will negatively impact your score. This is 100% correct; Your credit score is made up of various metrics on how you manage debt, one of which is credit cards. You will get a % boost if you have a card that you manage well, whereas without a credit card, you will get no boost at all in that category. Granted, you may make up for it overall in other categories, but in the main, for most people, my statement still stands. Credit scores start at 0, and only improve if you show you can manage debt across multiple products.

swarnie 5y ago

Such a broken system..... I have to spend everything on a credit card, then when i get home from shopping 45 minutes later go and pay it off using a debt card. Its so unfriendly for the consumer.

cjrp 5y ago
I've not seen a credit card where you can't automatically pay the full balance by direct debit each month. You do still have to do some maths (actual balance = current account balance - card balance) but I don't worry about it not being paid off.
adav 5y ago
Why not rely on direct debit to pay the full balance?
- swarnie 5y ago
  Poor management on my part, i'd rather know its done and keep a watch on my spending day to day.
  - scatters 5y ago
    Which demonstrates that you in fact are bad with money, so the system is working as intended. If you don't trust yourself with day-to-day spending, why should a lender trust you with a loan representing months or years of income?
    - swarnie 5y ago
      Oof.... OK mate. Keeping an eye on my spending and borrowing on a daily basis is now a negative? I assume you sit in the same camp that thinks i can afford £1400 monthly rent for 5 years but not an £800 mortgage yeah?
      - scatters 5y ago
        Keeping an eye on your spending is great, but you can equally do that with credit; it's easy to look at or download transactions in your credit card app or website. Unless of course you don't trust yourself not to overspend, in which case my point stands. You are aware that interest rates have been incredibly low for years? They have to go up to keep a lid on inflation, and the BoE needs to be able to do that without worrying about mortgage borrowers being overstretched.

deleted 5y ago

[deleted]

deleted 5y ago

[deleted]

socialdemocrat 5y ago

I know this is a thing in the US, but in Norway where I am from it doesn’t matter. Nobody gets a credit card here improve credit rating. I doubt people do they in most of Europe. When somebody does a credit check on you they don’t get a score, only a remark on whether that person has done any negative with respect to their credit worthiness. Thus there is really only the negatives which count.

fomine3 5y ago
Credit "score" isn't exist here in Japan, but higher age and zero credit history is bad because they can't be distinguished to bankruptcy person.
tigershark 5y ago
In U.K. it definitely helps your credit score.
- GoodbyeMrChips 5y ago
  Except we don't have a "credit score" in the UK. Credit reference agencies instead report credit history. The difference is a subtle but very important one, as it allows companies to assess your individual circumstances, rather than base decisions on an arbitrary score. The above misunderstanding is so commonplace that the Redit UKPersoanlFinace sub had (has?) a bot explaining this on every UK post mentioning 'credit score'. Here "credit scores" are instead a marketing gimmick launched by credit reference agencies to get consumers to subscribe to monitoring services. The 'score' they give is meaningless. https://blog.moneysavingexpert.com/2021/06/martin-lewis-credit-score-myths/ https://blog.moneysavingexpert.com/2021/06/martin-lewis-cred...
  - ryanlol 5y ago
    It works exactly like this in the US too. The numbers shown to consumers are not what big financial institutions base their decisions on. By the same logic credit scores don’t exist in the US either. It’s just an approximation, your bank still makes their own decisions.

mnw21cam 5y ago

It's more correct to say that never having any credit facility negatively impacts your credit rating. I have a credit card now, but several years ago I didn't, and I had a perfect credit rating, by dint of the multitude of other credit agreements that I had for the general running of my life, like mortgage, telephone, internet, etc.

mbg721 5y ago

The way this works in the US is nuts. I had to get a parent to co-sign the loan for my first car (or else they wouldn't lend me money at any rate), but then I spent a year paying a monthly fee to borrow my own money with a "secured credit card" and instantly I'm good for 40 grand, apparently.

effie 5y ago
Isn't it completely rational from the lender standpoint? First they make sure you will be profitable for them (involve other people who can be milked), then they offer you money and hope you can't pay back on time.
- mbg721 5y ago
  I mean, maybe, but it didn't work; I'm one of those deadbeats who makes all the payments before they're due.
BenjiWiebe 5y ago
That's not how it works in the US currently. You go through that process to get your first credit card, yes, but you do not get approved for $40k. My first card was $500. My best one now (with excellent credit score) is $5k IIRC. If you got approved for $40k, there's something else funny going on.

retube 5y ago

Not in the UK