2 ms·
You could try spreading the truth instead of bullying people? I do care about my mothers health you know. And if a doctor isn't convinced by a large number of s
by roenxi 5y ago
You could try spreading the truth instead of bullying people? I do care about my mothers health you know. And if a doctor isn't convinced by a large number of studies I want them to explain why not rather than call me a conspiracy peddler.
The way someone gets ivermectin is to walk a doctor through the evidence they've seen and then ask them to prescribe it.
- jacquesm 5y agoIf you care about your mothers' health then you shouldn't engage in quackery. > The way someone gets ivermectin is to walk a doctor through the evidence they've seen and then ask them to prescribe it. That is factually incorrect, no doctor in their right mind will allow the patients to effectively prescribe their own controversial and in some cases downright dangerous medicine.
- ddingus 5y agoIs that not what the ADS we see on TV are helping patients to do? I am being dead serious here. Confused. And to be clear, it should not work that way at all. I think it does work that way a lot more than many of us would care to admit. Happy to be shown I am wrong.
- jonnycoder 5y agoEnlighten us on how it is "dangerous" medicine. Sources please.
- rscho 5y agoI am a doc. I am also a medical researcher, but you (and most other people here) _have_ to realize that the vast majority of practicing MDs are _not_ scientists, and understand almost nothing when reading medical studies. And that's fine, because it's not their job. The profession is bound by guidelines and expert opinion. Experts do research, formulate guidelines, and guidelines get applied by practitioners. And no, that absolutely does not mean you know better than the average doc because you've read 10 studies. That's telling a highly specialized labourer that you know the job better because you've read 0.0001% of the theory.
- deadpannini 5y agoThe dissonance here is intense. On the one hand, "practicing MDs ... understand almost nothing when reading medical studies", but also I don't "know better than the average doc [just] because [I've] read 10 studies." Is the idea that doctors deserve deference because they are conditioned to submit to guidelines formulated by experts? There is a lack of consensus on many long-standing, common medical questions, much less novel diseases. When I ask my GP about prostate screening, for example, he lays out the current state of research as best he can, but delegates the decision to me. Why is the COVID situation different, given that experts are still fighting through a figurative fog of war?
- nickspacek 5y agoGreat point. Perhaps the idea is that neither you nor the avg doc can conclude much from reading 10 studies. Therefore, defer to the experts? As to why the COVID situation is different, presumably because prostate cancer screening affects only you (and perhaps your family in the case of a true/false positive/negative diagnosis), and COVID represents a threat to everyone around you, and everyone around them, etc.
- deadpannini 5y agoI wasn't clear. Most of the time, as with prostrate screenings, one of the following is true: - There is no expert consensus (on treatments, etiology, etc.). - Consensus exists, but the level of consensus is overstated. - There is broad consensus, but with relatively low confidence. A generalized public health threat like a pandemic doesn't change the epistemological calculus, nor the sociology of knowledge.
- kaba0 5y agoBut why do you even assume that it works? The doctor might not be able to disprove it because disproving is fundamentally hard and may not even be possible. But the direction that makes sense is that we prove if something does work/has an effect. The zero hypothesis is the long standing default, that a random thing will not cure this illness. The alternative hypothesis is that it does cure it and then we can analyze the results based on the results of a fair trial.