3 ms·
Going through one of those studies from https://ivmmeta.com/ https://ivmmeta.com/ on YouTube would be a risky proposition for a YouTuber. It goes against YouTub
by roenxi 5y ago
Going through one of those studies from https://ivmmeta.com/ https://ivmmeta.com/ on YouTube would be a risky proposition for a YouTuber. It goes against YouTube's medical misinformation policy [0]. It is pretty clear that a study with that sort of effect size could encourage someone to take Ivermectin. Particularly the "Categorical claims that Ivermectin is an effective treatment for COVID-19
" would be a worry depending on how the censors feel that day. They'd potentially be arguing a technicality against some Silicon Valley type with an axe to grind.
Despite the fact that it appears those studies were honest, and picking up an actual factual effect. Now it turns out, laughably in hindsight, that the effect is probably whether people had parasites or not and I hadn't thought of that. But it isn't obvious how I'm going to figure that out without someone pointing it out to me. Ideally on YouTube where there are some really good channels covering COVID, often with actual doctors involved.
No-one else seems to have figured it out either, given I've seen lots of people shouting at each other and none suggested it as a possibility.
[0] https://support.google.com/youtube/answer/9891785?hl=en https://support.google.com/youtube/answer/9891785?hl=en
- joshuamorton 5y ago> Now it turns out, laughably in hindsight, that the effect is probably whether people had parasites or not and I hadn't thought of that. Your eagerness to jump on to this idea (which is a cool theory, and isn't meritless, but it should be stressed is a theory that a psychiatrist and social commentator came up with) makes me think you should be wary of how personally susceptible you are to what I'm going to call "fetishization of contrarianism". It's fun to be right, and fun to be right when other people are wrong. It's cool. But its easy to move from "I don't implicitly value what experts say" to "I implicitly distrust so-called experts", which you appear to be doing throughout this and other threads. You've further jumped from what could uncharitably be called a conspiracy theory to a counter-conspiracy theory. Scott even presents his idea as, essentially a conspiracy theory: > It feels right to me because it’s the most troll-ish possible solution. Everybody was wrong! "everyone was wrong", look at me, I'm right, here's a fantastic narrative that perfectly ties up all the loose ends. He looks smart and cool. And you do too[1] if you agree with him. But, to keep on theme, this is a brain worm. (and since we're on a Scott Alexander post, I'll tie this into the broader theme of rationalism) And it's a brain worm that I think a lot of people who otherwise think they're rational/rationalist fall for. The conventional wisdom is, usually, mostly right. Not always all the way right, and sometimes really wrong. But usually, it's most of the way there. This makes alternate modes of thinking really boring, because despite all the fancy self-reflection and attempts to be superior, you're going to draw relatively few conclusions that are all that different from the mainstream. So what's the point? Either you do all this work for a marginal gain, or...or...or, well what if the conventional wisdom is actually wrong a lot more often? What if the experts are misleading us? What if the experts fall into thinking traps that make them wrong all the time? We shouldn't just disregard the experts, we should actively distrust them and assume the opposite! This opens up lots of possibilities for cool ideas. Incredibly compelling narratives, narratives where you can say that everyone else was wrong, and you were right. You can be a hero, or at least feel like one. Outsmarting the experts is cool, and knowing things first is cool. It's cool. And the "problem" with this is that sometimes you'll be right. The government is spying on citizens illegally. Snowden was right. And Ivermectin might have a small effect on covid, and even cooler it might be due to worms! But there have been tons of quack covid cures (HCQ, bleach, silver, etc.) and not every conspiracy theory about the government is true, even if the narrative would be cooler, because we distrust the government and the profit motives of these corporations, and that makes us want to distrust everything they do. But the world is more boring than that, and even though the contrary opinion is true sometimes, usually it isn't. [1]: Another, potentially equally compelling take here is that Scott's presentation here has allowed you to change your mind without admitting (even to yourself) that you were wrong! Because as he presents it, you weren't "wrong". We really, really dislike doing that, but this way you don't have to. The data did/does show an an effect for Ivermectin. You were right. That the effect was due to a "global" confounding factor allows you to change your conclusion without admitting that you were wrong in how you did the analysis. Like, whether or not you were wrong, the people who disagreed with you were right: it's unlikely that it would be helpful for your mother or whomever to take Ivermectin. The rational thing to do here would be to update your priors to trust the "experts" a bit more, perhaps their expert analysis that you weren't willing to believe before, had some truth to it, even though you don't know precisely how or why they reached that conclusion!
- bayesian_horse 5y agoNope, it's not against the medical misinformation policy. But that's a fine point in that case. And most people who talk about these studies will violate the policy by a wide margin, rather than doing a well rounded analysis. You can't deliberately encourage people to take Ivermectin. But JUST citing a study wouldn't do that. Especially not with all the debunking of the other stuff.
- roenxi 5y ago> Nope, it's not against the medical misinformation policy. "I have reviewed these studies, they seem sound and there are no real downsides to taking Ivermectin. I can't think of any reason not to take it. I don't recommend taking it, maybe I haven't thought of something" is a position a reasonable person could come to after browsing through the available evidence. Are you absolutely sure a video like that would be kosher on YouTube? It sounds extremely disingenuous to me, just typing it out.
- bayesian_horse 5y agoBut most of them aren't sound. Those that aren't are still weak evidence and not really block-buster. Also, "there are no real downsides" is misinformation. If you let on that you are an expert when you aren't, and say "I reviewed them" then that's misinformation. Some is in the gray area, but even the gray area actually causes the kind of harm these policies try to prevent. I can't speak for Youtube, but that's my take.
- kragen 5y agoThere really are no real downsides to taking ivermectin at its usual therapeutic doses. I'm not an expert, but ivermectin is well enough understood that I don't need to be an expert to know that. That's why there are regularly ivermectin programs that dose literally every single person in a town with ivermectin for a month or so as a parasite extermination campaign. (I have somewhat less confidence in my second opinion about ivermectin, which is that precisely because it's so safe, it's vanishingly unlikely to have antiviral effects at those doses. That's something I could easily be wrong about because I'm not an expert.)
- jacquesm 5y ago> Now it turns out, laughably in hindsight, that the effect is probably whether people had parasites or not and I hadn't thought of that. No, that's just a hypothesis. To move that to 'probably' would require a very carefully designed study.
- kaba0 5y agoNull hypothesis should be that it doesn’t work.
- jacquesm 5y agoExactly. But all we have a slew of low grade anecdata masquerading as studies and a very large machine magnifying that into 'cheap miracle cure suppressed by MSM and big pharma'.
- afiori 5y agoGiven that it is already an antiparassitic drug the null hypotesys should be that it is "only" an antiparassitic drug
- jacquesm 5y agoNo, that is not how this works.