4 ms·
How do you police what your imports import? Serious question. Let's say I'm building a Discord app (as I want to do.) Well, either NPM or Python PIP to get one
by HWR_14 5y ago
How do you police what your imports import? Serious question. Let's say I'm building a Discord app (as I want to do.) Well, either NPM or Python PIP to get one module - the discord module. But who knows how safe what it imports is. That's the point.
Are there stable dependencies from reputable companies that do the things I want without me vetting 10k submodule imports?
- skinkestek 5y agoI somewhat naively assume that at least if I use plain React or Angular then - someone at Facebook or Google has vetted the dependcy graph for those - I also assume they have internal Snyk-like tools - I also assume other users have similar tools so someone should catch it. When it comes to anything else I often look into what it pulls in. Also I keep an eye on the yarn.lock-file in pull requests.
- ptx 5y agoThis requires that you're pulling in only exactly the same versions of those dependencies as those that Facebook and Google have vetted. Is there a way to do that?
- filoeleven 5y ago> so someone should catch it. Just a week or two ago, a malicious NPM package was published which, for the hour or so that it was up, would be pulled in by any installation of create-react-app, since somewhere in the dependency tree it was specified with “^” to allow for minor updates. Any machine that ran “npm -i” with CRA or who knows how many other projects during that hour may have compromised credentials. 1 hour to find and unpublish the malicious package is a fast turnaround time, so someone was watching and that’s great. But any NPM tree that includes anything other than fully-specified and locked versions all the way down the tree is just waiting for the next shoe to drop.
- HWR_14 5y agoSo my specific usecase (write a Discord bot) has the solution of "write everything from scratch" or "don't use JS"? That's kinda what I assumed, but "only run code that have been signed off on by a major company" is kinda a shitty solution.
- grey-area 5y agoIt may require picking a different language with a different culture. JS badly needs a more capable standard library.
- tempodox 5y agoThat's the crux of the matter. Server-side you can, and should, choose a different platform than Node.js but for the browser we're all stuck with JS. A more capable standard library, where vetting everything would be much more feasible, would do much to improve the situation.