3 ms·
Here's an interesting observation, if a bit dangerous for my karma: On average a succefull media outlet is serving the interest of its audience, otherwise audi
by DenisM 18y ago
Here's an interesting observation, if a bit dangerous for my karma:
On average a succefull media outlet is serving the interest of its audience, otherwise audience will leave and the new one may never come. So you have Fox News with republican audience that only shows them the news and views they want to see. Then there is some similar liberal news outlet that is also careful not to expose the users to an uncomfortable thought. In some sense this is an "Innovator's Dilemma, media edition" - the customers hold producers hostage by using their consumption preferences.
So where am I going with this? There is a distinct flavor of media that is railing against "management". Dilbert being the flag and the articles like the one linked is the rank and file. The article is pretty much devoid of content and is full of emotional appeal to anymosity against "them" and affinity with "us, the sane folks". Just like the previously mentioned political "news" media.
In other words when reading your favorite rant you are reading the content of your own head, as best guessed by the author and selected by your filters.
Most of the time you are reading yourself.
...no mushrooms were hurt in production of this message...
- wynand 18y agoI grant that we read what we want to believe, but this is true of everything, whether true or false. I can't convince you that the article is not thin other than pointing out that most writing is about communicating a handful of (and often just one or two) elaborated ideas.
- DenisM 18y agoThat's fine but this idea was better communicated by simply pointing to the original piece - Feynman's speech. This article was a rehash of Feynman's speech plus a lot of "managers do this, down with managers!". Ironically in its blanket unqualified assertions the article itself is what it complains about - junk science.
- seregine 18y agoMost of the time you are reading yourself. That's only true if most of what you read is boring.
- ojbyrne 18y agoI have found in myself, that I tend to champion the ideas of the last book I read - i.e. I'm easily convinced and over-enthusiastic. But at least I am aware of that.
- Herring 18y agoProtip: if you choose to criticize something, don't say it's devoid of content then write up a long ad hom.