6 ms·
Interesting decision. In practice I don't think this will change a lot, because it's been years since Slashdot was primarily the personal project of Malda; from
by _delirium 15y ago
Interesting decision. In practice I don't think this will change a lot, because it's been years since Slashdot was primarily the personal project of Malda; from what I can tell, he's been "just another editor" and a bit withdrawn from the decision-making for a few years now. But I can see wanting to do something else.
For all its downsides, Slashdot is a quite interesting experiment imo.
In terms of form: It was one of the first (the first?) widely read tech blogs, in the sense of something that posted about technology in reverse chronological order, with a comments section below it (the comments section was even threaded). The idea of having users submit stories and write blurbs was also fairly novel, and has led to several different directions. Kuro5hin and MetaFilter took it in one direction, expanding from blurbs to more general kinds of article submissions (and Kuro5hin switched to voting rather than editorial curation), while Reddit/Digg/HN took it in the opposite direction, paring it down to link submissions with no blurb (again with voting).
In terms of content, imo it was a main way, especially in the late 90s, that a generation of tech people were introduced to things like the EFF, free software, problems of software patents, driver support for Linux, hardware hackability, and other such techno-liberty type things. Those predated Slashdot, of course, but it sort of crystallized a community on the web, alongside those that had previously been organized mainly around mailing lists, Usenet, etc. It also gained considerable mindshare for those ideas from a broader set of readers who weren't necessarily "activists".
- sjs382 15y agoGod, I miss K5...
- kahawe 15y agoMe too... they had some of the strangest and freaked-out submissions there. I don't know any substitute for it on today's internet. Last time I went to the website I was surprised it was still online and I felt really sad when I realized the frontpage submissions were weeks old. I feel old now, missing the 90s pre-bubble internet and I am sad I was just a few years too late to that party back then. sigh
- gte910h 15y agoThe day it dawned on me that the way you pronounced k5 was "corrosion" my mind was blown.
- ekanes 15y agoHeh. Annnnd you just blew mine. I always thought it was "Kooroshin"
- zem 15y agometafilter is the closest thing i've seen to k5 in terms of the kind of writing the community encouraged
- dholowiski 15y agoI once had something I wrote on the front page... that was crazy. Remember how you would submit a post for editing first, and let the grammar geeks fix every little thing first? And you didn't just post a link to a blog post, you wrote the whole thing right there, on the site, the longer the better. I just looked for a link, but apparently my stories are too old, and are gone, and my last diary post was 2004. Anyone know where you can go to find that kind of community nowadays?
- nl 15y agoWhat happened to K5? I was one of the "cool kids" who switched from Slashdot to K5 back when it started (back then we had 3 digit K5 id numbers, now we have Klout scores) I stopped visiting it, but I am curious why it seems to have half died, but is still running. What's the story there?
- _delirium 15y agoI think people just lost interest, mixture of the community losing interest and the founder losing interest. The rise of blogs didn't help, I don't think: many of the people who in 1999-2004 would've written an article to submit to Kuro5hin would today prefer to post it on their own blog and just submit links to places like HN/Reddit. That has the advantage of letting you "own" your writing, to build a personal brand, perhaps monetize it, etc.; but it does result imo in a bit less of a community aspect.
- nl 15y agoIt's funny because K5 diaries were one of the very early blog implementations.
- hemos 15y agoK5 was interesting to me, and I actually was the one who negotiated an ad deal between Andover and Rusty to help him with money for the first couple years. K5 had very much the same feel as Everything2 which was the "other" site to Slashdot that the original krewe did. E2 still has a tight community with numerous marriages, people still talking. I think the problem with K5 is that become too self-referential, and ultimately people lost interest. That was the same thing with E2 -- while people for a time loved being part of the community at some point you have to start to do other things in life and the time commitment drops away.
- hemos 15y agoK5 was interesting to me, and I actually was the one who negotiated an ad deal between Andover and Rusty to help him with money for the first couple years. K5 had very much the same feel as Everything2 which was the "other" site to Slashdot that the original krewe did. E2 still has a tight community with numerous marriages, people still talking. I think the problem with K5 is that become too self-referential, and ultimately people lost interest. That was the same thing with E2 -- while people for a time loved being part of the community at some point you have to start to do other things in life and the time commitment drops away.
- dholowiski 15y agoYeah, that was possibly the best site ever. Back when it went downhill all the people jumpt over to hulver.com but I left around that time. People talk about community, but that site was a _real_ community. Anyone remember the year we did a secret santa gift exchange?
- morsch 15y agoNot only were the comments threaded, they also had an elaborate moderation and karma system in-place that still works very well. (With meta-moderation, to boot.) I often browse Slashdot at +5 to get a quick overview of the discussion. If there something interesting going on, it's easy to drill down and see the less popular posts and counterpoints related to the +5 post. I think it's a great compromise: Get karma, you get a slight, but not overpowering, visibility boost. Lose karma or post anonymous, and you get a slight, but not overpowering, visibility malus. Capping the range of post ratings at -1 and 5 ensures that nothing ever truly gets voted into oblivion. Oh yes, and you can post anonymous -- even when logged in! How cool is that.
- MostAwesomeDude 15y agoI honestly believe that Slashdot was one of the first sites to Get it Right with regards to content moderation, and continued to get it right even while sites like Digg were struggling to figure out how to handle users being dicks to each other. Rob will be missed.
- jdp23 15y agoAgreed, Slashdot's moderation/karma/meta-moderation remains state-of-the art -- nobody else I'm aware of comes close to it.
- Pinckney 15y agoAnd you can modify comment scores by moderation reason, to boost e.g. informative comments while hiding e.g. funny ones, if you want to read a more serious discussion.
- hemos 15y agoThe moderation system is one of the things Rob and I are most proud of. We set out to make a system that would allow for anonymous postings while avoiding it turning into Usenet. I think, with some hiccups, we largely succeeded. We also took careful steps to make sure that we get anonymized all the data; all the IPs and subnets are hashed, so even we can't go back and find the real IP while still having something to work with.