4 ms·
Randall Munroe has a strip about how all the math most people need is how to fairly split a bill for a birthday dinner (so that the guest of honor doesn't pay).
by hinkley 5y ago
Randall Munroe has a strip about how all the math most people need is how to fairly split a bill for a birthday dinner (so that the guest of honor doesn't pay).
I sometimes wonder if we'd be better off telling teenagers that the motivation they need to learn math is self-preservation. There are always people who are going to try to trick you with bad math (from misleading cost/benefit analysis, to financial malfeasance, to bad faith public policy debates) and if you know some math they can't do that to you.
The "you give Timmy five apples" shtick is almost anathema to that. You've practically built a narrative for the kid to get distracted from the point of the exercise. I don't like Timmy, or I don't know who the hell Timmy is. I'm not giving him five of my apples. Timmy can go fuck himself. Get your own damn apples.
Better: you put twenty skittles into a cup. You drop the cup, and there are only 5 skittles left in the cup. How many are on the floor/how many do you need to replace the lost ones?
- emodendroket 5y agoThat would seem to imply that there's little point in learning algebra, let alone anything more advanced than that.
- smegger001 5y agowell to be fair i have never had to find the area under a curve, and have had to use the quadratic formula like once. and never had to find the log^10 of anything I use arithmetic logic and geometry and occasionally some basic statistics.
- zamadatix 5y agoFor most people there is little point in doing so from a "I really benefitted from knowing how to use this actual math" perspective. Fantastic for expanding reasoning and logical thinking capabilities, being able to come up with ways to reason about previously unseen logical problems from experience on learning how to solve many others previously. Not because finding a particular angle in an irregular nonagon from some other measures will be useful math to know itself.
- quinnjh 5y agoI recall in my algebra classes students being exasperated and asking repeatedly what if anything this has to do with any real world application. The answer was always "theres a lot of applications if you get a math job" to which we all groaned imagining counting cups of skittles and mentally dividing while the computers sat idle...
- late2part 5y agoTimmy's actually pretty cool. I'd recommend you give him a chance. Plus he tends to return more apples than you give him.
- BLKNSLVR 5y agoClassic "lies, damn lies, and statistics". I need to start collecting examples of conclusions drawn from incomplete and / or poorly explained statistics. I did three levels of statistics, and found it boring because I struggled to find how it would be useful in my future career. I'm eternally annoyed at myself for not paying enough attention, I love stats now. One interesting (and divisive) example for statistics was way early in the COVID timeline the talk about reaching herd immunity through "just letting it propagate" as per the narrative around Sweden's approach. The required herd immunity figure was something like 60%[0] at the lowest end. In the US daily new infections peaked in January 2021 at 305,000[1], and the US population is around 330 million[2] (with 60% being 198 million). At that maximum rate of new daily infections, it would take 649 days (1.77 years) to reach herd immunity. The average daily new infection rate from the 21st of March 2020 to the 15th of November 2021 is ~79,500. At that rate it would take 2,490 days (6.8 years) to reach herd immunity. In both of the above scenarios, with a fatality rate of 1%, there would be 1.98 million deaths during the time span. Other numbers that would be interesting in context: - Number of hospital beds - Number of ventilators, how quickly they can be manufactured, how long they're dedicated to an individual case (and bonus points for recovery rates of those who needed to use a ventilator) - Medical oxygen usage rate and availability (India had an issue with running out of medical grade oxygen[3], although it may not be as much of an issue for more countries with more advanced infrastructure) Thank fuck for medical technology and vaccine development (the age we live in!) [0]: https://www.sciencemediacentre.org/expert-comments-about-herd-immunity/ https://www.sciencemediacentre.org/expert-comments-about-her... [1]: https://www.worldometers.info/coronavirus/country/us/#graph-cases-daily https://www.worldometers.info/coronavirus/country/us/#graph-... [2]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Demographics_of_the_United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Demographics_of_the_United_Sta... [3]: https://www.theguardian.com/world/2021/apr/29/explainer-why-is-getting-medical-oxygen-for-covid-patients-in-some-countries-so-difficult https://www.theguardian.com/world/2021/apr/29/explainer-why-...