3 ms·
In high school any other way would probably be borderline insane. If you somehow managed to skip trigonometry in high school but still got into college calculu
by tzs 5y ago
In high school any other way would probably be borderline insane.
If you somehow managed to skip trigonometry in high school but still got into college calculus, then there are a few of other ways they might be defined.
One way is to put off dealing with trig functions until you get to differential equations. Then sin is the unique solution of y'' + y = 0, y(0) = 0, y'(0) = 1, and cos is the unique solution of y'' + y = 0, y(0) = 1, y'(0) = 0.
Another way is to define them axiomatically. These are the axioms for sin and cos:
1. They are both defined everywhere on the real line,
2. cos(0) = sin(pi/2) = 1, cos(pi) = -1,
3. cos(y-x) = cos(y) cos(x) + sin(y) sin(x)
4. for 0 < x < pi/2, 0 < cos(x) < sin(x)/x < 1/cos(x).
From that you can deduce all the usual trig identities and the limits you need to do calculus with them.
You still need to prove that functions satisfying those 4 axioms actually exist. One approach is to put that off until later when you've got more tools under you belt. For example once you do Taylor series, you can work out what they Taylor series would be for sin and cos if they exist. The functions defined by those Taylor series do exist, so then you just need to show that those functions satisfy the axioms.
- jacobolus 5y agoThe reasonable ways to rigorously define sine and cosine functions (as functions) are: (1) (analytic continuations of) inverses of particular integrals (2) the sums of particular power series (3) solutions to a differential equation (4) as odd/even parts of the complex exponential, itself defined via (1), (2), or (3). Proving that these are all equivalent is a good exercise for a complex analysis student. But all of these require calculus and quite a lot of hand waving about real numbers and limits and infinite sums, especially in a high school context. And most of their applications (per se) are pretty advanced. At the high school level it’s probably best to explain that angle measure per se is a very tricky concept (an angle measure is a type of logarithm). We can get a very long way without ever having any explicit "angle measure" concept. E.g. there are no angle measures anywhere in Euclid’s Elements. (Angle measures come from astronomy and navigation.) We can look at the complex coordinates of 2D rotations (points on the complex unit circle) without ever trying to turn that into a single scalar-valued quantity. And should do that in a lot of circumstances where angle measures are currently used. In e.g. geometric simulations (computer graphics, robotics, computational geometry, ...) it’s best to avoid angle measures as much as possible, and stick to vector algebra.
- sudosysgen 5y agoYou don't need logarithms for angle measures. Arcs of circles work pretty well too.
- jacobolus 5y agoMeasuring arclength (in mathematics) requires calculus: that is, you need to take ∫|ds| = ∫√(dx² + dy²) or similar. It is inherently a tricky advanced concept which can’t be discussed in any precise way until after at least one calculus course. An angle measure "is" a logarithm of a planar rotation with the orientation stripped away. That is, the structure of angle measures is isomorphic to these logarithms. (Planar rotations are most naturally represented by a quantity like a + Ib, where I is a unit bivector and a and b are scalars with a² + b² = 1.) Logarithms need comparable amounts of technical machinery to define as arclengths, so there’s no difficulty advantage in considering an angle measure to be an arc length or the area of a sector instead of a kind of logarithm. Conceiving of a logarithm of a rotation as being the same quantity as the area of the associated circular sector can be a helpful mental picture though (and there is no need to even strip out the bivector’s orientation if you use an area).
- sudosysgen 5y agoI fear you may be overcomplicating the matter. If you want to measure an angle on the plane defined by two lines, simply form a circle of a radius one and take the ratio of the length of the arc at the angle to total circumference. You can calculate the length of an arc associated to a triangle by simple comparison to a known angle such as the quarter angle and its products, this will allow you to finitely compute any rational angle. This is the conceptual basis for using arclengths. To formalize this, you can define trigonometric functions now, and you can use them to introduce polar coordinates, and by translation of the intersection to the origin, show that you can calculate the angle for all real numbers by construction of a right angle triangle and now determine the sine as the ratio of two real numbers, etc... It is wholly unnecessary to introduce logarithms. Yes they are isomorphic. They are also unnecessary. So are bivectors. Angles are perfectly well defined without anything but basic algebra and some geometry. You really just need an extensible definition of the trigonometric functions to provide rotation and you've got yourself a perfectly sound definition.
- nyanpasu64 5y agoI would much rather derive the sum-difference identities from the expansion of e^(i (a+b)), than treat the arbitrary-seeming sum-difference identities as axiomatic.