4 ms·
> IBM Quantum System Two is designed to work with IBM's future 433-qubit and 1,121 qubit processors. what's the smallest useful (as in, 'non-toy', or maybe 'wo
by baq 5y ago
> IBM Quantum System Two is designed to work with IBM's future 433-qubit and 1,121 qubit processors.
what's the smallest useful (as in, 'non-toy', or maybe 'worth buying time on') quantum computer?
- xxpor 5y agoWhy 433 and 1121? In classical computers, everyone knows why a lot of things are done in powers of 2. Is there a different base number useful for quantum computation that I don't know about (for example, is this an integer multiple of a specific sin/cos value)?
- krastanov 5y agoNot really. For this particular device they are laying out the physical qubits in some geometric lattice constrained by where they can put traces for microwave inductors and capacitors, and it just happens that this is the convenient size at which to try to build the lattice.
- snarkypixel 5y agoA real random number generator, this is basically the "hello world" on a quantum computer.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- krastanov 5y agoIf you are a researcher from another field that just wants to contract out the computation of a numerical solution to some chemistry problem infeasible on a classical supercomputer, a million "physical" qubits is a fairly reasonable guestimate. If you are a quantum computation person developing near term applications, you probably would already start getting excited with a 100 (sufficiently long-lived) qubits. The "sufficiently long-lived" is the problematic part. Every lab has its own bespoke figure of merit (quantum volume, CLOPS, fidelities, etc). It is basically impossible to compare devices without being a researcher in the field for now. But at some point a novel drug or material will be developed thanks to a quantum computer and then we should really get excited about renting time on these devices.
- mchusma 5y agoIs it accurate to say the primary use of this is likely to design further quantum computers?
- krastanov 5y agoIn a way, yes. I usually call such devices "technology demonstrators". But I am certain there would be researchers offended by such a trivialization of their work.
- haneefmubarak 5y agoYeah the R&D that goes into this is mainly part of the longer term effort to make increasingly large quantum computers. In case you meant it the other way: the number of qubits here is still far too small for any real world application, including for simulations that would help design larger chips.
- PeterisP 5y agoWhat near term applications would be possible with just a 100 long-lived qubits?
- sz4kerto 5y agoFor example routing algorithms used to change railroad traffic in case of a problem with a junction or track.
- krastanov 5y agoWith long-lived ones, gosh, a ton. When you hear a researcher talk about "logical qubit" or less formally "long-lived qubit" they mean a reliable abstract computational component. When we talk about "physical qubits" we mean the unreliable real implementations like the one from this article. A rough rule of thumb is that you need a 1000 physical qubits to make one logical qubit. With 100 logical qubits (i.e. 100k physical qubits), you can start thinking about running chemistry simulations on the edge of what is possible with classical supercomputers. That is what I am excited about. There are also optimization problems, and some pretentious claims about quantum machine learning, which I am certain would be fun, but I am not as excited about. With 100 physical qubits, you can start testing non-trivial control schemes, circuit compilations, error correction methods, and many other building blocks.
- cgearhart 5y agoKinda depends on what you want to use it for. If you want to simulate a physical system then you need at least as many qubits as the system has (and an understanding that such a simulation will have terrible noise). If you want to do something “useful” like run Shor’s algorithm to factor large encryption keys then it would take millions of qubits and quantum error correction. To me the significance of this kind of increase in number of qubits is that many detractors of quantum computing had argued we’d never even reach this point, so I am slightly more optimistic that we’ll eventually reach the scale required for reliable abstract computations.
- bnjemian 5y agoIt depends on your use case. By some measure, the Google collaboration that demonstrated a time crystal was a practical quantum advantage in the space of condensed matter research. But in that space, practical means validating theory with experiment. That's a much lower bar for a quantum advantage than, say, showing that you've implemented a quantum algorithm that can, with high statistical likelihood (e.g. an error rate of 1/10e5), provide fleet routing solutions for a logistics company that are 10% more efficient than any known classical routing algorithm.