4 ms·
How much math have you studied? I think they are talking about grad level math courses where things starts to get really abstract. Calculus, linear algebra and
by Jensson 5y ago
How much math have you studied? I think they are talking about grad level math courses where things starts to get really abstract. Calculus, linear algebra and discrete math are all super concrete, pretty sure they are talking about things described as "generalized abstract nonsense": https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Abstract_nonsense https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Abstract_nonsense
Try reading the example on that page. That is what makes math hard. Not the way calculus is described.
- jeffreyrogers 5y agoI had a math minor in college and took some upper level analysis courses, so I know what abstract means in the context of higher mathematics. I wasn't talking about calculus.
- Jensson 5y agoBut how would you study abstract math without those abstractions? The math is just abstractions and nothing else, the abstractions are what you study, there is no concrete thing there to describe. So your original comment tells me you haven't studied a lot of very abstract math since you still want those explanations, but they stop existing after a point. > took some upper level analysis courses Real Analysis is still not very abstract, but yeah that is a step. The next step is to remove everything concrete about it and just study abstractions. And then you start studying abstractions of those abstractions, hence "abstract nonsense". Maybe sometimes in the future someone will invent abstractions of those. Edit: Meant the stuff you learn in Rudins principles of mathematical analysis. Not sure exactly what the course would be called in an English class, but I called it real analysis here.
- jeffreyrogers 5y ago> But how would you study abstract math without those abstractions? I'm not saying you would, I'm just saying the abstractions are directly related to why its harder. > since you still want those explanations, but they stop existing after a point. You're misunderstanding me. > The next step is to remove everything concrete about it and just study abstractions. And then you start studying abstractions of those abstractions, hence "abstract nonsense". Maybe sometimes in the future someone will invent abstractions of those. Yes, I understand all this. I have the textbooks and I've read parts of them. The reason I didn't study math more seriously (I considered it) is because I realized I didn't have the brain for it and am not that interested in studying really abstract stuff.
- agumonkey 5y agoWell they are concrete and not so much, for instance e being it's own derivative only started to make sense to me when I got the 'abtract algebraic' (fix point, neutral element, self similarity) thinking. Otherwise it was a fuzzy if not empty property.
- Jenk 5y ago> things described as "generalized abstract nonsense": https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Abstract_nonsense https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Abstract_nonsense > In mathematics, abstract nonsense, general abstract nonsense, generalized abstract nonsense, and general nonsense are terms used by mathematicians to describe abstract methods related to *category theory* and homological algebra. Oh so _that_ is why I can't understand Haskellers..
- m0lecules 5y agoOr try reading the ethereum yellow paper: https://ethereum.github.io/yellowpaper/paper.pdf https://ethereum.github.io/yellowpaper/paper.pdf When it gets into the symbolics of the ethereum state machine (section 4+), things get hairy fast. Unfortunately papers like this only make sense once you understand the paper. It's a succinct representation of knowledge for someone skilled in the field, but not a sensible way to teach others about the EVM.
- interroboink 5y ago> It's a succinct representation of knowledge for someone skilled in the field, but not a sensible way to teach others Sounds like manpages (:
- ben_w 5y agoLikewise; I still have no idea what a monoid or an endofunctor is, and my grasp of monads is only as deep as a short list of positive examples.
- hxksleo 5y agoIt's a mistake to just think of linear algebra as being super concrete. Linear algebra can be very theoretical. Obviously, there are a lot of categorical applications to linear algebra as well.