2 ms·
> It's not about sharing the "cost", it's sharing the risk. The "risk" is a high cost event. For insurance to work, there has to be winners and losers. The p
by cogman10 5y ago
> It's not about sharing the "cost", it's sharing the risk.
The "risk" is a high cost event.
For insurance to work, there has to be winners and losers. The price the losers pay isn't exactly fair to them, is it?
> If you are less risky and make a lot of money you won't get a higher premium than someone much more riskier and who doesn't make a lot of money.
Not how it works in the US (particularly with Obamacare regulations) the only risk profiles insurance companies are allowed to consider for health is age and smoking. Prior to Obamacare there were preconditions they could evaluate to offer different insurance premiums. Those are all out the door.
> Okay, but then what? Cross-subsidization is a inherently unfair practice.
And? I don't understand why it matters to be absolutely "fair" to the wealthy. The wealthy achieved their wealth by means of a great society powering their empires. Why is it a wrong to expect them to pay more to improve the society around them?
And, importantly, the US wouldn't be the first nation to do this. Progressive taxation exists in pretty much ever successful country. And, besides the US, all of those countries will have some form of Universal healthcare funded by that taxation.
- gruez 5y ago>For insurance to work, there has to be winners and losers. The price the losers pay isn't exactly fair to them, is it? Right, but there's a difference between you paying your expected value in costs (imperfect as it might be, because of the attributes insurance companies are allowed to consider), compared to you paying 3x the expected value on the basis of your income.