3 ms·
> I still think Eurisko is fascinating Note that Doug later wrote a paper “Why AM and Eurisko appear to work” (emphasis mine). People are still using semantic
by gumby 5y ago
> I still think Eurisko is fascinating
Note that Doug later wrote a paper “Why AM and Eurisko appear to work” (emphasis mine).
People are still using semantic KBs like OpenCyc for research.
> …confirmed or refuted the intuition that architecture isn’t enough, [that] we need to encode knowledge
For my position on this: I left the project for a number of reasons, but one fundamental one was that I perceived the corpus to be largely pointless (note the countervailing position above, in that people still get value from them today ).
Architecture alone is clearly inadequate as can be seen from the fragility / inadequacy of current systems, yes, including GPT-n. They remind me of things like the X-15: providing valuable data but ultimately not on the path to space flight.
Knowledge acquisition is ad hoc, and more importantly the graph connections are highly as hoc, but dependent on architecture and prior state. I no longer believe (perhaps I never did) that you can meaningfully have one and not the other.
After leaving Cyc I went into a different direction (e.g. Cygnus) and only returned to symbolic AI a few years ago working from a constructivist model. Unfortunately I had to step away from that work last year due to a more pressing problem. But I think it’s ultimately a more powerful approach.