3 ms·
I landed with poetry as well. The issue with python dependency managment in my book is, that it is incredibly (and needlessly) hard to learn how to do it proper
by atoav 5y ago
I landed with poetry as well. The issue with python dependency managment in my book is, that it is incredibly (and needlessly) hard to learn how to do it properly. It took me years to figure out how things should work and there are still issues now and then that cost me a few hours to figure out and restore things.
Meanwhile when I use Rust all these things are taken care of in cargo. It is part of the language. There is one right way to do things and the way is supported by comfortable tooling, that works so well that you literally don't even consider thinking about anything else.
The way python does dependencies is totally unpythonic. The fact that it is 2021 and this isn't fixed or at least the number one priority of things that need fixing sheds a dark shadow on the whole language – a language that I like to use.
Poetry is good. But it isn't as good as cargo, because it also has to deal with all the legacy cruft. To run code developed with poetry on a non-poetry system you have to figure out all the ways of dealing with envs, paths and such.
Issues like these get me a little fired up, because the collective brainpower wasted on something that should have been elegantly solved in one place is gigantic.
- jhrmnn 5y agoTo run code developed with Poetry, you shouldn’t even know it’s developed with Poetry. It should be released as a source distribution or a wheel on PyPI or as a conda package if it contains nontrivial binary extensions. These distributions should be then either packaged by the OS or they should be installed with all their dependencies into a separate virtual environment in /opt.
- atoav 5y agoSure, if I release the code I tend to do just that. However a lot of the code I have been writing was to be used on servers where installing poetry was not an option. That means there was no straightforward, well documented or otherwise easy way to copy the project onto the server an "just have it work". And this was not due to me not taking care of my dev environment. Now I know how to do this, so this is not a problem. My complaint was mostly, that this was a waste of time.