8 ms·
1632 by Eric Flint (2000)
- mikewarot 5y agoI think a lot of people here have already read, or would be interested in this book/series. There seemed to be a lot of questions about what would happen if the supply chain broke today... this series explores that issue in a deep way.
- throwaway10122 5y agoIt also got me interested in the 30 years war which i didnt realise was possibly even bloodier period than WW1 and 2 in europe for the populations impacted. He has another series in same premise with a modern cruise ship going back to ancient greek times, not as good as this series tho'. if anyone else has any other recommendations in same genre of time travel and re-booting up civilisation it be great to hear! I always found the genre interesting since Jules Verne's Mysterious Island https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/32831.The_Mysterious_Island https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/32831.The_Mysterious_Isl...
- dj_gitmo 5y agoI had no idea about this. Did Jules Verne really have to be the originator or every science fiction sub-genre? What a jerk.
- Apocryphon 5y agoHe was a contemporary of Edison’s. Perhaps both were future men, out of time…
- sanxiyn 5y ago> if anyone else has any other recommendations in same genre of time travel and re-booting up civilisation it be great to hear! The island of Nantucket goes back to the Bronze Age. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Island_in_the_Sea_of_Time https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Island_in_the_Sea_of_Time
- ghaff 5y agoYes, Stirling's Nantucket series is a good example. Loosely also his Emberverse (basically the flip side of the Nantucket series) although I lost interest as I often do with long-running series. Lucifer's Hammer by Niven and Pournelle. A Connecticut Yankee in King Arthur's Court is probably the classic of the genre (Mark Twain). Most of these books are probably overly optimistic about what one or a small group of smart people who just happen to have to right skill sets could accomplish in such a situation with very limited supply chains.
- bhaak 5y agoThe short story "The Man Who Came Early" by Poul Anderson touches on that theme as well. A soldier is transported back to Iceland of about the year 900 AD. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Man_Who_Came_Early https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Man_Who_Came_Early Another classic one is "Lest Darkness Fall" by L. Sprague de Camp in which an archaeologist is transported to Rome in the year 535 AD. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lest_Darkness_Fall https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lest_Darkness_Fall
- jwhitlark 5y agoDavid Drake wrote a sort of prequel to "Lest Darkness Fall" called "To Bring the Light", with an imperial Roman woman transported back to the founding of Rome. Drake's personal experiences increase the realism of his writing, IMO. He also wrote "Ranks of Bronze" which is sort of the reverse idea, a Roman Legion kidnapped by aliens for preindustrial warfare. Absolutely worth a read, and an interesting counterpoint to most of the 'bringing civilization to the barbarians' narrative these stories normally follow. H. Beam Piper did a bunch too, check out "Lord Kalvan of Otherwhen" if you can find it.
- coremoff 5y ago> if anyone else has any other recommendations in same genre of time travel and re-booting up civilisation There's a couple that I know of: https://www.goodreads.com/series/40821-belisarius https://www.goodreads.com/series/40821-belisarius https://www.goodreads.com/search?q=safehold&qid= https://www.goodreads.com/search?q=safehold&qid= Flint was involved in the Belisarius series (along with David Drake), and Safehold is basically Weber's "reboot" of one of the books in his "Armageddon Moon" series. If you liked 1632 you will probably like these as they're in a similar vein
- spiralx 5y agoI've been reading these for a while now and they're a genuinely great exploration of 17th century European cultural, religious, political and scientific ideas as well as a fascinating take on how the 20th century would fare in that situation. How would the 1911 Encyclopedia Brittanica affect the lives of those people featured in it? How would the Catholic Church deal with the changes in Vatican II? What effects would radio and antibiotics have on society? How would the Bach family react to discovering the complete works of a man who wouldn't have been born for another half century? The Grantville Gazette publishes short stories set in the world by other authors, there's in fact a master character list where authors can "check out" characters to ensure consistency. It also has technical articles on subjects such as building aircraft using 17th century techniques, how to build radios that are effective during the Maunder Minimum or how to synthesise different primers in order to manufacture cartridge ammunition.
- panzagl 5y agoIs there a 'main thread' through the books? I read the first book, but then, like the Honor Harrington series, it seems to split into more offshoots than I care to tackle.
- derefr 5y agoDon't know about this series in particular, but the Harrington series does have a "main thread", and is intentionally written† to not interdepend; the mainline sequence of books by Drake make some references to things happening in the other series, but the books don't expect/require you to have read those series (i.e. the books reintroduce any characters and events that happened in those series that are relevant to the current plot.) † I find the logic of this series-splitting very interesting; David Drake seems to license out his setting for the creation of, essentially, fanfiction, but fanfiction where he sits in as creative consultant. So other authors create stories in his setting, and he declares them canon. But, since those stories are not his stories — not created as part of his original series planning — the later novels in the mainline series aren't planned to take these side-sequences into account, but rather just have references to those side-sequences worked in in non-arc-damaging ways as the series allows. Almost like the characters and events from the ascended fanfic are "guest starring" in the main series, as a reward to the audience for reading those side-series and a semi "seal of quality" nod by Drake toward those series. This isn't a practice I've ever seen anywhere else. The closest might be simultaneously-running TV dramas with different writing teams who lend one-another characters (and their actors) for crossovers, with each writing team acting as the creative consultant for how that character is written by the other team. But even then, there isn't a hierarchical relationship between the two teams, as both teams own their own setting. Also, this setup usually implies that the dramas to be owned by the same production studio. What Drake does with his settings, is more like when franchise with a valuable IP licenses that IP out for the creation of "licensed" works in adjacent media, on the condition that they sit in as creative consultant for how their IP is being used. E.g. when some random game studio decides to make "a Spiderman game." Except in this case, the IP isn't all that valuable, just an inspiring setting for other authors; and the licensed works aren't in an adjacent medium, but rather also in the original medium, such that they almost "blend in" with the original works. It's be as if Star Wars were primarily a novel series, but then the various Star Wars Extended Universe licensed novels were still a thing.
- hoseja 5y agoI'm still sad Rome Sweet Rome fizzled out.
- tomcam 5y agoI still reread it occasionally. Electrifying. For those who missed it: https://www.reddit.com/r/AskReddit/comments/k067x/could_i_destroy_the_entire_roman_empire_during/c2giwm4/ https://www.reddit.com/r/AskReddit/comments/k067x/could_i_de...
- Apocryphon 5y agoPax Romana finished but also didn’t amount to much. Great setup and art though: https://imagecomics.com/comics/series/pax-romana-1 https://imagecomics.com/comics/series/pax-romana-1
- Adam_36 5y agoThanks for the update. I'll be sure to keep an eye on this thread. https://www.advancedmd.ltd/ https://www.advancedmd.ltd/
- bayesian_horse 5y agoAuthors in the 1632 series have a very optimistic view of capitalism. Also very little understanding of the German language, which is explained away by the creation of "Amideutsch". In the real world, "Amideutsch" wasn't nearly as bad and while Germans readily take up English words, they aren't that malleable when it comes to grammatical mistakes/changes. Especially adults probably wouldn't form that kind of creole and there aren't enough American children to make that much of a difference... The series helped me think more deeply about the history of Europe, also other parts of the World. There are now stories about China, India, the Americas, probably other places I am forgetting right now.
- irishsultan 5y ago> In the real world, "Amideutsch" wasn't nearly as bad In the real world Germans already were on a technological comparable level to the Americans. Not to mention that by the 1940s the German language had already been much more standardized than it would have been in 1632, one big reason mentioned in the books that boosted "Amideutsch" was the fact that there was no "German" language that all German immigrants to Grantville/Magdeburg could fall back to.
- bayesian_horse 5y agoI can easily read and understand most texts from that period. It does feel and sound "old". The grammar is pretty much identical. It's sometimes difficult to distinguish between a grammatical error and a grammatical "difference to the standard", for example in a dialect or even Creole language. But if it hurts a native speaker, it may very well be a mistake.
- irishsultan 5y agoI don't entirely disagree on whether the German in the books is bad, I definitely notice issues when they have someone speaking in Dutch. It's just that I don't see how you could compare amideutsch (1632) with amideutsch (real world).
- aardvark179 5y agoNot passing any judgment on the books themselves, but that web page makes me want to run a mile. “At that moment Freedom and Justice, American style, are introduced to the middle of The Thirty Years War.” It all feels a little too like A Connecticut Yankee in King Arthur's Court but not written as a burlesque.
- throwanem 5y agoAs with durian, nattō, and many others in Baen's stable, Eric Flint is very much an acquired taste.
- mherdeg 5y agoI wonder how much overlap there is in fan base between Flint and his occasional collaborator David Weber? I've read all the Honor Harrington books/stories and basically nothing else by either of them. Every now and then I read the phpbb forums (forums.davidweber.net) because it's interesting to see conversations by people who have a pretty different worldview than me. Seems like pretty nice folks.
- fmajid 5y agoI have no issues with Eric Flint or David Weber (although I find Flint's infatuation with Gustavus Adolphus quite bizarre). The one author whose book I just set down because it made want to puke was one by John Ringo (it was an ARC, don't worry, no money of mine went into his pocket).
- throwanem 5y agoAs a historiographer, Flint makes a solid writer. As a writer, Weber makes a solid historiographer.
- spiralx 5y agoI read this review of one of John Ringo's series some years back and have never been tempted to read anything by him - the review is hilarious, the books sound absolutely fucking awful. https://hradzka.livejournal.com/194753.html https://hradzka.livejournal.com/194753.html This review even coined the meme "OH JOHN RINGO NO" lol.
- eru 5y agoI grew up in and around Magdeburg, a city that plays a large role in the book(s). It's interesting that they've never been translated into German.
- CRConrad 5y agoMy main memory of Magdeburg: Best hotel breakfast I've ever had. Holiday Inn, I believe. Not necessarily so any more: This was in 2007.
- JasonFruit 5y agoHistory, time travel, and rednecks doing liberty shit? Sign me up!
- zeckalpha 5y agoIf you like this you may like The Watch, by Dennis Danvers. Peter Kropotkin ends up in Virginia in 1999… https://www.kirkusreviews.com/book-reviews/dennis-danvers/the-watch/ https://www.kirkusreviews.com/book-reviews/dennis-danvers/th...
- Aaargh20318 5y agoAnother series in the same vein is the Safehold series by David Weber: https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/72199.Off_Armageddon_Reef https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/72199.Off_Armageddon_Ree...
- ThrowawayR2 5y agoSafehold was decent but kind of drags towards the end. "Oh, no, if us bad guys lose these huge armies, our treasury will be dry and we'll collapse!", then at the start of the next volume, "We lost those armies, which we already couldn't afford, but we somehow managed to scrape up an even huger army than last time that are even better armed and this time, if we lose them too, no honest, our treasury will be dry and we'll collapse, totally for real this time!"; lather, rinse, repeat.
- Aaargh20318 5y agoThat seems to be a problem with a lot of these series. They usually start out good but they drag on and on. The story gets stretched out over too many books and it never gets to a satisfying end. It kills the pacing and makes me burn out on a series. Nowadays I won't even start a series if I see it has that many books without showing any signs of coming to an end. At some point I want to have some closure. Ideally a series has 5 books max, 3 or 4 would be ideal.
- CRConrad 5y ago> That seems to be a problem with a lot of these series. They usually start out good but they drag on and on. The story gets stretched out over too many books and it never gets to a satisfying end. It kills the pacing and makes me burn out on a series. Hello, Wheeel of Time. Hello, A Song of Ice and Fire. Let's see if Martin pulls a Jordan.
- strenholme 5y agoThis book is available in a bunch of e-book formats as a free download: https://www.baen.com/1632.html https://www.baen.com/1632.html There’s also an updated version of the book one can buy on the same website. Baen is a good source of science fiction and fantasy which, as often as not, has a conservative military slant to it. May not be everyone’s taste, but I also greatly enjoy reading Orson Scott Card who has a conservative (but not fundamentalist) religious slant to his stories.
- rmah 5y agoThis book is definitely an example where judging a book by its cover leads to very wrong conclusions. The cover looks silly and implies amateurly written dreck. But it's actually very well written. Interesting premise and gripping plot with compelling characters. Even a few surprises. It's a great book and one of the best of the genre, IMO. I highly recommend reading it.
- JPKab 5y agoLooking forward to reading it. My family on both sides come from West Virginia, and interestingly, all of Appalachia was settled by people fleeing the various religious wars in Europe in that time. Specifically, Appalachia was settled mostly by refugees from Ulster (primarily the Scots-Irish Presbyterians and other non-Anglican protestants who found themselves isolated in northern Ireland) and a smaller percentage of the settlers were Protestants fleeing the aftermath of the 30 years war in Germany. My family's ancestry reflects this. The echoes of those wars still carry on in the culture there. What was then known as Presbyterian (virtually zero relation to the current Presbyterian faith, and far more in line with evangelical Christians today) at the time shaped the culture to be hugely antagonistic to all forms of central authority. The Scots-Irish were particularly antagonistic to the British monarchy due to them being used to secure northern Ireland, and then in decades following being isolated from society due to laws treating non-Anglicans as second class citizens. The part of history I want to learn far more about is the 30 years war in Germany. My lack of knowledge on this subject was particularly embarrassing when I last went to Prague and was looking at the former seat of power for the Holy Roman Empire (one of many, since the capital shifted over the years to various cities). I had very little historical context for that part of Europe, which was frustrating.
- cafard 5y agoI think it is incorrect to describe the Scots-Irish as refugees. They mostly had some capital, didn't they? Also, I think that Albion' Seed suggested that the Scots-Irish emigration was much outnumbered by the entirely Scots emigration.
- 5y ago
- alex_stoddard 5y agoAnother very entertaining series, with a much more SF bent, by Eric Flint, with Ryk E. Spoor is kicked of by the freely available 'Boundary'. https://www.baen.com/boundary.html https://www.baen.com/boundary.html (Like 1632 it also has a dreadful cover - actively despised by Ryk I believe).
- boojums 5y agoThe premise of the book is interesting, but I do not enjoy Eric Flint's prose or characterization. If you liked 1632 you may also like Belisarious [0] by David Drake and Eric Flint which has a similar feel set in the Eastern Roman Empire. [0] https://www.baen.com/belisarius-i-thunder-at-dawn.html https://www.baen.com/belisarius-i-thunder-at-dawn.html